“One thing, however, is certain. Although we may never know with complete certainty the identity of the winner of this year's presidential election, the identity of the loser is perfectly clear. It is the nation's confidence in the judge as an impartial guardian of the rule of law.” - Justice John Paul Stevens (Ironically an activist judge)
In politics, just like in life, many individuals' beliefs and views are based on emotions and false preconceived notions instead of facts and statistics. These views can cause problems throughout society, but when these individuals who belief in falsehoods elect like-minded politicians to enact policies that control countries, states, and localities, society as a whole is punished for the voters’ lack of knowledge. To inform the well-intentioned but misguided populace is as great a public service as any.
Disinformation runs rampant in pop culture, whether you get it from liberal Hollywood on television and movies, to biased media outlets, or it could be learned as one of the many falsehoods and false narratives taught in schools (either intentionally by biased textbooks and teachers or unintentionally through lessons which give abbreviated drive-by summaries of complex issues and events).
A portion of the voting populace votes based on single issues or on singular categorical issues. Examples of this would be gays voting for only candidates who support gay marriage; or perhaps some church going folks only voting for candidates who oppose gay marriage and abortion. I don’t want to criticize people for strong beliefs and convictions; I, myself, have many. However, recklessly voting for candidates for such isolated issues is dangerous. What if the gay voter in the first example voted for his pro gay marriage candidate despite the fact that the candidate also supported terrible policies such as an open (unsecured) border, supported the largest tax increase in history, and pushing shady union deals that’ll hurt businesses, eliminate private ballots for union organizing, and burden state budgets with debt.
Perhaps the socially conservative voter elected politicians who are personally socially conservative, but accomplish nothing towards that goal and in fact help double the size of government and double the national debt. Obviously those two voters elected politicians who they agree with on at least one issue that’s important to them, but at what cost? I included the examples of those specific drawbacks because those exact politicians exist… in great numbers. Most democrats support gay marriage and are pro abortion, while most republicans oppose gay marriage and are pro life. However, anyone who casts a straight ticket vote for all democrats or all republicans is voting for a number of politicians who have no say on that issue. Your county council, school board, city council don’t legislate on those issues. Nationally and statewide, there is more that can be done to effect those issues; but generally not to the degree that most voters expect and believe. An issue that was considered under the Clinton Administration was a partial birth abortion ban. That was entirely possible, but an all out ban on abortion is currently impossible. States can legislate how late someone can have an abortion, but also cannot currently ban abortions. If you are a one issue voter primarily based on these issues, its probably high time you learn about other issues.
Proponents of gay marriage view the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) essentially the same way that pro life advocates view the Roe v Wade Supreme Court decision. DOMA was authored by then Congressman Bob Barr R-GA, and signed into law by President Bill Clinton in 1996. The bill federally defines marriage as between a man and a woman and also prevents states from having to legally recognize same-sex marriages having taken place in a state in which same-sex marriages are legal. Bob Barr, since then, has left the republican party and is now a member of the libertarian party, and ran in 2008 as their presidential candidate. In 2009, Bob Barr wrote an op-ed in the Los Angeles Times which said, “I have concluded that DOMA is neither meeting the principles of federalism it was supposed to, nor is its impact limited to federal law. In effect, DOMA's language reflects one-way federalism: It protects only those states that don't want to accept a same-sex marriage granted by another state. Moreover, the heterosexual definition of marriage for purposes of federal laws -- including, immigration, Social Security survivor rights and veteran's benefits -- has become a de facto club used to limit, if not thwart, the ability of a state to choose to recognize same-sex unions. Even more so now than in 1996, I believe we need to reduce federal power over the lives of the citizenry and over the prerogatives of the states. It truly is time to get the federal government out of the marriage business. In law and policy, such decisions should be left to the people themselves.”
Bob Barr, at that point was a fairly mainstream republican, a party of people who like to consider themselves to be advocates for a Constitutionally limited government and strict adherents to the Constitution. However, Barr came to the realization that following the Constitution means personal, civil, and economic liberties that most Americans have come to embrace and enjoy; but also it means the allowance of some things that you may personally dislike. One cannot use the Constitution when practical and when it supports your views and ignore it when it doesn’t. And this is precisely what most people in both political parties do. In 2004, Barr testified in front of Congress in opposition to a proposed Constitutional Amendment banning same-sex marriage. Barr said, “Part of federalism means that states have the right to make bad decisions – even on the issue of who can get married in the state. Resisting the temptation to use the federal government to meddle in state matters is the test of this conservative principle. Indeed, it is the test separating conservative federalists from hard-line social conservatives, willing to sacrifice the Constitution in their understandable anxiety over the sorry state of modern morality.” The acceptance of this view is something vital to conservatism’s purpose and is also required to be a true advocate for the Constitution.
Now the important question, what would happen if DOMA was repealed or ruled to be unconstitutional? All of the federal benefits given to married couples would then be given to married same-sex couples. Also, in accordance to Article IV Section 1 of the Constitution, commonly known as the Full Faith and Credit Clause, states regardless of their views on the marriage issue would have to recognize same-sex marriages from other states. I’m a stronger advocate for state’s rights than perhaps anyone else I know and I personally don’t care if gays get married, its not an issue near or dear to my heart. I’ve always considered it to be a state’s rights issue. However the reason DOMA should be at least partially repealed, has nothing to do with morality or equality.
The reason DOMA should be repealed is that the legislation is in direct violation of the Full Faith and Credit clause which states, “Such Acts, records and judicial proceedings or copies thereof, so authenticated, shall have the same full faith and credit in every court within the United States and its Territories and Possessions as they have by law or usage in the courts of such State, Territory or Possession from which they are taken.” In simpler terms, states must respect the "public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of every other state." I'd personally prefer a partial repeal of DOMA that would allow the federal government to recognize gay marriage but wouldn't force it upon the states. In a free society there are things that will upset you, but that is the nature of freedom. But going back to a lesson my uncle (and the Rolling Stones) taught me frequently when I was younger, is “You Can’t Always Get What You Want”.
Abortion activists consider the Roe v Wade Supreme Court Decision (1973) to be a landmark triumph for women’s rights. In fact, women’s rights groups appear to be single issue advocates now. Women’s rights used to mean equal pay for equal work, protection for mothers in the work place under the Family Medical Leave Act, the right to vote, and general acceptance in mainstream society. Now, women's rights means pro abortion. It appears feminism and being pro-life are mutually exclusive. If you are a pro life woman and you are viciously attacked in the media, it takes nearly an act of God to get a women’s group to condemn the attacker.
On the other hand, pro-life advocates consider Roe v Wade to be an abomination because of the onslaught of millions of babies that have been terminated since the court decision. However, the issue of morality has nothing to do with why Roe v Wade was potentially the worst supreme court ruling of all time.
Writing for the American Thinker, Michael Filozof makes a great analogy as to why Roe v Wade was a terrible ruling. “Imagine for a moment that you were ticketed for speeding by the state police. Suppose that you lied to the cop about why you were driving so fast. Then imagine that a group of special-interest lawyers contacted you and told you they wanted to appeal your ticket to the Supreme Court, and they gave you a legal pseudonym to hide your identity. Now imagine that the Court ruled that the ancient Romans had no speed limit on the Appian Way, that the Germans have no speed limits on the autobahn, and that speed limits are a violation of the Constitution and must be struck down.” That is essentially the logic, or perhaps more accurately the lack thereof, given by Justice Blackmun who wrote for the majority. Michael Filozof artfully breaks down a number of quotes given by Blackmun perhaps much better than I can; so, I will let him take over for a bit. The bold text is what the court wrote in its decision and the italicized text is Filozof’s analysis.
We forthwith acknowledge ... the emotional nature of the abortion controversy ... one's philosophy, one's experiences, and one's exposure to the raw edges of human existence ... are likely to influence and color one's thinking ... about abortion. [Emphasis mine.]
Do tell! Sounds more like the Oprah Winfrey Show than a Supreme Court decision.
In addition ... pollution, poverty and racial overtones [emphasis mine] tend to complicate and not simplify the problem. ...
Racial overtones? What in hell is that supposed to mean?
James Hubert Halford ... [alleged that the Texas law prohibiting abortions] violated ... his own right to practice medicine ... guaranteed by the First, Fourth, Fifth, Ninth[,] and Fourteenth Amendments.
Really? I'll give $500 cash to the first person who can find the phrase "right to practice medicine" in any of those amendments, or anywhere else in the Constitution. State governments have complete authority over the licensing and professional standards of physicians, nurses, clinics and, hospitals.
Ancient attitudes [toward abortion]. These are not capable of precise determination ...
OK, so why mention them?
We are told that at the time of the Persian Empire ... criminal abortions were severely punished. We are also told ... that abortion was practiced in Greek times as well as the Roman Era, and that "it was resorted to without scruple."
Precisely what does any of this have to do with the U.S. Constitution, ratified in 1789?
The Ephesian, Soranos, often described as the greatest of the ancient gynecologists, appears to have been generally opposed to Rome's prevailing free-abortion practices ...
This clearly takes the cake as the most ridiculous statement in the entire decision. It's not as offensive as citing the laws of the British Parliament, though. British Parliament? Yep, you read that right:
The English statutory law. England's first criminal abortion statute ... came in 1803 ... Recently, Parliament enacted a new abortion law. This is the Abortion Act of 1967 ... [which] permits a licensed physician to perform an abortion ...
Wait a minute! Didn't we fight a revolution against these people? It's been over two centuries since the laws of Parliament mattered on this side of the pond!
It has been argued ... that [antiabortion laws] were the product of Victorian social concern to discourage illicit sexual conduct. Texas [the defendant], however, does not advance this justification in the present case ...
This is insane. Why did Blackmun mention an argument the defendant did not even make?
The Constitution does not explicitly mention any right of privacy ...
Aha! The truth is revealed! The mask slips! (As an aside: Yes, that was the gist of the majority’s decision, a right not guaranteed by the Constitution. Courts cannot make up rights to give people, nor can they take rights away. This decision made up a right, and that’s well… not right. And I’m a fan of rights, the Constitution is all about giving people rights, that’s why there is a Bill full of them. This is a textbook example of judicial activism, which ironically is a charge usually directed at people who want to overturn court precedents. Overturning decisions like this should be the goal of anyone opposing judicial activism.)
[But] this right of privacy, whether it be founded in the Fourteenth Amendment's concept of personal liberty ... as we feel [emphasis mine] it is, or ... in the Ninth Amendment's reservation of rights to the people, is broad enough to encompass [abortion].
There you have it. The Constitution does not mention any right of "privacy," but it's in there -- somewhere. Doesn't even matter where -- it's "broad enough" to include abortion. (Justice Rehnquist dissented, observing that paying a physician for a medical procedure is hardly "private" -- it's a commercial transaction that normally falls under the regulatory power of the state.) Roe is so bad it makes other controversial decisions -- like Plessey v. Ferguson or Dred Scott -- look like models of Solomonic wisdom by comparison. In those cases, the Court was clearly biased, but it at least made an attempt to pay lip service to the Constitution.”
Furthering the atrocity of such an awful supreme court ruling is the fact that the study of Constitutional Law has nothing to do with the Constitution itself. Constitutional Law is based off previous court rulings. Or as Robert Bork put it, “I don't think the Constitution is studied almost anywhere, including law schools. In law schools, what they study is what the court said about the Constitution. They study the opinions. They don't study the Constitution itself.” So when the court makes a decision such as Roe v Wade, it's asinine reasoning will continually damn our country when future courts make stupid rulings based on Roe v Wade’s initial stupidity. Stated differently, terrible rulings create an endless cycle of compounded stupidity.
What would happen if Roe v Wade were to be overturned, you may be asking? The overturning of Roe v Wade would result in the nation’s abortion policy returning to what it was before the decision, the states would decide their abortion policy. Before Roe v Wade, the states decided their abortion policies. Twenty states had abortions (with varying restrictions from only rape victims to on demand) and thirty states had no abortions under any circumstance. If Roe v Wade were to be repealed, the policy would revert to something similar, likely with many more states likely allowing it with their own varying degrees of restrictions, as times have changed.
Talking to a liberal about issues like medical marijuana, prostitution, or gambling (issues liberals wouldn't morally oppose, but aren’t legal on a nationwide level) they may say that the state’s should have the right to choose their policies. They feel this way because they may like those said things, but generally not because they sympathize with the 10th amendment. Those same issues, which conservatives typically don’t like, will draw one of two reactions from conservatives. The conservatives will favor the states’ rights approach, not because they like the issues, but because they do adhere to the 10th amendment and appreciate the Constitution’s dual sovereignty setup OR the conservatives will appreciate the status quo because they don’t mind using the federal government to ban things they don’t like. The two distinct conservative positions is a very accurate representation of the divide in the conservative movement, the Ron Pauls vs. the Mike Huckabees. Statists on both sides of the two issues makes me again prompt the question, abortion (or pro-life) or anti-gay marriage (or pro gay marriage) at what price? Is voting strictly on these issues worth eroding other freedoms? Endless wars? Trillions in debt? Open borders? Crazy judicial appointments who legislate from the bench? Pro-longed economic depressions? That’s a question one needs to ask themselves when being a single issue voter