If you’ve seen headlines on newspapers recently or watched many media reports you’d think that the Tea Party won the debt ceiling deal. And with so many people in both parties expressing anger and dissatisfaction towards them, you’d think the media was right. John McCain referred to the Tea Party as “hobbits” and Joe Biden compared them to terrorists. Peter Beinart wrote an article for The Daily Beast entitled, “How the Tea Party Won the Deal,” in which he claims the Tea Party is running Washington.
Despite his incorrect assertion, he does provide a number of surprisingly accurate narratives of the Tea Party’s goals. Where he goes wrong is with his claim that “Given the era of fiscal scarcity we’re now entering, those neocon and progressive dreams are now likely dead for many years to come. Meanwhile, the Tea Party’s dream of a government reduced to its pre-welfare-state size becomes ever real.” Despite the Tea Party’s best effort, the welfare state is alive and well and we still have well over 750 military bases in 150 countries; and this debt deal does virtually nothing to correct those situations.
The Republican party went for the debt deal because it got some cuts and served as a way to put pressure on Obama, and because they were afraid they’d get blamed in the event of no compromise being reached. As frustrated as I get with their timidity, they are correct in their fear of getting blamed. A Pew Research Poll found that 42% would blame Republicans if no debt deal were reached; the irony is that the vast majority of the public agrees with their solution, a balanced budget amendment to the Constitution. This shows the power of the liberal media bias.
The Democratic party supported the debt deal because the cuts involved in the deal are minuscule, they were losing on their opposition to a balanced budget amendment, and the deal opens the door for tax increases and military budget cuts.
So let’s take a closer look at the media narrative that the Tea Party won on the debt ceiling deal. The Tea Party wanted serious cuts and a balanced budget amendment; they got neither. The Tea Party-leaning Republicans overwhelmingly opposed the deal. Nineteen Senate Republicans and 66 House Republicans voted no on the deal. So if the Tea Party supposedly won in the debt ceiling deal and is running Washington, why would they oppose the measure? If you were to ask this of a member of the media elite, I imagine they’d be at a loss for words and eventually conclude that it's because the Tea Party is bipolar.
The debt ceiling deal was so limited in terms of its cuts that the credit rating agencies S&P did downgrade us and Moody’s actually changed their outlook on our debt to “negative” and still are considering downgrading us unless further cuts occur. When and if that will happen is impossible to predict; but the timing could conveniently occur in the next president’s term. But, if in the event it happens, one thing is clear. The debt ceiling deal’s lack of serious cuts is to blame, and because the media declared the Tea Party as the winner, the patsy is in place.
The media has tried to place blame on the Tea Party numerous times in the past, most recently when Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords (D-AZ) was shot earlier this year. Before any details were confirmed, one thing was clear: it was a right-wing extremist tea partier. That is, until it wasn’t. Jared Loughner was a crazy person whose friends thought he was liberal, probably because he read books by Adolf Hitler and Karl Marx. Last year, when a man flew his plane into an IRS building, before the details came out it was obviously a Tea Partier then too. This was until it was discovered that he hated capitalism, Republicans, the Pope, and George W. Bush, and quoted Karl Marx in his suicide letter.
You may also remember in 2010 when a Democratic congressman claimed a Tea Partier spit on him as he walked with then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi through a crowd on the way to vote for the Obamacare bill. The media was certain this occurred and widely reported it, but their story was missing one crucial element: any evidence of the incident taking place. Every network had cameras on Pelosi and company and none of them captured it. Conservative media critic Andrew Breitbart has offered $10,000 to anyone who can prove the congressman was spit on, and not surprisingly, no one has been able to prove it.
When the media establishes a narrative, the facts don’t always matter, and the fix is usually in. When it comes to the media’s treatment of the Tea Party, its safe to say that they seem to use the “throw everything at a wall and see what sticks” method, hoping desperately that one day they’ll be able to pin something solid on them. They haven’t yet, but not for lack of trying. But until they are able to, they’ll just keep trying, knowing that the worst-case scenario is that they defame people they don’t like and slowly and deceptively turn public opinion against them. And they’ll continue this, resting assured that the only possible backlash against them is that the people who already don’t trust the media will continue to distrust them.
Originally Posted @ http://blogcritics.org/politics/article/the-debt-deal-a-victory-for/ before the downgrade occurred. Not bad, eh? Especially considering the democrats' latest talking point of calling our debt downgrade "The Tea Party Downgrade".
My goal is to both explain politics to political novices and to provide fresh insight to politically savvy individuals.
Showing posts with label George W Bush. Show all posts
Showing posts with label George W Bush. Show all posts
Monday, August 15, 2011
Tuesday, July 26, 2011
A Debt Ceiling Compromise: A Modest Proposal
My solution to the debt ceiling debate concludes that we need a balanced budget amendment and a constitutional limit on spending at no more than 19%. And actually that’s a higher spending percent than I’d consider ideal, because since 1971-2010 the US has only taken in an average of 18.47 percent of GDP in tax revenues (despite the varying tax rates in that period). From 1950 to 2000 federal spending as a percent of GDP averaged 19.8%. Under George W Bush (2001-2008), despite his overseeing of large deficits, spending was actually lower than the 50 year average at 19.6%. By comparison, under President Obama, federal government spending as a percentage of GDP was 25% in 2009 and 23.8% in 2010.
As part of the debt ceiling compromise, Democrats want to increase taxes (which is typically their solution to every problem) and combine that with spending cuts (which they will rabidly fight against). The Republicans' typical position is to refuse any plan that raises taxes, however they are even more emboldened in this case because our economy is already in such bad shape.
Obama went on the attack during his June 29, 2011 press conference, accusing Republicans of favoring corporate CEOs over middle class Americans. One may be inclined to ask, “How does not wanting to raise taxes on anyone, including the people who want to hire middle and lower class people, the same thing as opposing the middle class?” To borrow a line from Ayn Rand’s classic Atlas Shrugged, "Why ask useless questions? How deep is the ocean? How high is the sky? Who is John Galt?", the answer is nobody knows... just don’t question it.
Despite his 2009 stimulus package giving tax incentives for corporate jets, Obama attacked corporate jets six times in his speech. For the record, eliminating the tax incentives for corporate jets would generate roughly .1% of the revenue he wants to take in as part of the Democrat debt reduction strategy. As you may have been able to tell by the measly increase in tax revenue generated by an elimination of corporate jet tax incentive, his focus on corporate jets and CEOs and such isn’t really about debt reduction. His focus on the issue is a tactic in class warfare, which has long been a Democrat strategy to gain popular support for tax increases on the wealthy and corporations; as well as painting Republicans as corporate shills.
Interestingly, on The O’Reilly Factor airing 6/28/11, liberal radio host Alan Colmes said the Democrats don’t want to raise taxes, they just want to eliminate tax loopholes and deductions. For the record, I think that Alan Colmes is qualified to have a show called “Alan Colmes says the darndest things”, as he has a history of saying the most absurdly false things that could possibly come to his mind. Democrats have been clamoring for higher taxes for as long as I can remember. But it does appear as though he may have forecasted a strategy change, as lately President Obama has been echoing the same thing.
A true supporter of free markets understands that means not incentivizing or disincentivizing the purchasing of certain goods. For example, politicians levying high taxes on cigarettes to discourage smoking creates a disincentive and thus isn’t a free market action. The Democrats subsidizing and giving tax breaks to green energy companies and offering tax breaks to people who buy their products creates incentives for sellers and buyers of the products, and also isn’t a free market action.
Therefore I propose this idea: for every specific tax deduction that Democrats want to eliminate, we lower the corporate and individual tax rate by .025 percent. So if the Democrats want to eliminate 120 deductions from the tax code, that is great so long as the overall rates are lowered by 3 percent. According to the Cato Institute, the income tax code in the US had 54,846 pages in 2003, and it has grown by thousands of pages since. There are probably thousands of deductions, promoting activities/behavior at the expense of other competing industries and other taxpayers who have to pay more to make up the revenue surrendered by the deductions. My proposal will get us closer to a freer market and will lower the already too high taxes. It should also be stated that this isn’t a radical proposal, as Obama’s own debt reduction committee recommended an idea very similar, but their idea was ignored by the Obama administration. I should also mention that lowering taxes as a whole under Ronald Reagan, increased revenues to the government. Combining the revenue generated by the elimination of numerous tax deductions and economic growth through people being able to keep and spend a little more of their money could perhaps generate much more revenue than anticipated.
Lowering the corporate income tax is just as important as lowering the personal income tax rate, because the United States has the highest corporate income tax rate in the world. This causes American companies to move operations overseas and for US money to stay in offshore bank accounts; when it could be in our banks for them to lend it out as loanable funds to Americans. Also problematic is that the corporate income tax is in many ways a double tax. As businesses typically have a set profit margin, they pass on the cost of their taxes on to consumers. As a result, companies must sell their items for much higher prices to pay for the taxes levied on them. People may argue that removing the corporate income tax after its been in effect, won’t cause companies to lower their costs, as they’ll just pocket the money. Businesses could do that, but for them to stay in operation, they’d either have to lower their prices or resort to praying that their competition isn’t interested in expanding market share by lowering prices. However, even in that unfortunate scenario, the companies would then have the revenue to increase hiring, give their current employees raises, and put tons of money in R&D to make better products. Or perhaps the companies would drop the prices by half of the tax decreases and keep the other half, either way it’s a win-win for the economy.
Read more: http://blogcritics.org/politics/article/a-modest-debt-ceiling-proposal/#ixzz1TEba8c2h
As part of the debt ceiling compromise, Democrats want to increase taxes (which is typically their solution to every problem) and combine that with spending cuts (which they will rabidly fight against). The Republicans' typical position is to refuse any plan that raises taxes, however they are even more emboldened in this case because our economy is already in such bad shape.
Obama went on the attack during his June 29, 2011 press conference, accusing Republicans of favoring corporate CEOs over middle class Americans. One may be inclined to ask, “How does not wanting to raise taxes on anyone, including the people who want to hire middle and lower class people, the same thing as opposing the middle class?” To borrow a line from Ayn Rand’s classic Atlas Shrugged, "Why ask useless questions? How deep is the ocean? How high is the sky? Who is John Galt?", the answer is nobody knows... just don’t question it.
Despite his 2009 stimulus package giving tax incentives for corporate jets, Obama attacked corporate jets six times in his speech. For the record, eliminating the tax incentives for corporate jets would generate roughly .1% of the revenue he wants to take in as part of the Democrat debt reduction strategy. As you may have been able to tell by the measly increase in tax revenue generated by an elimination of corporate jet tax incentive, his focus on corporate jets and CEOs and such isn’t really about debt reduction. His focus on the issue is a tactic in class warfare, which has long been a Democrat strategy to gain popular support for tax increases on the wealthy and corporations; as well as painting Republicans as corporate shills.
Interestingly, on The O’Reilly Factor airing 6/28/11, liberal radio host Alan Colmes said the Democrats don’t want to raise taxes, they just want to eliminate tax loopholes and deductions. For the record, I think that Alan Colmes is qualified to have a show called “Alan Colmes says the darndest things”, as he has a history of saying the most absurdly false things that could possibly come to his mind. Democrats have been clamoring for higher taxes for as long as I can remember. But it does appear as though he may have forecasted a strategy change, as lately President Obama has been echoing the same thing.
A true supporter of free markets understands that means not incentivizing or disincentivizing the purchasing of certain goods. For example, politicians levying high taxes on cigarettes to discourage smoking creates a disincentive and thus isn’t a free market action. The Democrats subsidizing and giving tax breaks to green energy companies and offering tax breaks to people who buy their products creates incentives for sellers and buyers of the products, and also isn’t a free market action.
Therefore I propose this idea: for every specific tax deduction that Democrats want to eliminate, we lower the corporate and individual tax rate by .025 percent. So if the Democrats want to eliminate 120 deductions from the tax code, that is great so long as the overall rates are lowered by 3 percent. According to the Cato Institute, the income tax code in the US had 54,846 pages in 2003, and it has grown by thousands of pages since. There are probably thousands of deductions, promoting activities/behavior at the expense of other competing industries and other taxpayers who have to pay more to make up the revenue surrendered by the deductions. My proposal will get us closer to a freer market and will lower the already too high taxes. It should also be stated that this isn’t a radical proposal, as Obama’s own debt reduction committee recommended an idea very similar, but their idea was ignored by the Obama administration. I should also mention that lowering taxes as a whole under Ronald Reagan, increased revenues to the government. Combining the revenue generated by the elimination of numerous tax deductions and economic growth through people being able to keep and spend a little more of their money could perhaps generate much more revenue than anticipated.
Lowering the corporate income tax is just as important as lowering the personal income tax rate, because the United States has the highest corporate income tax rate in the world. This causes American companies to move operations overseas and for US money to stay in offshore bank accounts; when it could be in our banks for them to lend it out as loanable funds to Americans. Also problematic is that the corporate income tax is in many ways a double tax. As businesses typically have a set profit margin, they pass on the cost of their taxes on to consumers. As a result, companies must sell their items for much higher prices to pay for the taxes levied on them. People may argue that removing the corporate income tax after its been in effect, won’t cause companies to lower their costs, as they’ll just pocket the money. Businesses could do that, but for them to stay in operation, they’d either have to lower their prices or resort to praying that their competition isn’t interested in expanding market share by lowering prices. However, even in that unfortunate scenario, the companies would then have the revenue to increase hiring, give their current employees raises, and put tons of money in R&D to make better products. Or perhaps the companies would drop the prices by half of the tax decreases and keep the other half, either way it’s a win-win for the economy.
Read more: http://blogcritics.org/politics/article/a-modest-debt-ceiling-proposal/#ixzz1TEba8c2h
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)