For as long as I can remember, I’ve had IBS and related digestive disorders. I recently was joking around with my friends trying to explain to them that my stomach’s solution to every problem, complication, or regular event seems to be to produce stomach acid. And the excessive stomach acid, which in normal amounts is necessary to break down my food, gives me regular bouts with painful stomach cramps. This in turn limits my enjoyment of eating foods I enjoy and can cause potential delays in spontaneous plans.
So how is that like Democrats? Democrats’ solution to every problem, real or perceived, is more government. Can you think of the last time the Democratic party proposed anything aside from more government? To clarify, government is necessary in moderate amounts. Government has a role in protecting our liberties, providing for the common defense, enforcing contracts, protecting the environment (from pollution, not the irrational special interest driven protection currently in effect), etc. However, when too much government intervention, regulation, and taxation exists, it hampers economic growth, incentivizes bad behavior, causes moral hazards, and creates perpetual economic busts and recessions.
There are three potential areas in which Democrats could possibly be perceived as not demanding more government involvement. The first is gay marriage. However a closer examination of the gay marriage debate reveals that at the heart of the gay marriage debate is gays receiving government benefits/incentives from being married. The libertarian view is that government should stay out of marriage, neither giving it incentives or disincentives (government incentives usually come at the expense of someone else’s dollar); therefore demonstrating that government involvement is still involved in the Democrat’s seemingly laissez-faire action. Granted, in this case Democrats aren’t solely at fault here, as Republicans like to incentivize marriage to create a solid family structure.
Next is the issue of abortion, where it could appear that they don’t want others to interfere with “women’s rights”. The are two problems with this line of thinking, one being that in order to create on demand abortions in every state instead of letting the people of each individual state decide, they had to ram it through with judicial activism in arguably the worst supreme court decision in history. The other issue is that Democrats scream like children if you try to eliminate government funding of Planned Parenthood. Just so we’re on the same page, Planned Parenthood is nonprofit organization, separate from the government; so giving them taxpayer funds to “keep on keeping on” is certainly government involvement.
The last issue Democrats seemingly don’t call for increased government involvement is illegal immigration. Most Democrats appear to be happy having an open border and allowing whomever and whatever to cross it freely. If that were just the case, then yes, Democrats would prefer the government avoid getting involved. The great irony here is that border control is one of the few actual responsibilities of government, and Democrats appear to abdicate this authority. Despite their appearances, a closer inspection reveals that Democrats make it easier for illegals to receive entitlements, obtain “worker’s rights” such as minimum wage, and constantly push for amnesty to give them the right to vote (presumably, not for Republicans). So Democrats give governmental incentives for illegals to come here, meaning they are quite involved in the issue. Again, to be fair, a number of Republicans are weak on this issue as well; with the prime examples being Reagan who signed the "Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986" amnesty bill and George W Bush who pushed for Ted Kennedy's “comprehensive immigration reform” (aka amnesty) under his administration.
Speaking to Democrats reveals that many of them have good intentions. They legitimately want to help people. Obviously, I don’t feel that way about the Democratic politicians who are in bed with industries trying to push green energy and union agendas. Many Democratic voters want to feel the reassurance which government theoretically provides and that leads to their big government desires. They sympathize with the poor, and try to help them by passing policies that in the end create dependency/lasting poverty and adverse economic effects. Democrats want to be judged based on their intentions and goals, not the results. They become upset if you refer to Obama as a socialist, because socialism has such a reputation of failure and an overwhelmingly negative connotation. They view the term as an insult, rather than what it is, an economic and social policy.
I remain unconvinced of most prominent Democrats’ intentions. Are they looking out just for the special interests and telling people what they want to hear, knowing that the Democratic voting base is unlikely to look closely at their voting records? Do they legitimately feel that government involvement is going to create widespread prosperity? Or do they just subvert the free market system knowing creating high paying unnecessary government jobs and special interest tax incentives are great ways to get money and votes from the beneficiaries of the taxpayer money? Largely I believe it depends on the politician, nationally I think its more corrupt than locally. Regardless of their intention, I oppose 90 percent plus of the Democratic agenda. I don’t judge based on feelings and emotions, but based on policies and results.
Originally Posted @ http://blogcritics.org/politics/article/how-democrats-are-like-digestive-disorders/
My goal is to both explain politics to political novices and to provide fresh insight to politically savvy individuals.
Monday, August 1, 2011
Tuesday, July 26, 2011
A Debt Ceiling Compromise: A Modest Proposal
My solution to the debt ceiling debate concludes that we need a balanced budget amendment and a constitutional limit on spending at no more than 19%. And actually that’s a higher spending percent than I’d consider ideal, because since 1971-2010 the US has only taken in an average of 18.47 percent of GDP in tax revenues (despite the varying tax rates in that period). From 1950 to 2000 federal spending as a percent of GDP averaged 19.8%. Under George W Bush (2001-2008), despite his overseeing of large deficits, spending was actually lower than the 50 year average at 19.6%. By comparison, under President Obama, federal government spending as a percentage of GDP was 25% in 2009 and 23.8% in 2010.
As part of the debt ceiling compromise, Democrats want to increase taxes (which is typically their solution to every problem) and combine that with spending cuts (which they will rabidly fight against). The Republicans' typical position is to refuse any plan that raises taxes, however they are even more emboldened in this case because our economy is already in such bad shape.
Obama went on the attack during his June 29, 2011 press conference, accusing Republicans of favoring corporate CEOs over middle class Americans. One may be inclined to ask, “How does not wanting to raise taxes on anyone, including the people who want to hire middle and lower class people, the same thing as opposing the middle class?” To borrow a line from Ayn Rand’s classic Atlas Shrugged, "Why ask useless questions? How deep is the ocean? How high is the sky? Who is John Galt?", the answer is nobody knows... just don’t question it.
Despite his 2009 stimulus package giving tax incentives for corporate jets, Obama attacked corporate jets six times in his speech. For the record, eliminating the tax incentives for corporate jets would generate roughly .1% of the revenue he wants to take in as part of the Democrat debt reduction strategy. As you may have been able to tell by the measly increase in tax revenue generated by an elimination of corporate jet tax incentive, his focus on corporate jets and CEOs and such isn’t really about debt reduction. His focus on the issue is a tactic in class warfare, which has long been a Democrat strategy to gain popular support for tax increases on the wealthy and corporations; as well as painting Republicans as corporate shills.
Interestingly, on The O’Reilly Factor airing 6/28/11, liberal radio host Alan Colmes said the Democrats don’t want to raise taxes, they just want to eliminate tax loopholes and deductions. For the record, I think that Alan Colmes is qualified to have a show called “Alan Colmes says the darndest things”, as he has a history of saying the most absurdly false things that could possibly come to his mind. Democrats have been clamoring for higher taxes for as long as I can remember. But it does appear as though he may have forecasted a strategy change, as lately President Obama has been echoing the same thing.
A true supporter of free markets understands that means not incentivizing or disincentivizing the purchasing of certain goods. For example, politicians levying high taxes on cigarettes to discourage smoking creates a disincentive and thus isn’t a free market action. The Democrats subsidizing and giving tax breaks to green energy companies and offering tax breaks to people who buy their products creates incentives for sellers and buyers of the products, and also isn’t a free market action.
Therefore I propose this idea: for every specific tax deduction that Democrats want to eliminate, we lower the corporate and individual tax rate by .025 percent. So if the Democrats want to eliminate 120 deductions from the tax code, that is great so long as the overall rates are lowered by 3 percent. According to the Cato Institute, the income tax code in the US had 54,846 pages in 2003, and it has grown by thousands of pages since. There are probably thousands of deductions, promoting activities/behavior at the expense of other competing industries and other taxpayers who have to pay more to make up the revenue surrendered by the deductions. My proposal will get us closer to a freer market and will lower the already too high taxes. It should also be stated that this isn’t a radical proposal, as Obama’s own debt reduction committee recommended an idea very similar, but their idea was ignored by the Obama administration. I should also mention that lowering taxes as a whole under Ronald Reagan, increased revenues to the government. Combining the revenue generated by the elimination of numerous tax deductions and economic growth through people being able to keep and spend a little more of their money could perhaps generate much more revenue than anticipated.
Lowering the corporate income tax is just as important as lowering the personal income tax rate, because the United States has the highest corporate income tax rate in the world. This causes American companies to move operations overseas and for US money to stay in offshore bank accounts; when it could be in our banks for them to lend it out as loanable funds to Americans. Also problematic is that the corporate income tax is in many ways a double tax. As businesses typically have a set profit margin, they pass on the cost of their taxes on to consumers. As a result, companies must sell their items for much higher prices to pay for the taxes levied on them. People may argue that removing the corporate income tax after its been in effect, won’t cause companies to lower their costs, as they’ll just pocket the money. Businesses could do that, but for them to stay in operation, they’d either have to lower their prices or resort to praying that their competition isn’t interested in expanding market share by lowering prices. However, even in that unfortunate scenario, the companies would then have the revenue to increase hiring, give their current employees raises, and put tons of money in R&D to make better products. Or perhaps the companies would drop the prices by half of the tax decreases and keep the other half, either way it’s a win-win for the economy.
Read more: http://blogcritics.org/politics/article/a-modest-debt-ceiling-proposal/#ixzz1TEba8c2h
As part of the debt ceiling compromise, Democrats want to increase taxes (which is typically their solution to every problem) and combine that with spending cuts (which they will rabidly fight against). The Republicans' typical position is to refuse any plan that raises taxes, however they are even more emboldened in this case because our economy is already in such bad shape.
Obama went on the attack during his June 29, 2011 press conference, accusing Republicans of favoring corporate CEOs over middle class Americans. One may be inclined to ask, “How does not wanting to raise taxes on anyone, including the people who want to hire middle and lower class people, the same thing as opposing the middle class?” To borrow a line from Ayn Rand’s classic Atlas Shrugged, "Why ask useless questions? How deep is the ocean? How high is the sky? Who is John Galt?", the answer is nobody knows... just don’t question it.
Despite his 2009 stimulus package giving tax incentives for corporate jets, Obama attacked corporate jets six times in his speech. For the record, eliminating the tax incentives for corporate jets would generate roughly .1% of the revenue he wants to take in as part of the Democrat debt reduction strategy. As you may have been able to tell by the measly increase in tax revenue generated by an elimination of corporate jet tax incentive, his focus on corporate jets and CEOs and such isn’t really about debt reduction. His focus on the issue is a tactic in class warfare, which has long been a Democrat strategy to gain popular support for tax increases on the wealthy and corporations; as well as painting Republicans as corporate shills.
Interestingly, on The O’Reilly Factor airing 6/28/11, liberal radio host Alan Colmes said the Democrats don’t want to raise taxes, they just want to eliminate tax loopholes and deductions. For the record, I think that Alan Colmes is qualified to have a show called “Alan Colmes says the darndest things”, as he has a history of saying the most absurdly false things that could possibly come to his mind. Democrats have been clamoring for higher taxes for as long as I can remember. But it does appear as though he may have forecasted a strategy change, as lately President Obama has been echoing the same thing.
A true supporter of free markets understands that means not incentivizing or disincentivizing the purchasing of certain goods. For example, politicians levying high taxes on cigarettes to discourage smoking creates a disincentive and thus isn’t a free market action. The Democrats subsidizing and giving tax breaks to green energy companies and offering tax breaks to people who buy their products creates incentives for sellers and buyers of the products, and also isn’t a free market action.
Therefore I propose this idea: for every specific tax deduction that Democrats want to eliminate, we lower the corporate and individual tax rate by .025 percent. So if the Democrats want to eliminate 120 deductions from the tax code, that is great so long as the overall rates are lowered by 3 percent. According to the Cato Institute, the income tax code in the US had 54,846 pages in 2003, and it has grown by thousands of pages since. There are probably thousands of deductions, promoting activities/behavior at the expense of other competing industries and other taxpayers who have to pay more to make up the revenue surrendered by the deductions. My proposal will get us closer to a freer market and will lower the already too high taxes. It should also be stated that this isn’t a radical proposal, as Obama’s own debt reduction committee recommended an idea very similar, but their idea was ignored by the Obama administration. I should also mention that lowering taxes as a whole under Ronald Reagan, increased revenues to the government. Combining the revenue generated by the elimination of numerous tax deductions and economic growth through people being able to keep and spend a little more of their money could perhaps generate much more revenue than anticipated.
Lowering the corporate income tax is just as important as lowering the personal income tax rate, because the United States has the highest corporate income tax rate in the world. This causes American companies to move operations overseas and for US money to stay in offshore bank accounts; when it could be in our banks for them to lend it out as loanable funds to Americans. Also problematic is that the corporate income tax is in many ways a double tax. As businesses typically have a set profit margin, they pass on the cost of their taxes on to consumers. As a result, companies must sell their items for much higher prices to pay for the taxes levied on them. People may argue that removing the corporate income tax after its been in effect, won’t cause companies to lower their costs, as they’ll just pocket the money. Businesses could do that, but for them to stay in operation, they’d either have to lower their prices or resort to praying that their competition isn’t interested in expanding market share by lowering prices. However, even in that unfortunate scenario, the companies would then have the revenue to increase hiring, give their current employees raises, and put tons of money in R&D to make better products. Or perhaps the companies would drop the prices by half of the tax decreases and keep the other half, either way it’s a win-win for the economy.
Read more: http://blogcritics.org/politics/article/a-modest-debt-ceiling-proposal/#ixzz1TEba8c2h
The Myth of the Anti-War Left
Throughout the Bush years, democrats were quite vocal in their opposition to the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. However, since the election of Barrack Obama, the anti-war rallies have gone from loud and commonplace to quiet and very few.
This is not just based on simple observation as two college professors actually have documented this phenomenon. This is strange because not only are we still in Iraq and Afghanistan, but under Obama the amount of troops in Afghanistan have significantly increased. Worse, according to statistics given by the LA Times, more deaths have occurred in Obama’s 2.5 years in office than the 6.5 years we were there under Bush. Even worse, Obama has started yet another war in Libya, even though his own Defense Secretary Robert Gates told ABC’s This Week, that Libya did not pose a threat to the United States and that “It was not a vital national interest to the United States…”
As though the decision to go into Libya wasn't bad enough, the Obama administration is in violation of the War Powers Act, as 90 days have passed since military action began in Libya. The War Powers Act (1973) was passed in order to limit the power of the presidency to engage in military conflicts without Congressional approval. The War Powers Act requires the President to notify Congress within 48 hours of committing troops to engage in military action and forbids armed forces from remaining for more than 60 days, with an additional 30 day withdrawal period, without a Congressional authorization of the use of military force or a declaration of war. Despite this, President Obama asserts that no authorization was required, since the US leadership was transferred to NATO, and the US involvement is somewhat limited.
This is obviously a ridiculous defense of his actions. As Charlie Savage of the New York Times wrote, “President Obama rejected the views of top lawyers at the Pentagon and the Justice Department when he decided that he had the legal authority to continue American military participation in the air war in Libya without Congressional authorization, according to officials familiar with internal administration deliberations.” Instead, Obama shopped around until he found lawyers that agreed with his position.
Seeing this third war come about and having seen the great number of leftist anti-war protestors in the Bush years, you’d think that there would be an uproar on the political left. With the exception of Democrat Ohio Congressman Dennis Kucinich who has been quite loud and consistent on the issue, and a few others, most democrats and the democrat leadership have avoided criticism of the president on the war in Libya. The loudest opposition against the military action has come from libertarians and libertarian-leaning republicans.
President Obama is no fan of peace with his ramping up of wars and violation of the War Powers Act, and the majority of democrats either: don’t care, support it, or won’t criticize their man. WWI, WWII, the Korean War, and Vietnam were all fought under democrats. The great myth is that democrats are anti-war. The reality is democrats aren’t anti-war, they just oppose republicans and republican wars. Democrats are willing to support nearly any action put forth by a fellow democrat and will use any excuse or justification to help defend it. Democrats ran as anti-war throughout the 2000s, not because of any core conviction, but because Bush supported the wars.
This is not just based on simple observation as two college professors actually have documented this phenomenon. This is strange because not only are we still in Iraq and Afghanistan, but under Obama the amount of troops in Afghanistan have significantly increased. Worse, according to statistics given by the LA Times, more deaths have occurred in Obama’s 2.5 years in office than the 6.5 years we were there under Bush. Even worse, Obama has started yet another war in Libya, even though his own Defense Secretary Robert Gates told ABC’s This Week, that Libya did not pose a threat to the United States and that “It was not a vital national interest to the United States…”
As though the decision to go into Libya wasn't bad enough, the Obama administration is in violation of the War Powers Act, as 90 days have passed since military action began in Libya. The War Powers Act (1973) was passed in order to limit the power of the presidency to engage in military conflicts without Congressional approval. The War Powers Act requires the President to notify Congress within 48 hours of committing troops to engage in military action and forbids armed forces from remaining for more than 60 days, with an additional 30 day withdrawal period, without a Congressional authorization of the use of military force or a declaration of war. Despite this, President Obama asserts that no authorization was required, since the US leadership was transferred to NATO, and the US involvement is somewhat limited.
This is obviously a ridiculous defense of his actions. As Charlie Savage of the New York Times wrote, “President Obama rejected the views of top lawyers at the Pentagon and the Justice Department when he decided that he had the legal authority to continue American military participation in the air war in Libya without Congressional authorization, according to officials familiar with internal administration deliberations.” Instead, Obama shopped around until he found lawyers that agreed with his position.
Seeing this third war come about and having seen the great number of leftist anti-war protestors in the Bush years, you’d think that there would be an uproar on the political left. With the exception of Democrat Ohio Congressman Dennis Kucinich who has been quite loud and consistent on the issue, and a few others, most democrats and the democrat leadership have avoided criticism of the president on the war in Libya. The loudest opposition against the military action has come from libertarians and libertarian-leaning republicans.
President Obama is no fan of peace with his ramping up of wars and violation of the War Powers Act, and the majority of democrats either: don’t care, support it, or won’t criticize their man. WWI, WWII, the Korean War, and Vietnam were all fought under democrats. The great myth is that democrats are anti-war. The reality is democrats aren’t anti-war, they just oppose republicans and republican wars. Democrats are willing to support nearly any action put forth by a fellow democrat and will use any excuse or justification to help defend it. Democrats ran as anti-war throughout the 2000s, not because of any core conviction, but because Bush supported the wars.
Labels:
Afghanistan,
Bush,
Dennis Kucinich,
Iraq,
Korea,
Libya,
NATO,
Obama,
Vietnam,
War Powers Act,
WWI,
WWII
Monday, July 11, 2011
The Complexity of Gas Prices
“The ideas of economists and political philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed the world is ruled by little else. Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influence, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist.” - John Maynard Keynes, Influential 20th Century Economist
First thing is first, OPEC is the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries. A good way to consider OPEC is a trade union on an international scale or perhaps more simply a cartel. OPEC consists of Algeria, Angola, Ecuador, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Libya, Nigeria, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, and Venezuela. If you find that the names of those countries by in large seem hostile to America, you’ve made a correct observation. These are nations, who, you may say, have a “past” with the United States and isn’t exactly looking to help us out or make life particularly easy. OPEC sets production rates of how much oil is produced, doing this allows the nations to profit equally (based on margins, not total output). If OPEC were to agree to pump double the amount of oil they currently produce, the price of gasoline would plummet, and they’d probably make less money, seeing as their profit margin would be lower. If OPEC raises the price too much, then its likely that more countries will try to produce their own oil (without joining OPEC) and would seek to compete with OPEC’s prices. OPEC reducing output, and therefore raising prices past a certain point would cause hate and discontent and may lead to more people seeking alternative transportation, which in the long run, would be bad for OPEC. When technology allows for a cost effective, reliable and convenient way to power means of transportation in the future, OPEC will probably cease to exist and oil as a natural resource will be outdated and useless. If run effectively, OPEC will do what OPEC can to make oil still viable.
With that being said, OPEC isn’t a private company who’s only goal is to make money and expand to make even more money in the future. OPEC is a group of fairly crappy, hostile nations. In the 1990s oil was around $15 a barrel and life in the US was good. However since then, 3 specific events have seemingly (so far) permanently driven up oil prices. The first was in 1998 when Venezuelan dictator and American enemy, Hugo Chavez hosted an OPEC head of state meeting where he organized a collective scaling back of oil production to raise the price of oil. The other two events were 9/11 and subsequent invasion of Afghanistan in 2001 and the Iraq war in 2003. Those events caused prices to go up fairly significantly, even more so than the scale back urged (and never relinquished) by Hugo Chavez. Donald Trump got a decent amount of attention last week when he gave a speech to supporters in Las Vegas and said, “They [OPEC] want to go in and raise the price of oil because we have nobody in Washington that sits back and says you’re not going to raise that fucking price, you understand me?” This is a prime example of why Trump is somewhat popular, because he says things that people want to hear or that play to a populist sentiment, regardless of whether or not the action he proposes is Constitutional or helpful. Bill O’Reilly may agree with Trump and add, “… OPEC isn’t looking out for the folks…”. This is true, OPEC as a cartel is self interested in making money, and the people on its board don’t like us. This means that we can’t expect any favors from OPEC or its member nations. Want cheaper gas prices? Cursing at them and telling them what they can and cannot do isn’t going to help. Both Obama and Bush paid homage to the Saudi King and he wouldn’t increase production, despite their respective pleas. For lower gas prices, you’ll have to find another way besides appealing to the generous and sympathetic nature of these 3rd world dictators.
The least scandalous and sexy reason for higher gas prices now, and in some past summers is simple supply and demand. As demand increases, the prices does too, especially if there’s a stagnant or decreasing supply. Looking for simple answers and an easy target to place their blame and discontent, many people will accuse the oil companies of “price gouging”. These people either willfully ignorant, just plain ignorant, intellectually dishonest, don’t understand economics, have a political motive, an ex-employee of an oil company, or have an IQ of less than 70 (the threshold for being mentally retarded). The best examples of these accusations usually come in an area hit by a disaster. In the disaster area, lets say that most gas stations are inoperable and that surrounding hotels are mostly full. The gas stations likely will raise their prices, being as half the ones in town are closed and they may not get anymore supply in days. This is where the ignorant people, we’ll call them democrats in this scenario (mostly because this is how democrats act and think), across the country will accuse the gas stations of gouging. If prices remained at their low level it was before the disaster, the townspeople would think nothing of filling up all their cars, boats, lawn mowers, and anything else that uses gas; and this would further worsen the gas shortage and mean that their neighbors may have to go without. However if its double the price, they’ll get what they need to operate or enough to go to the next cities over to get gas at a normal price. Likewise with hotels, if hotels remained at normal rates, a family may get 2 or 3 rooms to be comfortable for their stay; leaving the affected families who may not have anywhere to go, without shelter. Raising the prices would make the family who can do with 1 room but wants 2-3, settle for the 1 room, giving more people a place to stay.
Back to supply and demand’s impact on oil prices, until we get more supply or lower demand; or both, prices going up is something you can count on. There are a few ways to increase supply. Drilling more obviously increases the supply, both domestically and abroad. The mindset behind the catchphrase of “Drill Baby Drill” that Sarah Palin was known to incite, hit a speed bump after the Gulf oil spill a year ago. However, the increasing gas prices is resuscitating the sentiment. Currently most areas of the US are off limits to new oil exploration and drilling. At the beginning of 2010 Obama opened up some areas to offshore exploration, and this got a lot of media play; with people on both sides guessing this was Obama’s attempt at throwing the republicans a bone after the prolonged, controversial, and heated Obamacare debate. However, what most people didn’t know is that the ordinance closed more areas to exploration than it opened. The Gulf Oil spill is the worst in American history (not world history) and the images are disturbing to everyone, and its effects were devastating to the people in the gulf. The panic and public outcry the spill caused gave the White House a chance to pass its 10 month offshore drilling moratorium. A number of oil companies, politicians from gulf states, and economists warned that this moratorium would kill jobs as the rigs would move from the states to nearby countries who drill offshore. And sure enough, a number of the idle rigs has since moved to Brazil (a country that Obama has loaned more than $2 billion to for them to drill offshore, ironically) and a few other nearby nations. The day that the Libyan “Kinetic Military Action” began, Obama was in Brazil, where he told the government, “we want to be one of your best customers”. I can’t begin to describe how stupid it is to loan someone the money to compete against you internationally, but regardless we did. And not only did we do that, we are excited about it.
As the Wall Street Journal reported on April 20, 2011, “Offshore oil production, most of which comes from the Gulf, is expected to average 1.55 million barrels a day this year, down 13% from 2010, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. The drilling suspension, along with a new, slower permitting process, will result in the loss this year of about 375,000 barrels of oil a day, according to energy consultancy Wood Mackenzie. That is roughly equivalent to one-third of the production in Libya that remains shut down because of political turmoil there." The decline in production has hurt not only the oil companies themselves, but also the drilling companies. An example of this is the Texas-based Seahawk Drilling, the second-largest shallow-water driller operating in the Gulf, announced it had filed for bankruptcy in February. Its Chief Executive, Randy Stilley said that while the outcome is best for the company’s stakeholders, “I think it is important to note that Seahawk was forced to seek strategic alternatives only after an unprecedented decline in the issuance of offshore drilling permits following the Macondo blowout.” The Daily Caller reports that “Democratic Sen. Mary Landrieu of Louisiana called the bankruptcy an “economic nightmare." "I have repeatedly said that the administration’s excruciatingly slow release of oil and gas permits will cause job losses,” Landrieu said in a statement. “How many more rigs have to leave and how many more businesses have to close before it realizes the havoc the de facto moratorium is wrecking on the Gulf Coast?” Landrieu went on to say that although the shallow-water industry was not part of the moratorium, the regulations have made it “very difficult” for anyone to conduct business in the Gulf.”
These regulations aren’t the only ones slowing or stopping potential or real oil production. The Wall Street Journal reported that in 2007, an environmentalist group went to court and successfully blocked some exploration and planned offshore drilling in Alaska. On April 25, 2011, Fox News reported, “Shell Oil Company has announced it must scrap efforts to drill for oil this summer in the Arctic Ocean off the northern coast of Alaska. The decision comes following a ruling by the EPA’s Environmental Appeals Board to withhold critical air permits. Shell has spent five years and nearly $4 billion dollars on plans to explore for oil in the Beaufort and Chukchi Seas. The leases alone cost $2.2 billion. He’s especially frustrated over the appeal board’s suggestion that the Arctic drill would somehow be hazardous for the people who live in the area. 'We think the issues were really not major, and clearly not impactful for the communities we work in.' The closest village to where Shell proposed to drill is Kaktovik, Alaska. It is one of the most remote places in the United States. According to the latest census, the population is 245 and nearly all of the residents are Alaska natives. The village, which is 1 square mile, sits right along the shores of the Beaufort Sea, 70 miles away from the proposed off-shore drill site.”
At this point, its clear that liberals are determined to stop domestic offshore oil drilling. However, its not just offshore drilling that the Obama administration is opposed to. As Yahoo! News reported on April 27, 2011, “The Fish and Wildlife Service is considering placing a creature called the Dunes Sagebrush Lizard on the endangered species list. Should this happen, both the oil industry and agriculture in West Texas and Eastern New Mexico will be crippled. People in Texas view this prospect, when taken on top of the shuttle decision, the continuing slow walking of Gulf oil drilling permits, and slow response to FEMA to the Texas wildfires disaster, as further proof that President Obama has it in for Texas. Declaring the Dunes Sagebrush Lizard as endangered would certainly serve the president's purpose of shutting down domestic oil production, sending the price of gasoline even higher, and thus making his favored green energy technologies all the more attractive. While Texans may be correct about President Obama's antipathy to the Lone Star State, the Fish and Wildlife Service has been if anything bi-partisan in its willingness to destroy industries and livelihoods to protect obscure animal species. When the Delta Smelt, a small aquatic creature, was placed on the endangered species list, a great deal of the irrigation system in California's Central Valley was shut down, turning what was once lush farmland into a dust bowl.” I included the part about Texans feeling disgruntled, because I think they may be on to something. I also included the part about the Delta Smelt in California to demonstrate the consistent and regular damage done to the economy by environmental regulators.
Hmmm… Perhaps then its just domestic drilling that the Obama administration is opposed to. Well, what if we could get oil domestically without drilling for it? Well luckily we can, oil can be extracted from oil shale, and there is an over abundance in the Western United States. Plans were made by the Bush administration in 2008 to take a look at oil shale production domestically. There has long been concerns that oil shale may cost too much to produce to make it worthwhile, but with demand as high as it is, without a major increase in supply, it could perhaps now be viable. Unfortunately though, as ESPN College Football Analyst Lee Corso would say, “Not so fast my friend!” Under the direction of the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), the Department of the Interior Secretary Ken Salazar ordered public hearings in the states that have oil shale to get their input on the plan. While this sounds harmless to get public input, if you’ve ever witnessed how governments on all levels use public hearings, you know its not that simple. Here in Charleston, the completion of I-526 has been voted for a number of times and tax increases have passed to pay for its construction. However, not liking the results over and over through the years, in 2010, a new plan for I-526 was developed which angered both the environmentalists (who opposed its completion anyway to prevent development) and the vast majority of the public (who wanted its completion) called the “green way”. This plan involved low speed limits and medians with trees and flowers, which would cause development with its low speed limits and also not really make anyone’s commute any faster. This plan was likely designed to fail, and its unpopularity resulted in I-526 not getting completed, under any plan, including the previously accepted plans. These BLM public hearings are already being protested by organized environmental activists. I can guarantee you that the “rethinking” of the plan was designed to fail, in order to stop shale oil’s development.
Luckily we live in the most advanced nation in the world. Thank God for the fact that, we have the kind of wealth here where we can afford to make environmental regulations which will cost jobs and raise prices, but could be worth it for our quality of life. When we were a developing nation during the industrial revolution and soot covered the industrial districts of most cities, we didn’t have the money or quality of life to pass these regulations. We can decide things with cost-benefit analyses. Is it worth paying higher oil prices to save the delta smelt? We can decide that, and in that spirit I welcome that debate. An open and honest debate about the economic costs of such a regulation, which would include higher oil prices, less tax revenue (which would mean reduced services), eliminating (or never created) high paying jobs (both for the oil companies and extraction companies); versus the environmental impacts explained by neutral scientists, not rabid, crazy religion of environmentalist types. However that debate never occurs because when unelected (politically appointed) regulators make the decisions for us, its much harder to have an input; and most people don’t know its going on, because its not a bill being debated in Congress or typically receiving much media coverage. Are the environmental threats that advocates scream about, realistic and definite? By in large they are grossly over exaggerated to scare people, which is a popular bi-partisan tactic to get what you want. However, ironically, many times their warnings are 100% backwards. A perfect example of this was the environmentalists warnings that the Alaska Pipeline would severely harm the caribou population. What they found out though, was that the caribou love the pipeline, and they often habitat near it, and since the pipeline’s construction, the caribou’s population has skyrocketed. There is a pretty long history of ridiculous global warming catastrophic predictions that have never come to pass, in fact its really pretty common.
As a normal personal you probably would like the satisfaction of low gas prices and clean air and water. Luckily we do have clean air and water, however we obviously don't have low gas prices. You would also expect that most people, and particularly elected officials want the same, regardless of their political persuasion. This is where you would be wrong. As the Wall Street Journal reported after Obama was elected in the 2008 race, "Mr. Obama plans soon to introduce his energy and environment team, which will include Nobel Prize-winning physicist Steven Chu as energy secretary... The team's makeup shows that Mr. Obama plans to put a heavy emphasis on combating climate change and promoting technologies to wean the U.S. off imported oil. Mr. Chu has called for gradually ramping up gasoline taxes over 15 years to coax consumers into buying more-efficient cars and living in neighborhoods closer to work. ‘Somehow we have to figure out how to boost the price of gasoline to the levels in Europe,’ Mr. Chu, who directs the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in California, said in an interview with The Wall Street Journal in September. But Mr. Obama has dismissed the idea of boosting the federal gasoline tax, a move energy experts say could be the single most effective step to promote alternative energies and temper demand. Mr. Obama said Sunday that a heightened gas tax would be a ‘mistake’ because it would put ‘additional burdens on American families right now.’”
I appreciate president-elect Obama's position on this issue, raising gas taxes is a terrible idea; unfortunately candidate Obama and president Obama seemingly support many different policies. Obama, like most politicians, tends to say one thing and do the exact opposite; its very hard to read what he truly wants and supports. The danger in this, is the danger expressed by my previous blog post entitled “Obama’s False Flag Operation”; generally people don’t have an understanding on the complexity of political and economic issues and often times when something like gas prices increases, the easiest and simplest explanation is “these evil gas companies are gouging us”. However, in addition to being the easiest and simplest explanation, it happens to be a most incorrect explanation. However, this misunderstanding comes in handy when it comes to political policies. If a politician were to defend an oil company in public, from an unreasonable attack, it then leaves him open to eminent incoming political attacks from his opponents, portraying him as “in the pocket of ‘big oil’”. President Bush famously gave a speech (on the issue of terrorism) to a joint session of Congress saying, “Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists”. The same philosophy is true with the democrats and oil companies, you either hate oil companies or you are in their pocket, with nothing in between.
Another issue that raises prices is oil speculation. If you’ve watched a news story on any cable news station, you’ve probably heard the term. However, the amount that oil speculation has raised the price is largely minimal. The website, “How Stuff Works” explains speculation as, “An oil future is simply a contract between a buyer and seller, where the buyer agrees to purchase a certain amount of a commodity -- in this case oil -- at a fixed price [source: CFTC]. Futures offer a way for a purchaser to bet on whether a commodity will increase in price down the road. Once locked into a contract, a futures buyer would receive a barrel of oil for the price dictated in the future contract, even if the market price was higher when the barrel was actually delivered.” The process seems ominous, however speculation occurs in a number of markets, most notably in agriculture. Speculators offer to buy the yield of a harvest from a farmer at a set price. The speculator is betting that the value of the crops will be worth more than its current value, in the future. This process protects the farmer, who needs money up front for his operations, and is a total risk for the speculator. The Washington Post’s Ezra Klein, who is someone that I disagree with the far majority of the time, wrote a pretty good column in April entitled, “If only speculation explained gas prices”. Klein writes, “First, speculators probably aren’t the problem here. Second, the things that are the problem here are really, really scary. Speculators are an easy bad guy, says Michael Greenstone, an energy economist at MIT. 'They’re a malevolent other. They’re thought to produce nothing of value, and so blaming them has a long and rich history.' But it’s worth understanding what exactly you’re saying is happening when you place the blame on speculators. 'Speculators make money by pulling oil off the market, putting it in inventory, and selling it later,' Greenstone continues. So if you’re seeing speculation, you should be seeing a massive run-up in inventory.”
The Cato Institute, a think tank, also wrote in April 2011 about oil speculation; and the amount of blame it receives versus the amount it has risen oil prices. Their report explains, "Futures prices for some commodity like oil or gasoline can affect current prices — but if and only if those futures cause producers, consumers, or stockpilers (i.e., people who buy and hold commodities for future sale, aka speculators) to change their behavior in some way that would affect supply and demand today. For instance, if the federal government were to announce that it’s going to buy a lot of gold in six months at a price much higher than what it sells at now, stockpilers would likely respond by buying and storing gold today in anticipation of selling it to Uncle Sam later, at a profit. This would push up prices today. However, commodities that are costly to store are less likely to experience this because speculators will have to factor in the storage cost, which could make the strategy risky and unprofitable. For instance, roses are inexpensive most of the year, but are very expensive around Valentine’s Day. The reason for this (in part) is that roses harvested in August can’t be stored cheaply and sold on Valentine’s Day. A “rose future” signed in August but closing in February won’t have much effect on August rose prices. Interestingly, oil and gasoline are more like roses than gold. Oil and gas don’t spoil (at least, not to the extent roses do), but they’re expensive to store — petroleum is heavy, dirty, emits fumes, and is combustible. For that reason, not a lot of oil or gasoline is stockpiled for the long term (beyond the Strategic Petroleum Reserve). With that said, there has been some building of oil stockpiles in recent weeks, but it’s not dramatically higher than the stockpiling usually seen prior to the summer driving season — and gasoline stocks have been declining." I included speculation as a factor that raises prices, because it does, but of all the reasons I’m going to list, this is the least impactful. Also, speculation can work two ways, speculators will bet down on oil prices if there was any indication that the United States would increase its domestic oil production. The fact that it isn’t, is why people are “betting” against declining oil prices.
Another factor that impacts the price at the pump is taxes. Yes, Ben Franklin indicated his foresight, genius and wit when he noted that, “In this world nothing is certain but death and taxes”. The federal government and the state governments both tax gasoline. The national gasoline tax comes in the form of an excise tax, which is related to a customs tariff. What differentiates the two taxes, is that tariffs are charged in order to bring a product into the country; think of a “border tax”, if you will. An excise tax is a tax levied on a company who wants to operate or sell a product inside the country, and that tax is directly passed on to the customer. The national excise tax on gas is 18.4 cents per gallon. According to the Tax Foundation, South Carolina has 4th lowest state gasoline tax, totaling 16.8 cents a gallon, meaning that in the state, that taxes contribute 35.2 cents for each gallon of gas. Neighboring North Carolina, has the 16th highest state gas tax, 30.2 cents, combining with the federal tax to raise the price of NC’s gas by 48.6 cents per gallon.
Speaking of governmental taxes adding to gas prices, on February 14, 2011, Fox News reported that the Obama administration is going to attempt to try to eliminate the subsidies and tax incentives for oil companies, beginning on October 1 (the beginning of fiscal year 2012). The sum total of the subsidies and tax incentives is roughly $4 billion. Also planned is to increase the fees on oil and gas drilling, which could result in an additional $2 billion in government revenue. As someone who supports a free market, I don’t support subsidies for any business, but particularly businesses who are putting up record profits. However, taking away subsidies, tax incentives, and increasing the fee to produce oil and natural gas, isn’t going to make gasoline any cheaper. The way the oil companies (and any other industry that benefits from subsidies) treat subsidies is as if it was revenue from profits; and when those subsidies are eliminated, its likely that the oil companies will try to make up the difference by raising prices to generate the lost $4 billion. A good deal for the republicans to try to negotiate with the administration would be to agree to eliminate the subsidies, if the drilling fee is tossed out, and at least $4 billion in new drilling is allowed to proceed; as well as an elimination of the tens of billions in subsidies given to “green” energy manufacturers and producers. An elimination of all subsidies was agreed to by the free market think tank, the Cato Institute, and by the zealous environmentalist organization the Sierra Club, and if these 2 groups can agree on a policy, there’s no reason that a bunch of politicians can’t. Only time will tell if the republicans are smart enough to push for this compromise, and it’s very unlikely the democrats and Obama administration would agree to it, with all of their ties to the green energy lobby.
Perhaps the largest reason for the recent increase in the price of gas is inflation. Inflation is on the rise, and it’s much higher than most people are aware. The Federal Reserve, the central bank of the United States, in the past few years has conducted 2 rounds of quantitative easing. Quantitative easing (QE), simply put, is a process where the Federal Reserve prints a stated amount of money out of thin air, which devalues the currency as a whole. In the old days at least, it would be a mass printing of money, however, in today’s society, the money isn’t directly printed, but instead it is added digitally, to bank accounts and asset sheets. The benefit of this is supposed to be the ability to lower the price of exports so other nations can buy them, and more directly the new money is created to buy treasury bonds to keep the government going. With the currency being devalued, the dollar, by definition, has less purchasing power. Also, according to the Keynesian model of economics, inflation causes prices to rise, which is good for the producers and sellers of products, and is good for the economy in times of crisis. If this sounds ass backwards, then you understand it perfectly. I’m personally amazed that after being proven a fool for the past century, that John Maynard Keynes’ ideas are still widely practiced in Washington.
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is a figure put out by the Labor Department and its function is to calculate the inflation rate. The most well known figure they put out, is the “core inflation”, which excludes certain items that face volatile price movements, notably food and energy. The problem is that the 2 categories that have seen its prices raise tremendously are… food and energy. The CPI does have a figure that includes food and energy and that paints a much more gloomy picture than the core rate. According to MSNBC’s John Schoen, “Consumer Price Index seems to misstate the "true" rate of inflation is because many economists focus on the so-called "core" CPI rate, which excludes volatile food and energy prices. The "core" CPI is up only 1.2 percent over the past year, but many consumers rightly complain that figure understates the true inflation rate. But economists, including policymakers like Federal Reserve Chief Ben Bernanke, say the core rate gives a clearer picture of persistent inflation trends.” The CPI had its criteria by which it gauges the inflation rate adjusted in 1980. According to an article written by CNBC’s John Melloy, “After former Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker was appointed in 1979, the consumer price index surged into the double digits, causing the now revered Fed Chief to double the benchmark interest rate in order to break the back of inflation. Using the methodology in place at that time puts the CPI back near those levels. Inflation, using the reporting methodologies in place before 1980, hit an annual rate of 9.6 percent in February, according to the Shadow Government Statistics newsletter.” To best explain the danger of inflation, an average inflationary rate of 2% would mean that in 50 years, the money in your savings account is worth half as much as it did at your original deposit. If inflation is closer to 9.6% (depending on if the 1979 criteria more accurately reflected inflation) the value of your savings would be cut in half in just 12 years.
In summary, the price of oil, is dependent upon a great many factors. Oil isn’t an endless resource, and the more nations that develop, the higher the demand will be. Oil prices would rise in the future with the growth of economies such as China and India, both nations have around triple the population of the US. The only way to lower oil prices is to produce more oil or to lower demand, but only one of those two options can be done easily. You have one party in Washington who is steadfastly opposed to drilling, as has been demonstrated by the examples given. Anyone who tells you that oil prices are high because of the record profits that oil companies have recorded the past few years, is lying to you for one of two reasons. They either don’t know the truth because they’ve been lied to OR they have an agenda to turn public opinion against the oil companies. With that being said, it is true that the oil companies have recorded record profits last year, but that’s because of the volume of oil they’ve sold, not because their profit margin (the average margin that determines how retailers and companies price their goods) has risen. The New York Daily News reports that the 5 biggest oil companies average profit margin from 2006-2010 was 6.65%. How high is that? Compare that to Apple’s 22% or Coca Cola’s 33%. Also know that oil companies need the profits to fund surveys to explore potential oil locations, costing billions per exploration and often times finding no oil. I’m not a champion of big oil, as I would be accused in Washington. I simply try my best to be an advocate of correcting people’s ignorance, lies, or lack of understanding. And to quote Barry Goldwater’s The Conscience of a Conservative, “… and that in that cause I am doing the best I can.”
Labels:
Drilling,
Gas Prices,
Obama,
Oil,
OPEC,
Regulations,
Speculation,
Steven Chu,
Texas
Thursday, June 23, 2011
An Overview and Possible Compromise on Foreign Policy
“Whatever it is that the government does, sensible Americans would prefer that the government does it to somebody else. This is the idea behind foreign policy.” - P.J. O'Rourke, Author/Humorist
“Here is my first principle of foreign policy: good government at home.” - William Gladstone, British Prime Minister
“Here is my first principle of foreign policy: good government at home.” - William Gladstone, British Prime Minister
The Issue: Involved Long-Term Alliances
The Republican View - My interpretation of the main stream republican view on alliances is that you can never have too many good friends. Almost anyone we’ve ever been good friends with is deserving of our support militarily, financially or both. And while most republicans complain about the UN and its leftist globalist view of things, republicans seem to be ok with listening to their orders to fight who they want, how they want, and where they want. Libya is a terrific example for both of these complaints. The UN warned that Libyan civilians may be killed so NATO sprung into action. France and Great Britain were the two primary countries who wanted this action, and we decided to join in. As of late many republicans have turned against the war, but at the very beginning their immediate reaction was to support it. Interestingly enough, the republican support came in spite of Defense Secretary Robert Gates’ warning against it and stating that there are no American interests present in this action. Since the beginning though, one of the biggest republican complaints was not that we are fighting on behalf of an Al-Qaeda backed group of rebels, or that the president didn’t consult Congress let alone seek a declaration of war, it was that the United States wasn’t “leading” on this issue. Yes, what really angered republicans was that an ally was “taking the lead” instead of us. The problem isn’t that we are broke, we don’t have anything to gain from this war, or that we are essentially aiding and abiding a group hell bent on destroying us and our allies; its that we weren’t the ones using the bully pulpit to try to suck our friends into the asinine war. Republicans want to bend over backwards to appease allies or do their best to make new ones from scratch (the reason we are still in Iraq and Afghanistan). Our good friend Iraq, who we fought and spent to liberate from Saddam Hussein voted to block Saudi Arabia’s proposal to increase OPEC’s oil drilling. That’s what friends are for, right? Saudi Arabia, which is the kind of friend who smack talks you behind your back and who only goes through the motions when it comes to your wish that they prevent people from training to kill you, still seems to be a much better friend than the friend you spent over a trillion dollars and thousands of lives to save. But… we don’t want to lose our friends do we?
The Libertarian View - Libertarians and Constitutionalists often site the words of our founding fathers when it comes to allies. This is best summed up by Thomas Jefferson’s phrase in his inaugural address, "peace, commerce, and honest friendship with all nations, entangling alliances with none." George Washington in his farewell address stated, “The great rule of conduct for us, in regard to foreign nations, is in extending our commercial relations, to have with them as little political connection as possible. Europe has a set of primary interests, which to us have none, or a very remote relation. Hence she must be engaged in frequent controversies the causes of which are essentially foreign to our concerns. Hence, therefore, it must be unwise in us to implicate ourselves, by artificial ties, in the ordinary vicissitudes of her politics, or the ordinary combinations and collisions of her friendships or enmities.” In case Washington’s words are a bit challenging to understand there, he was essentially saying “The best policy for us to follow when it comes to other countries is extending trade but to stay out of their politics. Their politics and policies has very little impact on us so it serves us best to stay out of their diplomatic relations with other countries.” James Monroe similarly stated, "In the wars of the European powers, in matters relating to themselves, we have never taken part, nor does it comport with our policy, so to do. It is only when our rights are invaded, or seriously menaced that we resent injuries, or make preparations for our defense." Libertarians generally want to be an economically and personally free version of Switzerland, who no one wants to attack. With that being said, libertarians still want the strongest military in the world, only without commitments and only intervening militarily whenever we are attacked. While I agree with their general sentiment, not having reliable allies can be problematic if in the event we do find ourselves threatened. And had we not embargoed Japan’s oil in the early 1940s, they never would’ve attacked Pearl Harbor and we may not have joined the war to stop Hitler.
The Compromise - We can have allies who have our back and whose back we have, without us having to fight for them when they are wrong or when they are handling business that is totally irrelevant to us. In the 1980s, we had no real meaningful involvement in the Falklands War between Great Britain and Argentina, aside from helping the British with some logistics. In the Sinai War between Great Britain, France, and Israel against Egypt in the 1950s, Eisenhower refused to get involved, aside from helping negotiate peace. Today, the thought of those three friends of ours getting in a war without us being involved seems incomprehensible. Yet, the “special relationship” as it is often called between England and the US suffered no long term ill effects, and obviously we are still very good friends with Israel, however France has become much more worthless since then. We can have a few very good friends who we will protect if they are attacked, but we don’t need to fight their wars for them, particularly if its of no interest or us or if they are on the wrong side legally/morally. I’m not saying that our friends have a habit of doing things that are wrong, but the distinction should be made anyway. If Israel, England, or Canada gets nuked we should definitely get their back. Otherwise it should be a case by case basis, with more often than not, us erring on the wisdom of our founding fathers.
The Issue: Terrorism - Its causes and how best to combat it
The Republican View - The republican view on terrorism after 9/11 was that its causation was because the terrorists hate our freedoms. In other words, terrorists blow themselves up and kill thousands of innocent civilians because they disapprove of our Constitutional liberties, and American culture makes low cut shorts acceptable for women and in some states gays can get married. As Americans began to realize how fallacious that argument was, they’ve now determined that terrorists act because they want a global Muslim caliphate (for everyone to live either under Sharia law or convert to Islam). As a result, most republicans prefer the strategy of fighting them “there” (the Middle East) so we don’t have to fight them here. Though traditionally a democrat ideology, republicans who support our current wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are supporting the idea of nation building. This includes building infrastructure, modern conveniences, and protecting the people of those countries in an attempt to modernize them and creating good will towards Americans and making them a future ally. Though also typically a democrat ideology, the republicans are insisting on carrying out this goal despite the unpopularity in the nations, because they believe that one day the peoples of those nations will come to the realization that they were wrong and the Americans were right.
The Libertarian View - Libertarians view Islamic terrorism as being the violent and savage reaction from our unwanted influence in the Middle East. This view is called unpatriotic and anti-American by a few prominent figures, but I’ve yet to determine if its because those individuals are uninformed, ignorant, or are just belligerent. To clarify, the libertarians obviously don’t view America as evil, just that the terrorists react savagely to our actions benevolent or otherwise. The equivalent would be if I see you drop a stack of papers and go to help you pick them up and then you stab me. I wasn’t wrong in my intention, I wanted to help you, but its quite clear you didn’t feel the same way about my help. Libertarians never bought into the argument of the terrorists hating our freedoms. When Bin Laden attacked us on 9/11, the messages he issued explaining his actions stated that this was retaliation. He viewed America at war with Islam for having a permanent military presence in the Middle East, most notably its bases in Saudi Arabia, which they view as a holy nation because Mecca and Medina lie within its borders. Also, he opposed the US’ temporary actions in Mogadishu (what the movie Black Hawk Down was about). The libertarian view is that we should do less of the things that make the Islamic radicals mad, so they’ll have less of a reason to despise us, and therefore there will be less terrorists. Just so there’s no confusion, libertarians obviously want to defend ourselves if we are attacked, they supported going into Afghanistan initially… They just don’t view us intervening as passing the cost-benefit test. But as you may be able to tell, at times this is in direct opposition to the Republican view.
The Compromise - The view terrorism in an economic style of breakdown. Lets say of the radical Islamic terrorists 20% of them hate us for our support of Israel, 15% hate us for our permanent military presence in the Middle East, 10% hate us because someone they knew was killed or heard people nearby were accidental civilian casualties, 10% want to the entire world to live under global Sharia law, 15% hate us because they view the Middle Eastern wars as a modern day crusade, and 35% hate us for supporting the dictators who have oppressed them for years. I have no idea what the actual percentage breakdown is or if I’m leaving out reasons why the terrorists and insurgents hate us, but for this example lets go with it. And lets say there’s 25,000 terrorists (just made that number up, I have literally no clue as to how many of them there are). Bin Laden for example didn’t organize the 9/11 attack because he wants global Sharia law, he hated Americans, Israel and their presence and influence in the Middle East. Though, chances are he probably wasn’t opposed to the idea, as one of his biggest issues was stopping American influence (culture and political) in the Middle East. By ending the Middle Eastern wars and withdrawing from the area, you could cut the number of terrorists by 15,000. So you could eliminate 60% terrorists and save money while doing so. and not necessarily generate pro-American support because our cultures are too far different and in some ways they are incompatible, but you could generate less anti-Americanism in the region. Changing the attitude of the populace over there from hating us like many Americans hated the Germans and Japanese during WWII to the way most Americans hate the French which isn’t passionate because we despise their arrogance, their attitude, their worthlessness, their stench, and such. Now, with this being said there’s still 10,000 terrorists to deal with. The remaining people, like the one’s who are influenced by radical imams who promote Sharia law in the West, and the family and friends of accidental civilian casualties are going to hate us until the day they die. Luckily in the Middle East they live in incredible poverty, so vast majority lack the means of extracting their vengeance. But more competent security at our ports, airports, and borders can keep us safe from them.
Lastly we come to the issue of Israel. Libertarians would say that Israel can handle its business just fine, as its demonstrated throughout the years; and that our influence on Israel has actually prevented her from attacking her enemies and signing non-American approved peace treaties. Republicans say that we need to keep financially supporting them and if needed, militarily supporting them as well. I believe that if the US were to cut off foreign aid to all nations (Israel would lose $4 billion a year, its surrounding countries that hate Israel would lose a combined $12 billion), Israel would still net benefit from the decision. I also believe that churches and synagogues across the country would raise money yearly to support them. We’ll say the sum total of the donation would be $2-2.5 billion. Israel getting that much a year with its opposition getting $0 still is a great benefit to Israel. I’m not sure if that’d less then the hate from the 20% of terrorists who hate us for our support of Israel, but we’d have no official tie they could point to. With that being said we could secretly tell Israel that if Israel were to get attacked, we’d bomb the Hell out of their attacker. The only drawback would be the potential moral hazard caused by them being maybe acting a bit more aggressively than they do, with their new found confidence. However, no deal is perfect, and overall this is probably much better than the status quo. Obviously this compromise favors a more libertarian view but it would make us safer, cost us less money and lives, and still allows for us to protect our good friend if needed.
The Issue: Our Overseas Commitments
The Republican View - The republican view of 800+ bases in well over 100 countries is that we need to be there to keep the peace and prevent hostilities from breaking out. They view us as a/the source of stability and removing us would cause absolute chaos.
The Libertarian View - The libertarian view of our commitments is that they put our troops in harms way, cost us over a hundred billion a year which doesn’t provide any conceivable benefit to us, and that it allows for more people to live under socialism because most countries we are in don’t spend near the amount on defense that most nations need, so essentially we are picking up the tab for their defense. Libertarians believe in self reliance, and other nations shouldn’t rely on us for their convenience.
The Compromise - I think we should eliminate all of our bases overseas aside from 20ish. The 20ish bases outside US territory would be for staging in case something big does break out and we MUST get in. The 20 bases would be in countries around the world that we are good friends with so that they receive the economic benefits from our troops spending money. The bases would reduce anti-American sentiment from nations who are tired of us being there (which is a lot of them). If a nation can afford its defense, it should pay for it. By providing defense for Canada, Europe, and Asian nations such as Japan and South Korea, we are allowing them to be more socialistic than is otherwise sustainable. In fact, the point I use in arguments to generate this point is that we are creating democrats overseas, i.e.: we are giving these nations handouts in the form of defense, when they should pay for their own. What we republicans and libertarians oppose is the welfare state, and that’s exactly what we’ve created by paying for the defense of so many nations. Donald Trump gained support for his remarks that nations that have our bases in their borders should pay us for the protection. Obviously this suggestion would help in terms of the financial issue our bases abroad cause… But our military shouldn’t be treated as mercenaries, if that’s what they wanted, they’d join a private security firm like Blackwater or enlist in the German military. Not to mention, there’s other issues of our government earning a profit to protect countries, we could easily extort more nations like the mafia does when they offer “protection” to small businesses. Third, if they pay us for the service, like a private citizen would a bodyguard, they may feel emboldened to start trouble, knowing they pay a flat rate for their protection. Our soldiers shouldn’t be put in harm’s way unless they are protecting and defending the Constitution of the United States from enemies foreign and domestic, as their oath states.
The Issue: Foreign Trade Policy
The Republican View - Republicans usually agree that free trade agreements are beneficial to both nations (supposing there isn’t an absolute advantage by one nation, also supposing the republican doesn’t represent a union area, and also supposing the “republican“ isn‘t Donald Trump). However, when it comes to countries that the United States has a volatile past with or that we are: at war with or are threatening with war, its common for us to embargo them or vote in the UN to put economic sanctions on. The only time many republicans sympathize with the UN is when the country is lobbying for the sanctioning of a country.
The Libertarian View - Libertarians, like republicans, support free trade. The difference is that libertarians view economic sanctions as an act of war, and oppose their use unless war is imminent or is in progress. Libertarians like most republicans, don’t like the UN, even if they are supporting an issue libertarians back, because the UN is a constant threat to our sovereignty as a nation. Libertarians also support trading with even unethical nations with terrible human rights records, such as Cuba.
The Compromise - One must ask themselves, “Do libertarians love communism or support the oppressive Castro regime?” No, libertarianism is essentially the antithesis to communism. The reason libertarians support trading with Cuba is because it will improve the quality of life of Cubans and will also benefit the US, being able to buy products they currently aren’t able to. Nations we trade with can often go from unfriendly to neutral or friendly. Vietnam and China are great examples, they were oppressive isolationist communists that we were hostile to; then we opened up trade with them. Since then, while both nations are still mostly communist and still have terrible human rights records, they are more prosperous and their citizens have much higher qualities of life. We should leave the UN, as we don’t need to be their police force to fight for causes they believe are just and pay hundreds of billions a year to have them tell us how we should act. Sanctions should also be saved for nations we are at war with. Most nations we are at war with have a terrible dictator at the helm, and very rarely do they care about the well-being of their people. When the UN was considering sanctions on Iran to try to discourage them from creating a nuclear weapon, the thought was that the economic hardships it would impose on Iran would stop their government from going through with it. The Islamo-fascist regimes in the Middle East are among the most oppressive in the world, its complete lunacy to think that they are going to react favorably. When the people of their country grow poorer and become unemployed, they aren’t going to blame their leaders more than they already do. They are going to view the United States and its allies as the reason they are going hungry. If you want Iran to ever rise up and overthrow the current regime, the best way to go about it is supporting the people covertly like we did in Afghanistan in the ‘80s, supporting mutually beneficial trade policies to help their people become more wealthy, and avoid angering them with policies that negatively impact them.
There are definitely some differences in the republican and libertarian views of foreign policy. To clarify, when I describe the republican views I’m more or less referring to either the RNC (Republican National Committee), or the views of the Republican leadership in DC, not all republicans. There is for example, the Republican Liberty Caucus, an organization in the Republican party for libertarians. In the House of Representatives there is a handful of RLC members and some libertarian-leaning conservative members who don’t subscribe to the republican party’s conventional wisdom. Despite the differences, compromise isn’t impossible. I wouldn’t expect us to embrace a fully libertarian view, and in some cases I don’t endorse a fully libertarian view. What’s important is for us to head in the right direction. We need to abandon “the conventional wisdom” that has landed us in the dire straights we find ourselves in on every front. We need to go back to policies that made us into the prosperous nation we are. We need to embrace liberty and look to the words of our founding fathers for wisdom. Doing this would lead us to a foreign policy that would make us: more prosperous, well-liked, richer, and safer.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)