I remember well listening to the healthcare debate on CSPAN Radio while at work. At the lunchtime intermission, CSPAN took callers from the respective phone lines they have set up for varied political persuasions. A caller to the democrat line stated her opinion in the form of a plea to the people that she didn't know if the healthcare bill was good or bad, but if we as a nation were going to fail due in part to healthcare costs, we needed to pass the bill to try something, anything; we couldn't just do nothing.
While her logic was flawed in a number of aspects, doing something just to do it almost never works out, especially if it’s the result of emotion and platitudes instead of rationalized thought. The lady had clearly just heard the republicans destroy the healthcare bill intellectually, and saw that the democrats’ rebuttal was mostly citing individual cases of alleged constituents of theirs with tragic stories of people without health insurance. However, she still wanted it passed because she's a democrat and she liked the president and perhaps she thought that the bill would defy all expectations and be an astounding success. But as she, and many Americans will eventually find out, just because something sounds good (and the healthcare bill doesn't even sound good) and because people may have good intentions (I'm not even convinced the democrats have good intentions), that it can have dire and unforeseen consequences. The healthcare bill will undoubtedly make healthcare worse and more costly. Thus passing Obamacare, just because the people who you like support it, is a piss poor reason for supporting policies.
Similarly, the war in Libya appears by all accounts to be poorly planned, without aforethought, without a stated objective and done without reason or sound rationale. Mixed messages by the president and his administration has left much of the public confused, are we there for purely humanitarian reasons or to overthrow Gaddafi? If we are there for humanitarian reasons, how come the Iraq war was a bad idea? Obama's defense of his action in Libya could perfectly fit in for Bush's defense of Iraq. If we are there for humanitarian reasons there are a number of other countries around the world or next door that represent much more atrocious humanitarian crisis; the Ivory Coast being a perfect example. If we are there for "national interests", which is a euphemism for oil, Iraq has much more of it and also at present; Libya doesn't sell us any... However they do sell the British and French oil, which may answer why they wanted this action so badly. Gaddafi is a terrible dictator who deserves the worst fate imaginable. His support of the Lockerbie bomber is reason enough to kill him. But, it’s not that easy, it never is. Hand picking his successor isn't easy and generally backfires and results in further hatred and discontent at America. We also convinced Gaddafi to give up his nuclear weapons program during the Iraq War and gave him foreign aid. We obviously wouldn't have attacked him if he still had nukes. But as an unfortunate side effect, it’s very unlikely that any other 3rd world hostile dictator to disarm, as now they've seen the result first hand. Remember in 2006 when NBC news started to say (and eventually had to stop) that the United States was in the middle of a civil war in Iraq? That wasn’t true then, but it certainly is true now, as 2 forces are competing for control of the government of the nation.
No one knows who the Libyan rebels are. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said that most of the insurgents we fought for years in Iraq came from East Libya, which strangely, appears to be the rebel stronghold. Furthermore Gaddafi has stopped supporting terrorism, which is more than can be said for the Libyan rebels. The Libyan rebels are also supported by longer term US ally, Al-Qaeda... wait no, that’s not right... That’s right; their mission statement involves killing us and Israel. Well that’s good, I'm glad we found common ground with Al-Qaeda, maybe we can put aside our differences and finally break bread with them. Likely the rebels are a mixture of disgruntled Libyan citizens who would like to live in a democracy, some are rebelling over the rising food prices, others are extreme Muslims who don't want to live in such a secular state, and others are flat out terrorists. The problem is, even if the rebels are temporarily pro-American, likely when they realize that the US will have a long term presence in Libya and the Middle East, our good relations will quickly turn into a fierce hatred as it will further appear we are trying to conquer Islam in their eyes. This will be ignored in the US, as it usually is, because we Americans have more important things to tend to like Charlie Sheen and the latest celebrity couple splitting. You'll have the same old neo-conservatives clamoring for us to invade claiming the Libyans hate our freedom. And hopefully we'll be on guard, because the US will have yet another country with radical Islamists wanting to attack us; as if the ones currently in existence aren't numerous enough. Think of our foreign policy in the Middle East like the deals democrats give to unions to support their outrageous pensions, the damage and problems take years and years to brew and only become a threat after the issue has been out of the limelight and the parties directly responsible have long since retired. It’s important to realize that just because Americans have forgotten about an issue or as a whole are informed about it, doesn’t mean the extremists and radicals elsewhere have. They don’t forgive and forget over there, look at the ancient rivalries that are still in effect over there (Israel vs. everyone, India vs. Pakistan). Remember the sanctions on Iraq under Clinton, fought for by Madeleine Albright? Estimates from a wide variety of sources say that the sanctions killed anywhere from 100,000 to 1.7 million from 1991-1998. We may have forgotten about it, but I assure you, the Iraqis never did. Albright later told 60 Minutes in an interview, “We believe it was worth it.” The deaths of innocents like that only work to radicalize otherwise peaceful moderate Muslims. We will never know if it was worth it, because there is no way to directly track the actions of the friends and families of the effected victims.
Aside from the action clearly not demonstrating the necessary cost-benefit to be considered worthwhile, still other issues persist. The president did not get Congressional approval for the action, which the Constitution requires. We haven’t declared war since 1941, which incidentally, may have been the only Constitutional action to have occurred under FDR. Just because we have a recent history of ignoring the Constitution, doesn’t mean it’s acceptable. Historical precedent and legality are nowhere near the same thing. Does anyone think that the interment of the Japanese was Constitutional under FDR? Clearly not, but just because we’ve done it in the past doesn’t mean we have the authority to do it again “if necessary”. Radio host Mark Levin recently called out local columnist, author, and radio host Jack Hunter for his criticism of the action in Libya. Mark Levin supported the Iraq war, which also was never properly declared by Congress (they abdicated their war powers authorizing the president to take action he saw fit). Levin, in order to not sound like a hypocrite, takes no issue with Obama’s “kinetic military action” without Congressional approval; he even has the nerve to cite past related interventions as the reason the action is Constitutional.
Force is sometimes necessary, but issues like this shouldn’t be given a blind eye to, by the people. Conservatives who know the government’s inefficiency, ineffectiveness, and lack of success domestically often fall into the trap of viewing adventures like this as a good idea. Liberals who typically prefer to not go to war, blindly support their favorite politician’s actions without question. My plea to the readers of this blog is to explore all sides of any issue and never succumb to pre-conceived notions and emotional reactions. Always look for aspects that aren’t obvious. This blog was created to aid inquiring minds in that effort, and my hope is that is has and will in the future.
No comments:
Post a Comment