One of the more well known parts of Plato’s The Republic is the Allegory of the Cave. The Allegory is a fictional conversation between Plato’s teacher Socrates, and Plato’s brother Glaucon. In the dialogue, Socrates describes a group of people who have lived chained to the wall of a cave their entire lives staring at a blank wall. The people watch shadows projected on the wall by things passing in front of a fire behind them, and ascribe forms to these shadows (much like the activity of ascribing shapes to clouds). According to Socrates, the shadows are as close as the prisoners get to viewing reality. He then explains how the philosopher (someone who is a philosopher, metaphorically speaking) is like a prisoner who is freed from the cave and comes to understand that the shadows on the wall do not make up reality at all, as he can perceive the true form of reality rather than the mere shadows seen by the prisoners. Since the prisoners have been kept in there and chained since childhood, Socrates suggests the prisoners would take the shadows to be real things and the echoes to be real sounds, not just reflections of reality, since they are all they had ever seen or heard. They would praise as clever whoever could best guess which shadow would come next, as someone who understood the nature of the world, and the whole of their society would depend on the shadows on the wall.
Socrates then supposes further that a prisoner released to go experience the real world outside would become acclimated to the new reality and environment. He would observe nature and the sun and the four seasons. Socrates and Glaucon then discuss the events that would transpire if he were to return to the cave. Plato writes that Socrates contemplates, “And wouldn't he disdain whatever honors, praises, and prizes were awarded there to the ones who guessed best which shadows followed which? Moreover, were he to return there, wouldn't he be rather bad at their game, no longer being accustomed to the darkness? Wouldn't it be said of him that he went up and came back with his eyes corrupted, and that it's not even worth trying to go up? And if they were somehow able to get their hands on and kill the man who attempts to release and lead up, wouldn't they kill him?"
If the concept sounds familiar, it was a source of inspiration for the movie The Matrix (The obvious difference being that Plato is a genius and The Matrix totally sucks). The philosopher in this allegory isn’t too different from today’s free thinkers. And not a free thinker in the sense of the college Marxist who views himself as enlightened and everyone else as a philistine. But, look at Glenn Beck for example, who is attacked by the left constantly, but also by republican hacks on the right, such as Bill Krystol. Once you show people the error of their ways, there is often blowback driven by denial, corruption, pride, or emotion. Many well known conservative media personalities seem to spit out the same dribble as the others without questioning their well-recited dogma and orthodoxy and talking points. When it comes to bettering ones own understanding, presenting a good argument, or convincing others to adopt your point of view, honesty is the best policy. But also showing that you can be objective, willing to call out your own side when they screw up. Most people don’t want to hear the blunders of those they like, but accepting that there is no perfect broadcaster or politician is the first step to furthering one’s own ideology. Focusing on issues that matter, regardless of their complexity is also of the utmost importance. Convincing someone with mental problems to vote republican may cause more harm than good in the long run. When Snookie, of Jersey Shore fame, boasted she voted for John McCain, I was embarrassed. I didn’t vote for John McCain (or Obama, obviously), but having a complete idiot endorse beliefs similar to yours is a set back to the cause. You wouldn’t want an employee of your business to wear their work uniform while causing a drunken scene in public; it obviously reflects negatively on your establishment and all things associated with it. The ability to back up your argument with facts and statistics and in a manner which can be understood is key. Here are a few misguided topics that some mainstream conservative personalities talk about or focus on.
- Obama saying, “I believe in American exceptionalism, just as I suspect that the Brits believe in British exceptionalism and the Greeks believe in Greek exceptionalism.” Now this is important, because this is an issue that has been blown out of proportion. First off, the Brits and the Greeks probably do view themselves as exceptional. Look at the history of both of those nations, they have much to be proud of. The Brits controlled most of the world a few centuries ago, despite being a fairly small cold rainy island in Western Europe. The Greeks had some of the best thinkers in human history and produced cultures like Athens and Sparta. The United States is the biggest debtor in the history of the world that has a number of countries leaching off its success. We aren’t in an enviable position at the moment. Wouldn’t American Exceptionalism mean that the US is great and we are invulnerable so the threats that other nations face with debt, a weak economy, and enemies foreign and domestic don’t concern us like they would un-exceptional nations? I view “exceptionalism” as an arrogance and ignorance that “we can bend the rules because they don’t apply to us”. I think American exceptionalism was on display when LBJ implemented his “Great Society”, deciding that we could fight a long bloody war in Vietnam and implement costly socialistic entitlements that ended up decimating the black community and American society as a whole. The mindset of “We’re Americans so a poor economy, an inability to secure our borders, socialist domestic policies, record deficits and an overextended military don’t worry us; we can afford it all. The economy won’t crash, we’re American, damn it“. America is an idea, an idea that represents civil, personal, and economic liberty. Going away from such principles makes us just like everyone else. America is exceptional because of the freedoms and liberties we have/had, the idea that American exceptionalism and patriotism as being the same thing is ridiculous. A teenager who thinks he’s invulnerable and gets seriously hurt while drinking and driving believes he’s exceptional. He knows drinking and driving is bad, but he can do it, he’s different. This is an issue trumpeted by republican hacks like Sean Hannity and neo-conservatives like Bill O’Reilly.
- Misinformation about Ronald Reagan is also rampant amongst both political ideologies. Republicans portray Reagan as a secular messiah and democrats portray him as the anti-Christ. Reagan was obviously a great president to say the least, probably one of the two best of the 20th century. But having Reagan as a demigod is quite dangerous, as it allows every politician including democrats, moderates, independents, and republicans to rally around a figure that seemingly rode a big blue ox, was able to outwork a machine drilling railroad spikes, and leapt tall buildings in a single bound. Every republican says he’s a Reagan republican or a Reagan conservative, and when asked what that means exactly, the reply will be a basic description of conservative platforms without specifics. The mentioning of Reagan’s name is meant to invoke feelings of trust, conservative policies, and republican unity. Lindsey Graham probably loves the hell out of Reagan too, if in the event you’re attending a speech he’s giving about how we need to invade North Korea, Syria and Iran; and that we need to pass Cap N Trade, and give amnesty to every illegal alien, you’d likely get angry. Knowing that you oppose such policies, and being a predictable crappy politician, he’ll likely toss out some Ronald Reagan praise to appease you. Praise of Reagan is supposed to make actual conservatives think, “oh, well… This guys policies may completely suck and will further the wrecking of our country, but we both like the same president, I’ll vote for him anyway”. Charlie Crist, before he dropped out of the republican party to run as an independent in the Florida senate race, said is idol was Reagan; as did his primary competitor Marco Rubio. In the 2008 Republican Presidential Debate at the Reagan Library, one of the questions asked to the candidates was “if he were still alive, which of you would Ronald Reagan support in the primary?”. Obviously every candidate thought Reagan would endorse him. Hannity often spars with democrat Bob Beckel on his TV and radio shows; and being a stereotypical conservative, Hannity invokes Reagan’s name into a number of discussions on any number of topics. Hannity praises and brings attention to the success of Reagan-omics, pulling the US out of the economic mess brought on by Jimmy Carter. However, Hannity usually ignores Beckel’s attempts to correct the record of the truth behind Reagan’s tax policy; Reagan, by 1988 had raised other taxes enough that in the end, it was a net increase since becoming president. Reagan also granted amnesty to illegals and grew the size of the national debt by a substantial amount. Reagan has so many accomplishments that its pointless to begin listing them, however the point of this is to beware of blind praise of Reagan and realize that in the end its often meaningless hubris. An interesting debate transpires when the collapse of the Soviet Union is brought up. Many liberals still try to argue that Truman’s strategy of containment is the main reason the cold war ended. Seeing as Truman’s administration had no shortage of Soviet agents in it and also considering his warm relationship with “Uncle Joe” (Stalin)… I’m sure whatever strategy he came up with was very effective in its job of stopping the spread of communism. However, republicans often seem to be under the impression that Reagan’s military build up and hard lining is the only reason the Soviet Union came crashing down. It is true that, that had a lot to do with, the other half though is because simply collectivism and communism fail as economic policies. When Hannity argues that the Soviet Union collapsed purely because of Reagan, he isn’t completely wrong. Without Reagan, the USSR would’ve been around longer and depending on the circumstances, the cold war could’ve turned into an actual “shooting war”. Reagan deserves endless credit for his actions. However, where Hannity is shortsighted is in his negligence to give some credit where credit is due, which is to capitalism, the best economic system man has ever contrived. Capitalism will always trump communism, the technology and revenue that capitalism is able to generate over socialism is a fact that conservatives shouldn’t just admit, they should champion at every opportunity. Ronald Reagan, understanding and praising free market capitalism, would likely agree. Not that it really matters though.
- Bush’s fiscal policy is rejected by almost every conservative at this point, but still some apologists for him try to say “Obama’s deficit is an awful $1.5T (true statement), but Bush’s was only an average of $250B, so it wasn’t that bad!”. The claim of Bush’s average budget deficit ranges to a bit higher and a bit lower than that figure. Bush’s 8 years raised our national debt around $5T, so anyone who says his deficit was anything less than $500B, is trying to mislead you. Bush’s wars took place off the budget, all war spending was listed as “emergency spending” and thus went directly on the credit card instead of the budget. I’m not defending Obama, obviously I believe he’s the worst president since FDR; however if conservatism is to prevail, we must be honest with ourselves and with people we are trying to win over.
- Our trade policy with impoverished nations with authoritarian governments should also be revisited. When economic sanctions are put on a country, not only is it an act of war (its essentially a modern day blockade), but it rarely seems to hurt the nation’s dictatorial government. The common man is the one starving, and not receiving the food and revenue he’d otherwise get. At the end of Mao’s rule of China, he probably still thought communism was great, because he wasn’t one of the tens of millions dying from starvation. So when republicans were clamoring for sanctions of Iran last year, remember that won’t hurt Ahmadinejad or the ayatollah, that’ll hurt the citizenry of Iran. And the people of the Iran, unlike most of their other Arab counterparts, are fairly intelligent, educated, and most shockingly, pro-American. Hurting them is a good way to bring about the end of their well wishes. Vietnam is a country that we were engaged in an ill advised war in 40 years ago. Since then we’ve taken a different approach with them. The United States is a trade partner of theirs, and guess what. Their economy has grown substantially, and its on the rise. The people of Vietnam are wealthier than they’ve ever been, and as time goes on, capitalism grows more and more within their borders. Vietnam isn’t politically free at all, they have a 1 party system, the Communist Party of Vietnam. Yet through our influence, the people of Vietnam have seen how we live and how our economy works and have adopted many of our successful ideologies. Perhaps one day they’ll be both politically and economically free, without American blood and treasure being spent. The Castros in Cuba are obviously anti-American, but Cuban Americans are generally fairly conservative, as they realize the damages of communism. Showing Cubans the power of capitalism could one day free them from the poverty and propaganda they experience on a daily basis. As we’ve already explored, this is perhaps doable without pulling a trigger.
- WikiLeaks is another issue that causes conservatives to become belligerent. The media hype over the damage done by WikiLeaks is almost as greatly exaggerated as the reports of Mark Twain’s death. No one can point to any damage caused by them, they can only use fear and demagoguery (it’s almost bad enough to rise to the level of the democrats on domestic policies) in order to scare you and make you hate them. An informed populace is vital to America. Why shouldn’t Americans know that our Pakistani “allies” are taking our billions and are helping to support Al Qaeda or that America was trying to pay China to cut their emissions at Copenhagen. When the riots were first starting to occur in Libya, most major news organizations used WikiLeaks as their source of information. Pvt. Bradley Manning, the soldier who released the information to them is a traitor and should be executed. Ann Coulter was making an appearance on Fox News’ Red Eye and was railing against Julian Assange, telling the host what charges he should be brought up on. In the middle of her case against Assange, another panelist on the show butted in and asked if Coulter agreed with Assange’s opinion that Hillary Clinton should resign from her position as secretary of state, because of her intimidation, blackmailing, and cover-ups. As soon as Coulter was informed that Assange made that statement, Coulter then remarked that perhaps he wasn’t as bad as she had originally thought. But Coulter and the other folks who focus on WikiLeaks as the “Great Satan” that needs to be shut down are angry at the wrong thing. Don’t get mad at WikiLeaks for trying to inform you that your government is feeding you lies and propaganda. That would be like shouting down and murdering the philosopher who is trying to show you the truth, enlightenment, and the error of your current understanding.
No comments:
Post a Comment