Tuesday, May 17, 2011

My Philosophy on Voting + 2012 Candidate Analysis

“Always vote for principle, though you may vote alone, and you may cherish the sweetest reflection that your vote is never lost.” – John Quincy Adams

“Under democracy one party always devotes its chief energies to trying to prove that the other party is unfit to rule - and both commonly succeed, and are right” – H.L. Mencken

A vote to me is perhaps one of the most personal and serious actions you can experience in a lifetime. I consider it to be the equivalent of a secular prayer; it’s something that I must do to in order to show my appreciation for our founding fathers. Voting also allows me to do what I can by voting for people that I’m reasonably sure will take positions that will ultimately lead to prosperity and freedom for Americans. I will only vote for a candidate that I view will not contribute to the continuing decline of our nation; which I view as the vast majority of politicians out there. If my candidate doesn’t win, then so be it. I may be angry, or bitter; but it’s likely that my favorite candidates never really stood a chance anyway. The reason that many of the people I admire don’t have a chance is because; they may or may not possess give wonderful speeches, have indescribable amounts of charisma, or be in tune with pop culture goings on. I hold voting in such high regard because when I vote, regardless of the outcome, have tried to restore our city, county, state, or nation to the prosperity it once had. In 2008 when the republicans put up John McCain as their candidate and the democrats put up Barrack Obama, I voted for the libertarian candidate Bob Barr. I understand that third parties don’t stand a chance for the most part, but if I know that both major party candidates will be destructive to our country, why would I possibly vote for them? Voting for the lesser of the evils, still means you’ve voted for an evil. What good person can possibly, in good conscience, vote for someone who you’re fairly sure would enact a decent amount of destructive policies; regardless of who their main competition is? If an individual doesn’t have principles, then they are nothing. They are just like the charlatans in office who spend most of their time trying to lie to the public about the details of the legislation they are working on with equally immoral people.

At the end of my days, I don’t want to have to explain myself to the younger generations and tell them that I helped elect, and continued to help elect candidates that were going to make terrible decisions, because potentially that politicians’ main rival would’ve made more terrible decisions. Ronald Reagan famously said, “The person who agrees with you 80 percent of the time is a friend and an ally — not a 20 percent traitor.” That may be true, but why not stand in opposition to the damaging 20% as well? I may be able to work with that person, the far majority of the time, but hell if I want to endorse someone who I KNOW is going to make our country 20% worse. I’ve yet to find any political candidate whose views are 100% in line with mine; however there are some well into the 90s. Unfortunately though, many of the politicians I most agree with died decades or centuries ago.

Opponents to third parties often say that voting third party is throwing your vote away. I can’t imagine a bigger waste of a vote than voting for someone like John McCain, who at best agrees with me 60% of the time. Endorsing worthless republicans will just perpetuate the amount of worthless republicans in the future. If I can subvert the efforts of the Republican Party in their nominating such worthless politicians, by showing them that I can’t vote for anyone who isn’t at least 90% in agreement with me, I’ll gladly do it. Some republicans and talk radio hosts would claim that by advocating a third party, I’m helping Obama get re-elected. My answer to that is this: While the consequence of me voting for a third party is that the republican won’t get my vote, their insinuation is that my vote was actually owned by the republicans and I had the nerve to take it away. In no way am I beholden to them, if they wanted my vote they’d nominate a candidate that was going to be serious about constitutionally limited government and a smarter foreign policy. By nominating piles of crap like John McCain, they have declared to me, that my vote wasn’t important to them.

Senator Arlen Specter (D, then R, then D-PA) famously said, “I didn’t leave the Republican Party, it left me”. Well, Senator Specter is an idiot and left the party because he knew he was going to face a challenger in the primary and would probably lose, so he switched parties hoping to avoid a primary (and that didn‘t work out too well for him). Regardless, his quote would be true for me, if I had been cognizant and of voting age back in the Reagan years and times previous. In reality, I became of age to vote in 2004, and even though in my ignorance I voted straight ticket then; the Republican Party at that point didn’t represent any recognizable conservatism. How can I possibly get them to return to the ideologies of Reagan, Goldwater, Taft and such by voting for Bush and McCain? Although people can deny it as much as they want, “what you reward you get more of“. The only way to change the party is by voting in the primary and trying to educate the public, when that fails, you cannot sit idly by and continue to support them. When it comes to people like that, I think to myself something much like Jesus said while on the cross, “Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do”. But on my gravestone, I want a message written to show my ideology and dedication; I want that message to say, “Let it not be said that no one cared, that no one objected once it was realized that our liberties and wealth were in jeopardy.” (Quote by Ron Paul, with tenses modified for eulogy purposes.

With that being said I’m going to break down the major candidates who are expected to run. I’ll give a little background, and analyze factors like their: electability, upsides, downsides, and if I can or cannot vote for them.

Mitt Romney - Former governor of Massachusetts, successful businessman and 2008 presidential candidate
Upside - Successful track record in business. Helped a number of businesses and events turn a profit and/or stay in business after they looked like lost causes. His experience as a business profitability consultant can perhaps help “operate government like a business” as the cliché goes. Everyone wants a businessman in office it seems.
Downside - He is known for his flip-flopping on issues to try making him more electable in Massachusetts and as president. His political record isn’t impressive in terms of the legislation he signed into law. He’d essentially have to run against his past political career and stances, with the biggest albatross around his neck being Romneycare (the basis for Obamacare). He has no discernable principles and he stands as one of the many worthless neo-conservatives in the field.
Electable – At the 2011 CPAC Ann Coulter said, “If we don’t run Chris Christie, Romney will be the nominee and we’ll lose.” Well Chris Christie isn’t running, but she’s right about Romney’s viability. I don’t think he can make it out of the primary. Usually I’m fairly embarrassed of my state’s religious bigotry when it comes to non-protestants… But in this case, I’m pretty happy it means Romney can’t win here, even if he didn’t pass Romneycare.
Can I vote for him? - Hell no.

Ron Paul – Doctor and current congressman from Texas. Often called “the godfather of the Tea Party”
Upside – Ron Paul has perhaps the most consistent record in American history. He is well known for his principled fights on just about every fiscal or Constitutional issue. He has never supported an unconstitutional bill or voted for an unbalanced budget. He is known for his ability to rally the youth to his causes, and known for never compromising. Ron Paul’s nickname is “Dr. No”, a reference to his record number of votes where he votes against the majority 434-1. He is also known for his opposition to typical republican foreign policy ideology and stance on the Federal Reserve, two issues which he has brought to the forefront in American politics.
Downside – At times he is perhaps too much of a civil libertarian for even the libertarian-leaning conservatives. An example of this would be his position on giving trials to Guantanamo inmates. He also said in a radio interview that had he been in office, he would’ve sought permission from Pakistan to take Bin Laden alive. This angered people because we haven’t respected other nation’s sovereignty and international law for so long, that starting to do so seems extreme.
Electable - Many republicans and conservative commentators still don’t take him seriously and consider him to be “fringe”. In 2008, he was held out of a debate in New Hampshire, put on by Fox News. He often receives little or negligible media coverage, despite his frequent appearances. A number of his stances are either little known by the public, which, in conjunction with the media’s belittlement, tends to make him misunderstood as well as a constant underdog.
Can I vote for him? There’d be no greater privelage I could possibly receive.

Mitch Daniels - Current 2-term Indiana governor and successful businessman.
Upside - He has reduced the size of Indiana’s government, with several entities being leased to private companies for operation. He has been a fiscal hawk, and also has shown that he’s not power hungry like some other nominees by declining an appointment to the senate to fill Vice President Dan Quayle’s void. He has taken on the unions in a northern state and also said that he’d cut some of the pentagon’s budget, again showing fearlessness when it comes to the “third rails” of politics.
Downside – Compared to Obama, he’s fairly mild and meek, and doesn’t ooze charisma. He also angered some social conservatives by saying that in this session (2 year period of the state legislature agenda) he’d agree to a truce on social issues, in order to put fiscal issues to the forefront. However, recently he did defund (take away state funding from) Planned Parenthood in Indiana, showing that the truce was very short lived.
Electable – Yes, in both the primary and general, as his past is free from scandals. His wife may receive some tough scrutiny though, because she left Mitch and the kids to go marry a man in California. A few years later, the marriage ended in divorce and she remarried Mitch. This is probably the reason she stays out of the spotlight and seems to be one of the reasons the governor hasn’t been more “gung ho” in getting in the race.
Can I vote for him? – Yes, he’s about the only more “mainstream” candidate I can get behind, so far.

Rick Santorum – Former Pennsylvania congressman and senator.
Upside – As he points out, quite often, he was able to win elections in overwhelmingly majority-democrat districts. And, if able to catch momentum, could easily sweep the Southern primaries with his record of social conservatism.
Downside – When it comes to electability, I’m not sure he has a chance to win a senate seat again in PA, let alone carry it in a general election. Rick Santorum defines himself as a “compassionate conservative”, the premise there being that other forms of conservative are uncompassionate. Also, if that term sounds familiar, it’s because that’s the phrase President Bush used to describe himself. Electing Santorum in virtually every way seems like giving Bush a 3rd term.
Electable – In the south and Midwest, it wouldn’t be a problem. Obama will be much weaker this go-around than in 2008. Whether he can beat Obama remains to be unseen. My sincere hope is that he isn’t given the chance.
Can I vote for him? – I’d probably rather watch Tron on a continuous loop, while wearing Gamecock apparel than vote for Rick Santorum.

Tim Pawlenty – Former two term governor of Minnesota.
Upside – Governor Pawlenty received an A Rating from the CATO Institute regarding his fiscal record as governor. Another upside to Pawlenty is his popularity in his overwhelmingly blue state, the only state in 1984 that Reagan didn’t win.
Downside – Pawlenty supported having a “sensible” Cap N Trade-type policy and even made an ad supporting it. He has come out publically and admitted that his support for the policy was stupid and that he wasn’t aware of all the downsides at the time. He also seems too establishment, as it’s hard to distinguish where he separates from a number of other mainstream republican figures.
Electable – Pawlenty can probably beat Obama, however his problem is that he needs to become much more popular to win the primaries. He currently has low name recognition even in some nearby Midwest states.
Can I vote for him? – Doubtful, the issue being that his CPAC 2011 speech focused on a number of republican foreign policy talking points that I have grown to hate. The speech itself wasn’t necessarily the problem; so much as I’m not going to vote for another neo-con. He’s going to have to show an independent streak and show me that he’s not another republican pentagon robot.

Gary Johnson – Former two term governor of New Mexico and successful businessman.
Upside – As a libertarian, I like Gary Johnson because he too is a libertarian leaning republican. He’s an extreme fiscal hawk and has no sacred cow that he isn’t willing to cut. A number of his views are controversial, but he backs them all up with facts and statistics, showing that he’s very well researched and unafraid to tackle the issues. I also like that he had the foresight to oppose Iraq from the beginning and support Afghanistan initially.
Downside – He has low name recognition and seems to be viewed as sort of “the other libertarian”. He’s going to have to show people his stance on certain social issues doesn’t alienate him from the party’s base, which is likely an uphill battle.
Electable – In the general election, I think he can give Obama a run for his money. He was a very popular governor in a blue state. He is pro-choice, which isn’t necessarily typical of republicans, but he explains that he views it as a state’s rights issue and that he’d sign a ban on partial birth abortions. Unfortunately I think the primary is the limit for Gary Johnson, but I have hope that he’ll run for the open senate seat in NM in 2012.
Can I vote for him? Yes.

Newt Gingrich – Former Speaker of the house 1996-1999 from Georgia.
Upside – High name recognition and lots of experience. Newt is often hailed as one of the smartest people in politics. He is well known for balancing the budget in consecutive years under a democrat president.
Downside – Newt has a past of cheating on wives, and while that may not be a deal breaker in democrat circles, it’s going to be hell for him trying to defend that in the religious south. Newt also supported Cap N Trade and calls Paul Ryan’s Pathway to Prosperity “right-wing social engineering”. Newt also supported the concept of an individual mandate, a key tenant of Obamacare.
Electable – If you’ve read Newt’s downside, you now know that he’s unelectable and can’t make it far in the primary… or the general.
Can I vote for him? No.

I want to give an analogy to how I view our current situation. We as a nation are a car, 2 miles away from driving off a cliff. When the democrats drive they are going 200 mph towards the cliff, while they are drinking champagne and living it up, and obviously calling anyone who dares to question the logic of our current trajectory, a racist. When the republicans take the wheel, they slow the car down to a “reasonable” 120 mph while heading the same direction. The republicans are telling us this is the responsible thing to do and that eventually, if you give them enough time, it’ll be alright. Questioning the republicans trajectory will get you called unpatriotic. Unless I’m sure the person I’m voting for is going to hit the brakes immediately or slow down to pull a U-turn before we drive off a cliff, I can’t vote for them.

I personally take responsibility for Bush’s actions from 2004-2008, Henry Brown’s actions from 2004-2010, and so on and so forth. If I vote for someone who does a terrible job, then I’m responsible for their actions, as I have enabled it. Another example of how I view this is this: I’m against “No Child left Behind” but I supported a president and congressman who passed it, therefore it doesn’t matter that I opposed it, because I enabled it. I’m against the war in Iraq, but almost every politician I’ve voted for is for it, therefore it doesn’t matter that I’m against it, because I’ve enabled the people to keep us there. My way of looking at this, isn’t inspiring or uplifting, but its important that voters as well as the politicians are held responsible for their actions.

In closing, I want to leave you with this quote, it’s one that inspired me to be principled in my actions and views. "The turn will come when we entrust the conduct of our affairs to the men who understand that their first duty as public officials is to divest themselves of the power that they have been given. It will come when Americans, in hundreds of communities throughout the nation, decide to put the man in office who is pledged to enforce the Constitution and restore the Republic. Who will proclaim in a campaign speech: 'I have little interest in streamlining government or in making it more efficient, for I mean to reduce its size. I do not undertake to promote welfare, for I propose to extend freedom. My aim is not to pass laws, but to repeal them. It is not to inaugurate new programs, but to cancel the old ones that do violence to the Constitution, or that have failed in their purpose, or that impose on the people an unwarranted financial burden. I will not attempt to discover whether legislation is “needed” before I have first determined whether it is constitutionally permissible. And if I should later be attacked for neglecting my constituents’ “interests,” I shall reply that I was informed their main interest is liberty and that in that cause I am doing the very best I can.” – Senator Barry Goldwater

No comments:

Post a Comment