"A politician needs the ability to foretell what is going to happen tomorrow, next week, next month, and next year. And to have the ability afterwards to explain why it didn't happen.” - Winston Churchill
“Ninety percent of the politicians give the other ten percent a bad reputation.” - Henry Kissinger
“Ninety percent of the politicians give the other ten percent a bad reputation.” - Henry Kissinger
Let me start off by saying that I have the utmost respect for our military, both active and retired. They have demonstrated more courage than I could possibly imagine. My views on the pentagon budget, foreign policy, and views such as this article aren’t by any stretch of the imagination, supposed to portray our military as incompetent, cowardly, corrupt or anything of the like. It is the politicians, the beau racy, and the asinine logic that comes with government, that I dislike, not the men and women who protect us.
A popularly held view, particularly amongst republicans, and some veterans is the idea that the office of the President of the United States should be occupied by only those with military service. And in some ways it seems to make sense, the Commander in Chief, having experience in serving our great nation. Someone who has a direct understanding of how the military operates and the inner workings of it all. When the term “military veteran” is uttered, it invokes feelings of brave and honorable men and women who possess great integrity stand for everything that’s right about America. I feel the same way, however just like with any profession the 1% argument holds true… as the cliché goes, 99% of cops are good, it’s the 1% that gives cops a bad reputation. The same is true with some veterans.
Most Americans are aware that it takes a special kind of smooth talking, well connected, and soul-less bastard to get far in politics. The kind of person that can look you in the eye and promise you the world, knowing the entire time they are lying. And this is true with a number of the veterans who are politicians in Washington, DC; both today and in the past. Its quite possible that the veterans, while active duty, were honorable men with impeccable integrity who have lost it along the way; its also possible that these men never possessed it. That is not only hard to determine, but is inconsequential to the thrust of my argument. Most of our presidents have been veterans, and we’ve had a fair amount of good presidents, and we’ve had even more bad or mediocre presidents. The body of this posting with analyze military veterans to serve as president from 1900 - present. The reason for me choosing only presidents of the past 111 years is because it’d be unfair for every veteran to be compared to the likes of George Washington and as time has gone on, presidential policy has had greater and greater effect on society as the size and scope of government has grown.
Theodore Roosevelt (Republican, 1901-1909) - Served as a colonel in the Spanish-American War, and famously led the “Rough Riders”. Teddy Roosevelt was undoubtedly a badass in many ways. While giving a campaign speech, he was shot by a would-be assassin, but refused to seek immediate medical assistance in order to finish giving his speech. He was also full of charisma, an example being “teddy bears” him. However, while Roosevelt was probably not the first president who used what is referred to as “the cult of personality” to his advantage, he was the one who set the trend for the rest of the 20th century’s presidents. Roosevelt’s view of property rights were very much at odds with that of our founding fathers and the Constitution. Examples of this are found in the following quotes, “Every man holds his property subject to the general right of the community to regulate its use to whatever degree the public welfare may require it” and “We grudge no man a fortune in civil life if it is honorably obtained and well used . . . so long as the gaining represents benefit to the community.”
Something that should stand out to you in these quotes is that Roosevelt feels like he as well as the general public have a right to tell you what to do with the money you’ve earned and the property you own. In addition, what he feels like you should do is something that benefits communities as a whole. Seemingly in Roosevelt’s ideal world, every house would feature public restrooms and their yards would be public parks and playgrounds. Another startling statement comes from this Roosevelt Socialist Freudian slip, “I have always believed that it would also be necessary to give the National Government complete power over the organization and capitalization of all business concerns engaged in inter-State commerce”. The Cato Institute gives a pretty good summary of some policies that Roosevelt is best known for when they wrote, “In 1906 came the Pure Food and Drug Act and the Meat Inspection Act. TR pushed both laws largely in response to muckraking journalists, especially the socialist Upton Sinclair, author of The Jungle, a novel. Despite Sinclair’s propaganda, a government report confirmed that the novel’s claims about working and sanitary conditions in the Chicago stockyards were unfounded. Roosevelt in private said of Sinclair: “I have utter contempt for him. He is hysterical, unbalanced, and untruthful.” Nonetheless, the muckrakers had done their job and the meatpackers wanted to limit competition. So, TR signed the Meat Inspection Act, which cost taxpayers $3 million to implement. Economist Lawrence Reed reports that Sinclair, the socialist, despised the new law because he saw it for what it was, “a boon for the big meat packers.” The Pure Food and Drug Act produced the Food and Drug Administration, which controls which drugs consumers may purchase in the market and, to some degree, at what price. Roosevelt also pushed the Hepburn Act of 1906, which put price controls on rail rates. The result was a disaster—falling profits, poor service, and eventually the end of private management of the railroads.”
In writing this piece on Roosevelt, I don’t want to imply that he’s unpatriotic or hates America. Roosevelt has a great number of quotes that demonstrate a love of country, however, he isn’t the sinless hero that he’s made out to be in school textbooks or in popular mythology.
Harry Truman (Democrat, 1945-1953) - Harry Truman served as a major in the US Army in WWI, and eventually retired as a colonel in the US Army Reserves. Just like Roosevelt, despite his noble military service, Truman wasn’t a great president. Its hard to pick a place to start, with judgment or policy. Chronologically the best place to start is with the Venona Project. The Venona Project was a long-running secret collaboration of the United States and United Kingdom intelligence agencies involving secret analysis of messages sent by intelligence agencies of the Soviet Union, the majority of which occurred during World War II. The interesting fact about Venona is that there were so many soviet agents in high levels of the federal government that both FDR and Truman were informed of and didn’t believe, that the project was kept a secret from them. That’s right, our President and Vice President couldn’t be trusted with this information. The Venona Project cables were declassified in 1995, allowing the public to see for the first time the incompetence (at best, treason at worse) that was allowed to exist in our government in the FDR & Truman years. And keeping with the WWII theme, another failure of Truman, was the Marshall Plan he promoted to help Western Europe recover after the war. To explain the Marshall Plan’s effects briefly, I’d quote Austrian economist Ludwig Von Mises’ assertion that, “the American subsidies make it possible for [Europe's] governments to conceal partially the disastrous effects of the various socialist measures they have adopted".
In my opinion, and I may be wrong, another mistake made by Truman is the decision to intervene in the Korean War. The Korean War has left us with several unfortunate long lasting effects. Even aside from the debt from the war and the American Casualties lost, the Korean war was the first war the United States entered in, under the direction of the United Nations. Since then the UN, who the US provides the lion’s share of funding for, has since then consistently threatened US sovereignty by demanding we go handle other nation’s business. Another problem with the war is that it was the first war we engaged in without it being declared a war, which we haven’t done since 1941 (our entering into WWII). With American government relying as heavily as it does on the concept of precedence, its quite clear why this action has done great harm to the Constitution. Another long lasting effect is the political football that the rules of war have become. Korea was the first war where politicians really dictated a great number the aspects, tactics, and “rules” as opposed to the generals. An example of this is Truman not letting our forces hit the North Korean leaders escaping into China and not letting our forces strike the Chinese soldiers/weapons who were on their way to North Korea. Lastly, one of the most obvious effects of the Korean war is that technically its still going on, as the fighting came to a conclusion through an armistice (a signed cease-fire, not a treaty). And that is why we still have a large military presence in South Korea. According to the CIA’s World Factbook, South Korea’s GDP in 2010 is 375 times higher than North Korea’s, yet we are still there to protect them.
Truman’s popularity started to decline in 1951 and hit an all time low in April 1952 (actually the 2nd lowest approval rate in American history according to Gallup) because of his decision to fire General Douglas MacArthur. Truman told Time magazine in an interview, “"I fired him [MacArthur] because he wouldn't respect the authority of the President ... I didn't fire him because he was a dumb son of a bitch, although he was, but that's not against the law for generals. If it was, half to three-quarters of them would be in jail." One of my personal heroes, Senator Robert Taft wrote an editorial in the Chicago Tribune saying, "President Truman must be impeached and convicted. His hasty and vindictive removal of Gen. MacArthur is the culmination of series of acts which have shown that he is unfit, morally and mentally, for his high office. . . The American nation has never been in greater danger. It is led by a fool who is surrounded by knaves". One of the most controversial actions taken by Truman was his 1952 decision to nationalize (federal government’s seize and control of) the steel industries. The action occurred just hours before a scheduled United Steel Workers strike. This prompted the Steel companies to sue the government to regain control of their facilities. And in the Supreme Court case Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer (1952) the court ruled that the president didn’t have the authority to nationalize industries. Tank God, for that decision, but, regardless, this is yet another example of a military veteran not upholding his sworn pledge to defend the Constitution.
Lyndon B Johnson (Democrat, 1963-1969) - Served in the US Navy Reserve in WWII, and was awarded the silver star for seemingly being in a plane that saw combat action, where he acted as an observer. Now to be honest, LBJ is one of my least favorite presidents of all time, and I’m highly critical of virtually everything he did, however despite that, I’m trying my best to remain objective. However I want to emphasize how undeserving LBJ was in getting awarded the silver star. Pulitzer Prize winning LBJ biographer, Robert Caro, wrote of the incident, “The most you can say about Lyndon Johnson and his Silver Star is that it is surely one of the most undeserved Silver Stars in history, because if you accept everything that he said, he was still in action for no more than 13 minutes and only as an observer. Men who flew many missions, brave men, never got a Silver Star." Moving on to his presidential record, LBJ is best known for 2 events: the Vietnam War and the “Great Society” entitlement programs. The Vietnam War is a well covered event and this isn’t a referendum on the Vietnam War, but the vast majority of people view it as an unfortunate action, both in scope and in its operation.
The Great Society is the nickname given to the core of LBJ’s proposed legislation, similar to FDR’s New Deal or Roosevelt’s Square Deal. The Great Society’s most prominent lasting impact is the creation of the modern welfare state through Medicaid and Medicare. LBJ’s “War on Poverty” legislative agenda included enacting such programs as: Food Stamps, welfare to single mothers/pregnant women, head start, and many others. Award winning libertarian economist Thomas Sowell (who is an African American) writes of the Great Society, “the black family, which had survived centuries of slavery and discrimination, began rapidly disintegrating in the liberal welfare state that subsidized unwed pregnancy and changed welfare from an emergency rescue to a way of life." An example of this is the black legitimacy rate going from 75% before the Great Society to around 25% today. If you look at today’s exploding government budget, the deficit, and size of government most of the issues stem from the Great Society. These are depressing statistics, and I don’t like LBJ regardless, but the worst part of the situation is LBJ telling two governors aboard Air Force One, “I’ll have them niggers voting Democratic for the next 200 years”. Now, as an actual achievement of LBJ, he did sign the Civil Rights Act of 1964 into effect, granted the bill was more supported by republicans than democrats. But, because most of the Civil Rights Act support came from republicans, it makes me call into question the “good intentions” of LBJ’s Great Society/War on Poverty, despite its outcome. As the saying goes, “The road to hell is paved with good intentions”; but is it possible that the road to hell is paved with bad intentions of creating perpetual government dependency, ensuring your parties re-elections? In my opinion, yes.
Richard Nixon (Republican, 1969-1974) - Nixon was a Lt Commander in the Navy during WWII. Likely the first thing you think of when you hear the name Richard Nixon is the Watergate scandal. As a result, this could be the shortest passage in the entire post, because it already demonstrates Nixon’s character. Regardless, of the need, I’ll give you a few examples of Unconstitutional actions, bad ideas, and integrity-lacking decisions. In 1970, a proposal to give the president the power to control prices and wages passed in the democrat-controlled Congress; the motivation of which was to bait Nixon (who opposed the idea) into vetoing it and attacking him in the media OR for him to sign it and not use it and attack him in the media. Despite personally opposing the idea, and despite his economic advisors and a number of other prominent economists warning against it, Nixon signed the bill and used it. The results of which were disastrous, and shortly after the idea was repealed.
Another example of Nixon screwing things up was his putting an official end to the gold standard. FDR’s assault on the gold standard and seizure of gold in 1933 put the gold standard on the ropes. In 1971, as part of the Bretton Woods agreement of 1944, the US dollar was still redeemable in gold at a set $35 an ounce. But throughout the mid-late 60s, with the passing of the Great Society’s legislation and to finance the Vietnam War, inflation was increasing very quickly. As inflation increased, the dollar became less valuable, yet was could still buy an ounce of gold. More and more people kept buying gold, knowing it was worth more and more than the $35 it took to buy it. As a result, Nixon declared an end to Bretton Woods (admittedly a flawed piece agreement) but making the US dollar officially a completely fiat currency. (Fiat currency is a currency backed by nothing other than the government’s reassurance that it holds value).
Lastly, Nixon created a large number of permanent government agencies, such as the EPA, OSHA, and the DEA (which was created in tandem with the declaration of the official “War on Drugs”). Regardless of how you feel about these agencies, the case can be made that their goal was well intentioned and that they have had some positive effects; however just like virtually every government agency, most of their actions have had many negative consequences economically, politically, and constitutionally. However, this post isn’t a referendum on the costs and benefits of government agencies, so we’ll move on.
Gerald Ford (Republican, 1974-1977) - After Nixon’s resignation in 1974, Ford became the 38th president of the United States. Ford was also a Lt. Commander in WWII and a male model. I give you the male model fact to show diversity in his character and experience, because his presidency was very unremarkable. Ford inherited an unfortunate economy from Nixon, and failed to turn it around. Anytime Gerald Ford is mentioned, its likely because he was an eagle scout, a talented athlete, served on the Warren Commission and such because his time as president from 1974-1977 is very unmemorable (which isn’t a bad thing, if the time you preside over is prosperous, it just so happens that Ford’s time wasn’t). Fortunately, Ford lost re-election in 1976.
Jimmy Carter (Democrat, 1977-1981) - Unfortunately the person to unseat Ford was Jimmy Carter. Carter was a naval officer from 1946-1953. Carter is widely considered to be the worst president in modern history, which is quite an achievement, because there certainly are a large number of bad ones to chose from. Jimmy Carter’s worthlessness and bad policies could honestly fill an entire blog post; but I’ll do my best to pick and chose some of his worst ideas. Jimmy Carter bailed out Chrysler in 1979 and had the Iran hostage situation occur, and failed rescue on his watch. Carter oversaw skyrocketing inflation, an energy crisis, and re-instating registration to the military draft. Carter also created 2 expensive and unfortunate beaucracies, the federal Department of Education (even though the states and local levels have this same function) and the Department of Energy (which serves no actual purpose than to discourage energy entrepreneurs and create unintended consequences). You’d think after leaving office, Carter would owe the American public his silence, as no one should care what a failure thinks and feels. But you’d be wrong, Carter is constantly in the media making outrageous claims and trying to recover his image. In 2010, Jimmy Carter was on the CBS program 60 Minutes and was asked by the interviewer, “You are considered to be a failure of a president, yet you got more of your agenda passed than both Bushes, Clinton, and Reagan. Why do you think you have this negative reputation?” If it wasn’t quite obvious by listening to the question, the interviewer assumes that success and failure is based on how much of your agenda gets passed, not the effects of your agenda. Carter’s biggest problem was that most of his agenda got passed; he would have been a much less terrible president had more of his agenda not passed.
George H. W. Bush (Republican, 1989-1993) - George Bush (41) was a war hero pilot during WWII and was Reagan’s Vice President the 8 years prior to becoming president. The military buildup over the Reagan years were increasing the deficit, and in order to deal with it, Bush had to work with the democrat-controlled House (and in doing so, violated his now famous promise - “Read my lips, no new taxes”) on their proposal to raise taxes. This is ultimately the reason Bush lost in 1992, despite having an approval rate of near 90% the year previous. Bush also led Operation Desert Storm, which successfully beat the Iraqis in a few weeks time and gave him very high approval ratings; however this was yet another UN Security Council resolution, forcing American to go to war without a declaration. This action also began to facilitate a more permanent presence in the Middle East, which as is obvious today, can have negative impacts.
Bush also passed the Americans with Disabilities Act. The ADA is a piece of feel good legislation which seemingly prevents employers from discriminating against the handicapped. However, as University of Chicago economics professor Thomas DeLeire writes in Regulation Magazine, “Economists commonly lament public policies that transfer resources to a particular group because such policies ignore the “law of unintended consequences.” Economists point out, for example, that the law of unintended consequences is at work when workers’ wages fall in response to a mandated increase in benefits or when employment falls in response to an increase in the minimum wage... The ADA was enacted to remove barriers to employment of people with disabilities by banning discrimination and requiring employers to accommodate disabilities (e.g., by providing a magnified computer screen for a vision-impaired person). However, studies of the consequences of the employment provisions of ADA show that the Act has led to less employment of disabled workers. Why has ADA harmed its intended beneficiaries? The added cost of employing disabled workers to comply with the accommodation mandate of ADA has made those workers relatively unattractive to firms. Moreover, the threats of prosecution by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and litigation by disabled workers, both of which were to have deterred firms from shedding their disabled workforce, have in fact led firms to avoid hiring some disabled workers in the first place.” Bush’s major offenses were minor compared to many others, but going against his anti-tax principles helped fuel inflation and an economic dip, and passing legislation like the ADA hurt the people he was trying to help. Good intentions aren’t an excuse for bad policy, and thus Bush 41 isn’t a model president.
I didn’t include military veteran presidents Eisenhower, JFK, and Reagan in this analysis because to different degrees they were anywhere from acceptable to good presidents. Two presidents I hate the most and the president I like the most from the 20th century didn’t make the list because they weren’t veterans. As I stated in the introduction, being a military veteran and president doesn’t make you any better than the rest. Your decision making, integrity, effectiveness, level of corruption, philosophy and any other attribute seem to be not correlated to military service, in the realm of politics. Its important that you keep that in mind when voting, vetting your candidates, and spitting out mindless clichés and talking points. Despite my criticism in this of our veteran presidents, with memorial day coming up, its important that we think about and honor our noble and heroic veterans who served and sacrificed for this nation. May God bless them and keep them from getting corrupted by the dirty realm of politics.
No comments:
Post a Comment