Thursday, June 23, 2011

The Republican War on X, Where "X" in This Case = Science

"I've never been able to understand why a Republican contributor is a 'fat cat' and a Democratic contributor of the same amount of money is a 'public-spirited philanthropist'." – Ronald Reagan

"Get the habit of analysis - analysis will in time enable synthesis to become your habit of mind."
- Frank Lloyd Wright


I recently heard the term "The Republican War on Science"; and with the recent news story about Senator Tom Coburn (R - OK) uncovering $3 billion in ridiculously spent government funds from the National Science Foundation I felt the need to give an in-depth analysis of this misconceived notion. The story made headlines because two of the many grants were given to the study of shrimp on shrimp-sized treadmills and efforts such as artic Jell-O wrestling parties, respectively. To give some background, the Democrats, weighing in on several different policies had recently accused the Republicans of fighting wars on: women, the poor, the elderly, children, and education. Upon hearing the phrase the “Republican War on Science”, I thought to myself "Oh Hell, the Republican party is fighting wars on 6 fronts now, I wonder how effectively the war on science can be fought." Then I discovered that The Republican War on Science is actually a book written in 2005 by Chris Mooney. In the interest of exploring this issue from an economic and political perspective, I will lay out how the "Republican War on Science" is either a misunderstanding of "how stuff works" or its political propaganda; and really could alternatively be called "the government war on all things productive".

     The first issue with declaring the waste cited in the report as the “Republican War on Science” can be resolved with a closer look at what exactly we (as taxpayers) were funding. The shrimp treadmill study cost $500,000 for example; and as ABC News says, “its not entirely clear what the study hoped to establish”. The ABC News article went on to say, “The foundation spent $1.5 million to create a robot that can fold laundry. But before you try to buy one to save some time, consider that it takes the robot 25 minutes to fold a single towel. The list goes on. Lots of people love to use Farmville on Facebook, but lots of people probably don't love the government's spending $300,000 in taxpayer money to study whether it helps build personal relationships.” Now obviously adding up $3 billion in useless and wasteful studies still is less than what we borrow to finance the government’s operations (we borrow around $4 billion a day). So eliminating those grants would allow us to only borrow $1 billion tomorrow to keep the government operating, and not contribute anything else to our national financial crisis. This isn’t the first time the NSF has gotten public scrutiny in recent years, the Wall Street Journal reported in 2009, “In a blandly titled “Semiannual Report to Congress,” the National Science Foundation’s inspector general disclosed that “numerous reports” and an in-house investigation revealed that some NSF staff were spending a lot of time on government computers reviewing porn instead of grant proposals.”

    But, such waste is typical of governmental agencies, who don’t have to worry about staying in business or pleasing shareholders; who only answer to other Washington bureaucrats who have mastered the art of bribing voters/lobbies with their own money. As Sen. Tom Coburn says in the report, “The good news for taxpayers is there is no question NSF has contributed significantly to scientific discovery. The bad news is a significant percentage of your money is going to what most Americans will consider fraud, waste and abuse, and there are many areas where NSF could contribute far more with better management and smarter targeting of resources.” Coburn went on to explain in an interview the problems with government bureaucracies saying, “We have 12 different agencies doing pure research, and we're duplicating and we're not sharing the information across and it's siloed." He concluded, "What it says to me is, they have too much money if they're going to spend money on things like that." ABC News backs up Coburn’s statement on past innovations coming from the NSF by pointing out its role in creating important innovations like bar codes.

    Now, something to consider is what that $3 billion (and personnel) could’ve gone to (if paying down the debt wasn’t an option). It could’ve gone to medical research such as finding cures and treatments for cancer and such, or technology to help understand and predict natural disasters, perhaps it could‘ve gone to NASA who has received numerous cuts, or any other science related function that government funds. Or if that money wasn’t collected via taxes, it could’ve gone to companies employing scientists and engineers to develop new medicine, treatments, technology, or anything else. Hell, for that matter, not taking that money could help people pay down their debt, invest in companies, or spend it on products they like thus stimulating the economy. It could’ve gone to anything, but instead we have the satisfaction of an inefficient robot that folds clothes. The question I’d propose is, “is this an example of the Republican War on Science or is this the government’s war on the taxpayer?” If I were to truly support a war on science, I’d continue to fund worthless experiments and studies to rouse public anger, instead of funding important and worthwhile causes.

    With such waste which is so prevalent in government, a private charity or business with $3 billion to spend on research, would spend it on populist research such as archaeology or developing a product that people want to use or buy, respectively. If businesses waste that kind of money, their executive board will get fired by the shareholders and restructuring will be needed; if a charity were to do it they’d stop receiving donations. This isn’t true of government, they’ll keep on keeping on. As George Bernard Shaw is alleged to have said, “A government that robs Peter to pay Paul, can be assured of the support of Paul”. Likewise, one can perhaps assume that any person receiving grant money to study Farmville will throw their political support behind the people who gave it to them. That doesn’t make scientists terrible people, it makes them like any other group that is similar: unions, green energy companies, farmers, and etc. In case you were wondering, the Republicans who don’t want to give unions sweetheart deals like guaranteeing them alone government contracts and bailing out unionized companies, are accused of perpetrating a “war on the middle class”, another front on the war on the middle class was the Bush tax cuts which cut every tax rate, including the middle class. It is still unknown by most republicans how giving tax cuts to the middle class is the equivalent of engaging them in battle, but democrats insist that it is. Republicans who don’t want to give corporate welfare to green energy companies and enact policies designed to benefit them at the expensive of everyone else are accused of 2 things: being in bed with big oil (democrats employ the “if you aren’t with ‘us’, you’re against us” philosophy in insisting this) and waging war on the environment. Unfortunately though, republicans have never gone to war with agriculture as they give huge subsidies to farms and farmers, which raises the price of food.

    A more thorough look at the Republican War on Science (both the book and the nefarious struggle) reveals coordinated efforts on a number of fronts. An ongoing front in the Republican War on Science is their stance on global warming. One may first ask, what is their stance on global warming? The typical republican stance on global warming can be categorized into three groups: the wait and see approach, the human activity accounts for slim - none of the rise in temperature since it started going up, or the cost-benefit analysis approach. The fact that republicans aren’t alarmists, don’t profess a spiritual connection to Gaia/Mother Earth, and never bought into Al Gore’s widely discredited claims in An Inconvenient Truth is often used as an example of their war on science. The wait and see approach that many republicans subscribe to is based around both the fact that the temperature has only risen around 1 degree in the past 70 years and the fact that the Earth’s temperatures and climate has naturally changed numerous times throughout history. They essentially believe that we (as a society) need to observe the temperature for the next few decades, and if it rises drastically then take action to fix it. Those who believe in a cost-benefit analysis approach to global warming cite the costly measures of global warming proposals as well as they economically damaging impacts of the regulations versus expected results from the policies; with Cap N Trade being the perfect example of very costly without hardly an anticipated impact on temperatures.

    There are a number of inexpensive plans out there by think tanks and universities on how to reduce temperatures, but considering a number of them involve “geo-engineering”, the environmentalist wing of the democrat party will fight those proposals tooth and nail. The anti-corporation/socialist wing of the party views the issue as a way to redistribute wealth both nationally and internationally and thus they won’t support a non-Cap N Trade solution. Is there a democrat war on science? Yes, but seeing as they cite everything as being the consequence of global warming, the media portrays them as champions of science and the environment, so good luck fighting that narrative. Chris Mooney, the author of The Republican War on Science came out in 2007 and spoke on the cheap and effective solutions geo-engineering offers in combating climate change, however he fails to place the blame on the democrats for rejecting the ideas as he does the republicans for their hesitance to buy into global warming as a crisis. Mooney is a fairly typical liberal in this respect, and his 2007 article was written after his “Republican War on Science” book, so I can’t really say whether or not he would’ve presented a “more” fair attack on them if he had waited to write the book. Also noteworthy, since that book, global temperatures have gone down a small amount AND the climate gate scandal uncovered a large amount of falsified data which trumped up the global warming advocates’ accusations.

    The debate between Creationism versus Evolution is another battle in the Republican War on Science. The reason this discussion is used as an example is because more Republicans are Christian than democrats; however, even then the assumption is that every or the vast majority of Christians are creationists. I believe this is a faulty assumption. For example the Catholic Church, who employs a sizable amount of scientists, officially endorses evolution (via intelligent design) as a belief. How many Catholics are there? Roughly 1 billion worldwide.

    I think a larger disconnect comes from the fact that the majority of Christians hasn’t really spent much time thinking about it. I’m included in this category. Whether or not we got here via a process of evolution or by direct creation has no impact on my belief structure or way of life. My personal view is that evolution very possibly happened, I don’t know. There is lots of good evidence to make a compelling case for it, I just haven’t done anything besides a minimal amount of research because it doesn’t really matter to any practical degree. It doesn’t effect my income, my way of life, my education, my interests, my belief structure, or any other aspect you could possibly think of. Churches rarely focus on the book of Genesis, as it is the first book in the Old Testament and Christianity focuses on the New Testament. Why is this? Christ is foretold in the Old Testament, but the story of Him and His life is written in the New Testament.

    I was taught evolution in high school by a biology teacher who attends the church I attend (as rare as that may be…). The theory of evolution makes a compelling case, though obviously it isn’t without holes. Mathematicians for example often are at odds with evolutionary scientists based on how old Earth is believed to be. Mathematicians believe that its nearly impossible for evolution to have occurred (based on the way the theory is currently taught) in the time span in which Earth has existed. Because evolution is believed to be true, its often used as a basis for other theories. Every couple of years a news story will come out saying Earth is millions and millions of years older than expected, generally these stories come out not because they’ve necessarily founding archaeological evidence supporting it, but to help rectify evolution’s validity. I’m not saying the creationists out there necessarily know that and have based their beliefs accordingly, I state the above example simply because Christian apologists cite it as well as other reasoned arguments in defense of those who don’t believe in secular evolution. However, it does stand to reason that apologists such as CS Lewis could be popular amongst creationists.

    By mischaracterizing facts and beliefs and with blowing things out of proportion, it is assumed by those who didn’t grow up in a religious household that religious people are ignorant backwards hicks with a low IQ. Are there some uneducated redneck Christians without reasoned beliefs? Sure, and God knows they get all the attention. Think about what gets play in the media: Vatican scientific discovers (which includes the Big Bang Theory, by the way) or a few crazies featured in the documentary “Jesus Camp”? Generous donations by hard working church-goers or a minister in a sex scandal? Michael Guillen, an ABC News science correspondent and theoretical physicist, wrote a book in 1996 called Can a Smart Person Believe in God? He says the answer is yes and demonstrates his religious transformation, growing up with a father who was a preacher, becoming a steadfast atheist, and eventually coming back to Christianity. According to reviews, the book shows how intelligence and faith can and should go hand in hand. I haven’t read the book, but its personally insulting that someone would have to write a book saying that faith and intelligence isn’t mutually exclusive. But such religious bigotry is common thought in the society in which we live. And unfortunately the bigotry and anti-Christian bias, which is commonly featured in movies and in the media, can also create cynicism and skepticism over time, in some Christians, against the media and some scientists. The cynicism and skepticism in turn may be perceived by some groups of people as a complete rejection of reason, intelligence, and science further perpetuating the anti-Christian bias which in turn will continue to fuel the cynicism and skepticism. It can easily become a vicious circle.

    The self-perpetuating distrust on both sides can ferment into a “with us or against us mentality”. Comedian/Magician and TV host Penn Jillette is an atheist, who is good friends with radio/tv host Glenn Beck. The irony of the friendship is that Jillette will not allow any religious person in their house to prevent any possible influence on his children. On the other hand, you have groups like the Amish who are religious isolationists, who want the ability to raise a family without what they view as corrupting outside influences. This desire to raise children without corrupting influences is why some Christians don’t want evolution only taught in schools. Some Christians home school their kids, or send them to private school (both of which way out perform public schools… so much for Christians being stupid…) while the vast majority send them to public schools. Despite what perceptions may be, Christians aren’t trying to convert Atheist children, they just don’t want a science teacher to cause what may be irreparable damage to their children’s religious views. Once again, the goal isn’t to exclude evolution from being taught, there is a ton of evidence to support evolution as having occurred. The goal from most Christian parents (the ones who raise this issue publicly, which is a small minority as well), is to simply get intelligent design explained as a possible alternative, without any negative stigma. The teacher explaining the concept and saying “a number of Christians and Jews subscribe to this belief” may simply suffice for most of the complainants. This debate is way too polarizing and gets way too much attention for its actual level of importance. However, this debate being handled on a national level instead of at a local level could be another example of the “Democrat War on the 10th Amendment” and “The Democrat War on Parenting”.

    Why does it matter anyway? What it comes down to politically is a belief in centralized or decentralized government. In the late 1970s, Jimmy Carter, a democrat, created the Department of Education. The Department of Education exists in spite of every state and county having an education department and school board, respectively. The department’s goal is to dictate to the states how to run their operations and what to teach and what not to. Since 1970, the federal education spending has risen adjusted for inflation 190%. The result? Before I give you these statistics, which are from the department of education, its important to note that in 2004 they changed scoring which has “altered scores by 4 points”, they neglect to say what direction that has sent the scores, but in the interest of them keeping their jobs you’d expect them to say the changes have caused scores to go down 4 points, meaning that using past criteria that the scores would be 4 points higher. Thus I suspect that the 4 points are added points meaning that using past criteria, the scores are actually lower. Regardless, the NAEP math score in 1971 was 304. Trillions of dollars in spending later, in 2008 the NAEP math score was 306. The NAEP reading score in 1971 was 285. In 2008 the NAEP reading score was 286. The 2007 graph put out by the National Center for Education Statistics indicates that the NAEP used to test science scores as well. This trend ended in 2001, with science scores actually having gone down since their 1971 level.

    So if the federal Department of Education is a money sink that at best hasn’t improved education and at worst has either stopped potential improvement or made education worse, why do we continue to have it? Since its inception, democrats have supported it and have never stopped. There are two reasons for this: 1) democrats support it for their fundamental belief in a strong centralized government, there is a reason that virtually all of their solutions on a national level involve more government. They likely won’t admit the department’s failure, and if they do they’ll want to keep it under the hopes that one day it’ll have a positive effect. 2) The democrats gain their support from a number of special interest groups (wont go into all of them here) but perhaps their biggest supporter and fundraiser is unions. The largest union in the country is the National Education Association (NEA), who has gained permanently increasing power since on a national level since the Department of Education was instated. The NEA likes policies that give them power, more money, and job security and the democrats act in kind. This is why democrats oppose policies that have shown to be beneficial to education, but that limits governmental control and endorses schools being more self reliant (which may end up getting bad teachers fired); examples include the democrats (and NEA’s) opposition to: merit pay for teachers, charter schools, vouchers for schools, certain curricular changes, and weakening tenure for teachers.

    Conversely, conservatives and libertarians oppose centralized government, preferring to let states and localities enact policies that they deem best to fix their problems. Democrats use the issue of Republican’s opposition to federally mandated curriculums to make republicans look like they support creationism in schools. When in reality, conservatives and republicans either want to leave the decision up to states or localities and perhaps eliminate the federal department of education altogether.

    Another complain is that the supposed Republican War on Science is furthered by republicans opposing endlessly increasing funds to education. Even though to many people its counter-intuitive, there has never been an established correlation between education funding and test scores. Its often thought that South Carolina doesn’t give enough money to education. The reality is that SC is in the middle of the pack in terms of school funding and at the bottom in terms of results. In 2008, Texas A&M put a study together a state ranking for “Per-Pupil Expenditures - Adjusted Using Comparable Wage Index”. Washington DC ranked 9th with $13,434, SC ranked 33rd with $10,108, NC ranked 49th with $8,299, Utah ranked last (51st) with $6,523, and NY ranked 5th with $15,069 (using CWI, each state spent different real $ per student). And using National Center for Education statistics this is how they ranked on 8th grade reading (national average score was 261) and math (national average score was 282) scores: Washington DC had a math score of 254 and a reading score of 241. South Carolina had a math score of 280 and a reading score of 257. North Carolina had a math score of 284 and a reading score of 259. Utah had a math score of 284 and a reading score of 262. And New York had a math score of 283 and a reading score of 264. You may notice that only 2 of the 6 states I ranked scored above the national average in both departments, NY who spent the 5th most money on education of any state and Utah who spent the least money on education. Washington DC who spends much more than NC and SC did much worse than both states in both areas of study. And NC, who ranks 49/51 in funding compared to SC’s 33/51 ranking, beat them in both departments.

    So when conservatives and libertarians bring up that theirs no correlation between student achievement and school funding, now you know its not just a talking point. Sure, there is a necessarily base level, but clearly throwing money at a problem generally leads to a more expensive problem, not a solution. The solution is to use the money smarter, and to quote Ron Paul, “If I truly opposed education, I’d support keeping the federal Department of Education”. Continuing to embrace such reckless spending on education, without producing results could be called “the Democrat War on Statistics”  and another example of “The Democrat War on Taxpayers”

    The stem cell research issue is yet another example of the Republican War on Science. Anyone who  believes republicans oppose stem cell research is incorrect. What they oppose is government funding of embryonic stem cell research. There are a number of types of stem cells, including adult stem cells, amniotic stem cells and induced pluripotent stem cells, which don’t involve creating, using or destroying human embryos. Because of this: they aren’t controversial and republicans don’t oppose public funds going to their research. Republicans oppose public funding of embryonic stem cell research for these chief reasons: 1) Republicans (or at least free market capitalists) believe that companies and private entities will allocate their own funding more productively than the government (see any government department’s budget for details) and 2) is the opposition of making people who believe embryonic stem cell research is fundamentally wrong, fund it. I’m not saying I personally believe that you are condemned to Hell for “playing God with embryonic stem cell research” (or anything of that nature using aborted babies) and I’m not saying most Christians or church establishments believe it either, but if I were to believe it I sure as Hell wouldn’t want any of my money to go to it. Not because I’m personally performing the tests myself, but because I don’t want my money (voluntarily or involuntarily) to end up potentially damning me either. Once again, I’m not saying I believe that, but I sure as hell want to err on the side of caution with my soul. Pepsi recently announced they were using stem cell research (no you aren’t drinking human cells) and republicans haven’t moved to shut them down. They just don’t want to make people fund it against their will, particularly when one’s positioning in the afterlife is at stake. Republicans oppose government funds going to abortion too. I’m moderately pro-life, and my goal isn’t to make people in NY stop having abortions, but I sure as hell don’t want any part in it.

    Now let me address a related complaint, that politicians shouldn’t let their religious beliefs dictate their political views. Now, to a certain point I agree. I get angry with our republican dominated state senate and their refusal to let non-profit organizations run casino nights or that our liquor stores close at 7pm in South Carolina. However, when it comes to making the taxpayers fund controversial issues, I oppose making people do things against their will. Thomas Jefferson said, “But it does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg.” His point was somewhat obvious, that he doesn’t really care what the religious beliefs are of his neighbors because it has no impact on him. Well, making people pay for things that go against their religious views, picks their pocket and injures their soul. And to be honest, the complaint against republicans that their religious views dictate their public policy is a hypocritical purely political attack. Democrat Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi and numerous other democrats have cited their religion when passing a number of bills, when their promoted policies are in line with the official positions of various church establishments. Examples being Obamacare (Some churches support health care for all as being “humanitarian” and in line with God) and most democrat’s support of an open border policy (The Catholic Church doesn’t acknowledge national borders). Essentially when democrats do it, its fine. When republicans do it, they are the devil. This could be called The Democrat War on Consistency.

    Speaking of religion’s influence on politics, the separation of church and state was another issue brought up in the Republican War on Science, as being evidence of republicans ignoring science. Ignoring other issues with this being introduced as evidence, what should be focused on is the meaning and origin of the separation of church and state. This is often shouted by secular organizations anytime the issue of religion and government are uttered in the same breath; generally without much thought behind it. As the Free Republic writes, "In 1801, the Danbury Baptist Association of Danbury, Connecticut, heard a rumor that the Congregationalist denomination was about to be made the national denomination. That rumor distressed the Danbury Baptists, as it should have. Consequently, the fired off a litter to President Thomas Jefferson voicing their concern. On January 1, 1802, Jefferson wrote the Danbury Baptists, assuring them that 'the First Amendment has erected a wall of separation between church and state.'" They go on to explain the letter further saying, “His letter explained that they need not fear the establishment of a national denomination—and that while the wall of the First Amendment would protect the church from government control—there always would be open and free religious expression of all orthodox religious practices, for true religious expression of all orthodox religious practices, for true religious duties would never threaten the purpose of government. The government would interfere with a religious activity was a direct menace to the government or to the overall peace and good order of society. (Later Supreme Court identified potential "religious" activities in which the government might interfere: things like human sacrifice, bigamy or polygamy, the advocating of immorality or licentiousness, etc. If any of these activities were to occur in the name of "religion," then the government would interfere, for these were activities which threaten public peace and safety; but with orthodox religious practices, the government would not interfere).”

    In other words, whenever a group such as “Freedom From Religion Foundation” from Wisconsin demands that the Charleston Fire Department remove their Nativity scene from the firehouse grounds, citing the “separation of church and state” or the “First Amendment” as the legality behind their demand, they are out of line. The 1st Amendment states, “Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of a religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof”. A few things important distinctions show the idiocy of Freedom From Religion Foundation’s claim. First, the Charleston Fire Department isn’t Congress nor is it establishing a religion; its important we recognize that before going forward. With that being understood, the Fire Department isn’t prohibiting people from exercising their religion. Once we stipulate to those terms, the fallaciousness of the demand becomes obvious. Only when you get an understanding of the Constitution and the history behind the debate does it become apparent that the loud obnoxious cry of “separation of church and state!” doesn’t really mean what the masses think it means. The term God is actually a fairly ambiguous term, an example being when a Christian, a Buddhist, and a Muslim all pray to “God”, they are all praying to different deities. “Nature’s God” is a term in the Declaration of Independence, the reason of which is to establish natural rights that men are born with and because Thomas Jefferson, likely a deist, doesn’t quite subscribe to the same God as George Washington or John Adams. This sentiment was further reflected in the Massachusetts state constitution which states, "no subject shall be hurt, molested, or restrained, in his person, liberty, or estate, for worshipping God in the manner and season most agreeable to the dictates of his own conscience... provided he doth not disturb the public peace, or obstruct others in their religious worship."

    Yes, God was endorsed in their Constitution. Do we want to go over why its not a violation of the establishment clause? Congress isn’t mandating or establishing anything, nor are they prohibiting people from exercising their religious views. Its important we establish this point, there is a freedom of religion, you can choose to be a member of any faith or of none at all; and in doing so, you can practice your faith in any manner that doesn’t harm or impose on others. With that being said, there is no freedom from religion, you can’t claim that others must change their ways or demand fire departments take down displays because you don’t like it or believe in the faith. If I was driving by city hall in Dearborn, MI and they had an Islamic religious display, I wouldn’t mind, it doesn’t impact me at all. The same goes with Jewish displays in a municipal building in places such as Florida. In a free society you will hear and see things you don’t like, and we are privileged enough to live in a free society. Just keep that in mind the next time you feel tempted to complain about “In God we Trust” on our money or a license plate.
Its important to know why the founding fathers emphasized this freedom as important enough to be in the First Amendment. Our founders, being well-read men with mostly an English ancestry understood the dangers of government control of religion. In today’s society, our nation’s ignorance is on display when they believe the issue is religion creeping into government. The entire point of the First Amendment’s religious freedoms was to prevent government from controlling a religion. The historical basis for this fear was Henry VIII of England who separated his country from the Catholic Church and established the Church of England. The point of doing so was so he could control the church’s purse strings (he took a large amount of church assets and moved them to his treasury), so his actions were seen as perfectly acceptable in society and not at odds with the church, and so his priests would teach loyalty and service to the king as being as important as faithfulness and loyalty to God. Anyone who wouldn’t take the loyalty oath to the new Church of England was tortured, imprisoned, and often times killed. The perception that priests, ministers, pastors, rabbis, and other religious clergy beg and pray for government to get in bed with them is insane and ridiculous. Not acknowledging these truths is yet another example of “The Democrat War on History”

    Obviously, in this blog I use the narrative that republicans are all religious and democrats are 100% secular. This isn’t true, but this blog post is already unacceptably long. Both political parties have different religious bases. The “religious right” gets a lot of media attention and needs no further explanation as a key voting block for the republican party. But a closer look at the democrat base reveals the black community, which is somewhere around 85% democratic is much more religious than virtually every other group. The Hispanic community is perhaps just as religious as the black community and in 2008 voted 67% in favor of Obama according to Pew Research. But going back to my early referencing of Thomas Jefferson, the point is people shouldn’t have to pay for things that go against their religious beliefs. Now, one can point out that there are other policies that taxpayers pay for that could also violate a number of peoples’ personal beliefs. To that I’d say exactly, that’s why I advocate for a smaller central government so do this to less people, and let states and localities decide such policies. If people leave their cities or states in large numbers, then you’ll know that the controversial policies should be repealed. But its much more difficult and complex to leave a country than it is a city or state.

    This post was to show that there are 2 sides to every story. I wrote this, not to defend republicans in general, as I oppose them on a number of issues too. But at times I am put in a position where I must defend things and people I don’t hold in the highest esteem. When speaking to political novices I often refer to myself as a republican, I do this for 2 reasons. 1) Because my beliefs are much more complex than what the average person understands and they likely aren’t familiar with third parties. 2) Because third parties don’t get a fair shot in this country, the political rules and regulations help to stack the deck against them. Correcting the record and not letting platitudes and generalities stand is something that I must do. I hope this does an adequate job of explaining the politics and economics in depth, which is obviously much more complex than it appears at face value. This is true with nearly every political policy.

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

The Myth of the Military Veteran Presidency

"A politician needs the ability to foretell what is going to happen tomorrow, next week, next month, and next year. And to have the ability afterwards to explain why it didn't happen.” - Winston Churchill

“Ninety percent of the politicians give the other ten percent a bad reputation.” - Henry Kissinger

    Let me start off by saying that I have the utmost respect for our military, both active and retired. They have demonstrated more courage than I could possibly imagine. My views on the pentagon budget, foreign policy, and views such as this article aren’t by any stretch of the imagination, supposed to portray our military as incompetent, cowardly, corrupt or anything of the like. It is the politicians, the beau racy, and the asinine logic that comes with government, that I dislike, not the men and women who protect us.

    A popularly held view, particularly amongst republicans, and some veterans is the idea that the office of the President of the United States should be occupied by only those with military service. And in some ways it seems to make sense, the Commander in Chief, having experience in serving our great nation. Someone who has a direct understanding of how the military operates and the inner workings of it all. When the term “military veteran” is uttered, it invokes feelings of brave and honorable men and women who possess great integrity stand for everything that’s right about America. I feel the same way, however just like with any profession the 1% argument holds true… as the cliché goes, 99% of cops are good, it’s the 1% that gives cops a bad reputation. The same is true with some veterans.

    Most Americans are aware that it takes a special kind of smooth talking, well connected, and soul-less bastard to get far in politics. The kind of person that can look you in the eye and promise you the world, knowing the entire time they are lying. And this is true with a number of the veterans who are politicians in Washington, DC; both today and in the past. Its quite possible that the veterans, while active duty, were honorable men with impeccable integrity who have lost it along the way; its also possible that these men never possessed it. That is not only hard to determine, but is inconsequential to the thrust of my argument. Most of our presidents have been veterans, and we’ve had a fair amount of good presidents, and we’ve had even more bad or mediocre presidents. The body of this posting with analyze military veterans to serve as president from 1900 - present. The reason for me choosing only presidents of the past 111 years is because it’d be unfair for every veteran to be compared to the likes of George Washington and as time has gone on, presidential policy has had greater and greater effect on society as the size and scope of government has grown.

Theodore Roosevelt (Republican, 1901-1909) - Served as a colonel in the Spanish-American War, and famously led the “Rough Riders”. Teddy Roosevelt was undoubtedly a badass in many ways. While giving a campaign speech, he was shot by a would-be assassin, but refused to seek immediate medical assistance in order to finish giving his speech. He was also full of charisma, an example being “teddy bears” him. However, while Roosevelt was probably not the first president who used what is referred to as “the cult of personality” to his advantage, he was the one who set the trend for the rest of the 20th century’s presidents. Roosevelt’s view of property rights were very much at odds with that of our founding fathers and the Constitution. Examples of this are found in the following quotes, “Every man holds his property subject to the general right of the community to regulate its use to whatever degree the public welfare may require it” and “We grudge no man a fortune in civil life if it is honorably obtained and well used . . . so long as the gaining represents benefit to the community.”

Something that should stand out to you in these quotes is that Roosevelt feels like he as well as the general public have a right to tell you what to do with the money you’ve earned and the property you own. In addition, what he feels like you should do is something that benefits communities as a whole. Seemingly in Roosevelt’s ideal world, every house would feature public restrooms and their yards would be public parks and playgrounds. Another startling statement comes from this Roosevelt Socialist Freudian slip, “I have always believed that it would also be necessary to give the National Government complete power over the organization and capitalization of all business concerns engaged in inter-State commerce”. The Cato Institute gives a pretty good summary of some policies that Roosevelt is best known for when they wrote, “In 1906 came the Pure Food and Drug Act and the Meat Inspection Act. TR pushed both laws largely in response to muckraking journalists, especially the socialist Upton Sinclair, author of The Jungle, a novel. Despite Sinclair’s propaganda, a government report confirmed that the novel’s claims about working and sanitary conditions in the Chicago stockyards were unfounded. Roosevelt in private said of Sinclair: “I have utter contempt for him. He is hysterical, unbalanced, and untruthful.” Nonetheless, the muckrakers had done their job and the meatpackers wanted to limit competition. So, TR signed the Meat Inspection Act, which cost taxpayers $3 million to implement. Economist Lawrence Reed reports that Sinclair, the socialist, despised the new law because he saw it for what it was, “a boon for the big meat packers.” The Pure Food and Drug Act produced the Food and Drug Administration, which controls which drugs consumers may purchase in the market and, to some degree, at what price. Roosevelt also pushed the Hepburn Act of 1906, which put price controls on rail rates. The result was a disaster—falling profits, poor service, and eventually the end of private management of the railroads.”

In writing this piece on Roosevelt, I don’t want to imply that he’s unpatriotic or hates America. Roosevelt has a great number of quotes that demonstrate a love of country, however, he isn’t the sinless hero that he’s made out to be in school textbooks or in popular mythology.

Harry Truman (Democrat, 1945-1953) - Harry Truman served as a major in the US Army in WWI, and eventually retired as a colonel in the US Army Reserves. Just like Roosevelt, despite his noble military service, Truman wasn’t a great president. Its hard to pick a place to start, with judgment or policy. Chronologically the best place to start is with the Venona Project. The Venona Project was a long-running secret collaboration of the United States and United Kingdom intelligence agencies involving secret analysis of messages sent by intelligence agencies of the Soviet Union, the majority of which occurred during World War II. The interesting fact about Venona is that there were so many soviet agents in high levels of the federal government that both FDR and Truman were informed of and didn’t believe, that the project was kept a secret from them. That’s right, our President and Vice President couldn’t be trusted with this information. The Venona Project cables were declassified in 1995, allowing the public to see for the first time the incompetence (at best, treason at worse) that was allowed to exist in our government in the FDR & Truman years. And keeping with the WWII theme, another failure of Truman, was the Marshall Plan he promoted to help Western Europe recover after the war. To explain the Marshall Plan’s effects briefly, I’d quote Austrian economist Ludwig Von Mises’ assertion that, “the American subsidies make it possible for [Europe's] governments to conceal partially the disastrous effects of the various socialist measures they have adopted".

In my opinion, and I may be wrong, another mistake made by Truman is  the decision to intervene in the Korean War. The Korean War has left us with several unfortunate long lasting effects. Even aside from the debt from the war and the American Casualties lost, the Korean war was the first war the United States entered in, under the direction of the United Nations. Since then the UN, who the US provides the lion’s share of funding for, has since then consistently threatened US sovereignty by demanding we go handle other nation’s business. Another problem with the war is that it was the first war we engaged in without it being declared a war, which we haven’t done since 1941 (our entering into WWII). With American government relying as heavily as it does on the concept of precedence, its quite clear why this action has done great harm to the Constitution. Another long lasting effect is the political football that the rules of war have become. Korea was the first war where politicians really dictated a great number the aspects, tactics, and “rules” as opposed to the generals. An example of this is Truman not letting our forces hit the North Korean leaders escaping into China and not letting our forces strike the Chinese soldiers/weapons who were on their way to North Korea. Lastly, one of the most obvious effects of the Korean war is that technically its still going on, as the fighting came to a conclusion through an armistice (a signed cease-fire, not a treaty). And that is why we still have a large military presence in South Korea. According to the CIA’s World Factbook, South Korea’s GDP in 2010 is 375 times higher than North Korea’s, yet we are still there to protect them.

Truman’s popularity started to decline in 1951 and hit an all time low in April 1952 (actually the 2nd lowest approval rate in American history according to Gallup) because of his decision to fire General Douglas MacArthur. Truman told Time magazine in an interview, “"I fired him [MacArthur] because he wouldn't respect the authority of the President ... I didn't fire him because he was a dumb son of a bitch, although he was, but that's not against the law for generals. If it was, half to three-quarters of them would be in jail." One of my personal heroes, Senator Robert Taft wrote an editorial in the Chicago Tribune saying, "President Truman must be impeached and convicted. His hasty and vindictive removal of Gen. MacArthur is the culmination of series of acts which have shown that he is unfit, morally and mentally, for his high office. . . The American nation has never been in greater danger. It is led by a fool who is surrounded by knaves". One of the most controversial actions taken by Truman was his 1952 decision to nationalize (federal government’s seize and control of) the steel industries. The action occurred just hours before a scheduled United Steel Workers strike. This prompted the Steel companies to sue the government to regain control of their facilities. And in the Supreme Court case Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer (1952) the court ruled that the president didn’t have the authority to nationalize industries. Tank God, for that decision, but, regardless, this is yet another example of a military veteran not upholding his sworn pledge to defend the Constitution.

Lyndon B Johnson (Democrat, 1963-1969) - Served in the US Navy Reserve in WWII, and was awarded the silver star for seemingly being in a plane that saw combat action, where he acted as an observer. Now to be honest, LBJ is one of my least favorite presidents of all time, and I’m highly critical of virtually everything he did, however despite that, I’m trying my best to remain objective. However I want to emphasize how undeserving LBJ was in getting awarded the silver star. Pulitzer Prize winning LBJ biographer, Robert Caro, wrote of the incident, “The most you can say about Lyndon Johnson and his Silver Star is that it is surely one of the most undeserved Silver Stars in history, because if you accept everything that he said, he was still in action for no more than 13 minutes and only as an observer. Men who flew many missions, brave men, never got a Silver Star." Moving on to his presidential record, LBJ is best known for 2 events: the Vietnam War and the “Great Society” entitlement programs. The Vietnam War is a well covered event and this isn’t a referendum on the Vietnam War, but the vast majority of people view it as an unfortunate action, both in scope and in its operation.

The Great Society is the nickname given to the core of LBJ’s proposed legislation, similar to FDR’s New Deal or Roosevelt’s Square Deal. The Great Society’s most prominent lasting impact is the creation of the modern welfare state through Medicaid and Medicare. LBJ’s “War on Poverty” legislative agenda included enacting such programs as: Food Stamps, welfare to single mothers/pregnant women, head start, and many others. Award winning libertarian economist Thomas Sowell (who is an African American) writes of the Great Society, “the black family, which had survived centuries of slavery and discrimination, began rapidly disintegrating in the liberal welfare state that subsidized unwed pregnancy and changed welfare from an emergency rescue to a way of life." An example of this is the black legitimacy rate going from 75% before the Great Society to around 25% today. If you look at today’s exploding government budget, the deficit, and size of government most of the issues stem from the Great Society. These are depressing statistics, and I don’t like LBJ regardless, but the worst part of the situation is LBJ telling two governors aboard Air Force One, “I’ll have them niggers voting Democratic for the next 200 years”. Now, as an actual achievement of LBJ, he did sign the Civil Rights Act of 1964 into effect, granted the bill was more supported by republicans than democrats. But, because most of the Civil Rights Act support came from republicans, it makes me call into question the “good intentions” of LBJ’s Great Society/War on Poverty, despite its outcome. As the saying goes, “The road to hell is paved with good intentions”; but is it possible that the road to hell is paved with bad intentions of creating perpetual government dependency, ensuring your parties re-elections? In my opinion, yes.

Richard Nixon (Republican, 1969-1974) - Nixon was a Lt Commander in the Navy during WWII. Likely the first thing you think of when you hear the name Richard Nixon is the Watergate scandal. As a result, this could be the shortest passage in the entire post, because it already demonstrates Nixon’s character. Regardless, of the need, I’ll give you a few examples of Unconstitutional actions, bad ideas, and integrity-lacking decisions. In 1970, a proposal to give the president the power to control prices and wages passed in the democrat-controlled Congress; the motivation of which was to bait Nixon (who opposed the idea) into vetoing it and attacking him in the media OR for him to sign it and not use it and attack him in the media. Despite personally opposing the idea, and despite his economic advisors and a number of other prominent economists warning against it, Nixon signed the bill and used it. The results of which were disastrous, and shortly after the idea was repealed.

Another example of Nixon screwing things up was his putting an official end to the gold standard. FDR’s assault on the gold standard and seizure of gold in 1933 put the gold standard on the ropes. In 1971, as part of the Bretton Woods agreement of 1944, the US dollar was still redeemable in gold at a set $35 an ounce. But throughout the mid-late 60s, with the passing of the Great Society’s legislation and to finance the Vietnam War, inflation was increasing very quickly. As inflation increased, the dollar became less valuable, yet was could still buy an ounce of gold. More and more people kept buying gold, knowing it was worth more and more than the $35 it took to buy it. As a result, Nixon declared an end to Bretton Woods (admittedly a flawed piece agreement) but making the US dollar officially a completely fiat currency. (Fiat currency is a currency backed by nothing other than the government’s reassurance that it holds value).

Lastly, Nixon created a large number of permanent government agencies, such as the EPA, OSHA, and the DEA (which was created in tandem with the declaration of the official “War on Drugs”). Regardless of how you feel about these agencies, the case can be made that their goal was well intentioned and that they have had some positive effects; however just like virtually every government agency, most of their actions have had many negative consequences economically, politically, and constitutionally. However, this post isn’t a referendum on the costs and benefits of government agencies, so we’ll move on.

Gerald Ford (Republican, 1974-1977) - After Nixon’s resignation in 1974, Ford became the 38th president of the United States. Ford was also a Lt. Commander in WWII and a male model. I give you the male model fact to show diversity in his character and experience, because his presidency was very unremarkable. Ford inherited an unfortunate economy from Nixon, and failed to turn it around. Anytime Gerald Ford is mentioned, its likely because he was an eagle scout, a talented athlete, served on the Warren Commission and such because his time as president from 1974-1977 is very unmemorable (which isn’t a bad thing, if the time you preside over is prosperous, it just so happens that Ford’s time wasn’t). Fortunately, Ford lost re-election in 1976.

Jimmy Carter (Democrat, 1977-1981) - Unfortunately the person to unseat Ford was Jimmy Carter. Carter was a naval officer from 1946-1953. Carter is widely considered to be the worst president in modern history, which is quite an achievement, because there certainly are a large number of bad ones to chose from. Jimmy Carter’s worthlessness and bad policies could honestly fill an entire blog post; but I’ll do my best to pick and chose some of his worst ideas. Jimmy Carter bailed out Chrysler in 1979 and had the Iran hostage situation occur, and failed rescue on his watch. Carter oversaw skyrocketing inflation, an energy crisis, and re-instating registration to the military draft. Carter also created 2 expensive and unfortunate beaucracies, the federal Department of Education (even though the states and local levels have this same function) and the Department of Energy (which serves no actual purpose than to discourage energy entrepreneurs and create unintended consequences). You’d think after leaving office, Carter would owe the American public his silence, as no one should care what a failure thinks and feels. But you’d be wrong, Carter is constantly in the media making outrageous claims and trying to recover his image. In 2010, Jimmy Carter was on the CBS program 60 Minutes and was asked by the interviewer, “You are considered to be a failure of a president, yet you got more of your agenda passed than both Bushes, Clinton, and Reagan. Why do you think you have this negative reputation?” If it wasn’t quite obvious by listening to the question, the interviewer assumes that success and failure is based on how much of your agenda gets passed, not the effects of your agenda. Carter’s biggest problem was that most of his agenda got passed; he would have been a much less terrible president had more of his agenda not passed.

George H. W. Bush
(Republican, 1989-1993) - George Bush (41) was a war hero pilot during WWII and was Reagan’s Vice President the 8 years prior to becoming president. The military buildup over the Reagan years were increasing the deficit, and in order to deal with it, Bush had to work with the democrat-controlled House (and in doing so, violated his now famous promise - “Read my lips, no new taxes”) on their proposal to raise taxes. This is ultimately the reason Bush lost in 1992, despite having an approval rate of near 90% the year previous. Bush also led Operation Desert Storm, which successfully beat the Iraqis in a few weeks time and gave him very high approval ratings; however this was yet another UN Security Council resolution, forcing American to go to war without a declaration. This action also began to facilitate a more permanent presence in the Middle East, which as is obvious today, can have negative impacts.

Bush also passed the Americans with Disabilities Act. The ADA is a piece of feel good legislation which seemingly prevents employers from discriminating against the handicapped. However, as University of Chicago economics professor Thomas DeLeire writes in Regulation Magazine, “Economists commonly lament public policies that transfer resources to a particular group because such policies ignore the “law of unintended consequences.” Economists point out, for example, that the law of unintended consequences is at work when workers’ wages fall in response to a mandated increase in benefits or when employment falls in response to an increase in the minimum wage... The ADA was enacted to remove barriers to employment of people with disabilities by banning discrimination and requiring employers to accommodate disabilities (e.g., by providing a magnified computer screen for a vision-impaired person). However, studies of the consequences of the employment provisions of ADA show that the Act has led to less employment of disabled workers. Why has ADA harmed its intended beneficiaries? The added cost of employing disabled workers to comply with the accommodation mandate of ADA has made those workers relatively unattractive to firms. Moreover, the threats of prosecution by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and litigation by disabled workers, both of which were to have deterred firms from shedding their disabled workforce, have in fact led firms to avoid hiring some disabled workers in the first place.” Bush’s major offenses were minor compared to many others, but going against his anti-tax principles helped fuel inflation and an economic dip, and passing legislation like the ADA hurt the people he was trying to help. Good intentions aren’t an excuse for bad policy, and thus Bush 41 isn’t a model president.

I didn’t include military veteran presidents Eisenhower, JFK, and Reagan in this analysis because to different degrees they were anywhere from acceptable to good presidents. Two presidents I hate the most and the president I like the most from the 20th century didn’t make the list because they weren’t veterans. As I stated in the introduction, being a military veteran and president doesn’t make you any better than the rest. Your decision making, integrity, effectiveness, level of corruption, philosophy and any other attribute seem to be not correlated to military service, in the realm of politics. Its important that you keep that in mind when voting, vetting your candidates, and spitting out mindless clichés and talking points. Despite my criticism in this of our veteran presidents, with memorial day coming up, its important that we think about and honor our noble and heroic veterans who served and sacrificed for this nation. May God bless them and keep them from getting corrupted by the dirty realm of politics.

Tuesday, May 17, 2011

My Philosophy on Voting + 2012 Candidate Analysis

“Always vote for principle, though you may vote alone, and you may cherish the sweetest reflection that your vote is never lost.” – John Quincy Adams

“Under democracy one party always devotes its chief energies to trying to prove that the other party is unfit to rule - and both commonly succeed, and are right” – H.L. Mencken

A vote to me is perhaps one of the most personal and serious actions you can experience in a lifetime. I consider it to be the equivalent of a secular prayer; it’s something that I must do to in order to show my appreciation for our founding fathers. Voting also allows me to do what I can by voting for people that I’m reasonably sure will take positions that will ultimately lead to prosperity and freedom for Americans. I will only vote for a candidate that I view will not contribute to the continuing decline of our nation; which I view as the vast majority of politicians out there. If my candidate doesn’t win, then so be it. I may be angry, or bitter; but it’s likely that my favorite candidates never really stood a chance anyway. The reason that many of the people I admire don’t have a chance is because; they may or may not possess give wonderful speeches, have indescribable amounts of charisma, or be in tune with pop culture goings on. I hold voting in such high regard because when I vote, regardless of the outcome, have tried to restore our city, county, state, or nation to the prosperity it once had. In 2008 when the republicans put up John McCain as their candidate and the democrats put up Barrack Obama, I voted for the libertarian candidate Bob Barr. I understand that third parties don’t stand a chance for the most part, but if I know that both major party candidates will be destructive to our country, why would I possibly vote for them? Voting for the lesser of the evils, still means you’ve voted for an evil. What good person can possibly, in good conscience, vote for someone who you’re fairly sure would enact a decent amount of destructive policies; regardless of who their main competition is? If an individual doesn’t have principles, then they are nothing. They are just like the charlatans in office who spend most of their time trying to lie to the public about the details of the legislation they are working on with equally immoral people.

At the end of my days, I don’t want to have to explain myself to the younger generations and tell them that I helped elect, and continued to help elect candidates that were going to make terrible decisions, because potentially that politicians’ main rival would’ve made more terrible decisions. Ronald Reagan famously said, “The person who agrees with you 80 percent of the time is a friend and an ally — not a 20 percent traitor.” That may be true, but why not stand in opposition to the damaging 20% as well? I may be able to work with that person, the far majority of the time, but hell if I want to endorse someone who I KNOW is going to make our country 20% worse. I’ve yet to find any political candidate whose views are 100% in line with mine; however there are some well into the 90s. Unfortunately though, many of the politicians I most agree with died decades or centuries ago.

Opponents to third parties often say that voting third party is throwing your vote away. I can’t imagine a bigger waste of a vote than voting for someone like John McCain, who at best agrees with me 60% of the time. Endorsing worthless republicans will just perpetuate the amount of worthless republicans in the future. If I can subvert the efforts of the Republican Party in their nominating such worthless politicians, by showing them that I can’t vote for anyone who isn’t at least 90% in agreement with me, I’ll gladly do it. Some republicans and talk radio hosts would claim that by advocating a third party, I’m helping Obama get re-elected. My answer to that is this: While the consequence of me voting for a third party is that the republican won’t get my vote, their insinuation is that my vote was actually owned by the republicans and I had the nerve to take it away. In no way am I beholden to them, if they wanted my vote they’d nominate a candidate that was going to be serious about constitutionally limited government and a smarter foreign policy. By nominating piles of crap like John McCain, they have declared to me, that my vote wasn’t important to them.

Senator Arlen Specter (D, then R, then D-PA) famously said, “I didn’t leave the Republican Party, it left me”. Well, Senator Specter is an idiot and left the party because he knew he was going to face a challenger in the primary and would probably lose, so he switched parties hoping to avoid a primary (and that didn‘t work out too well for him). Regardless, his quote would be true for me, if I had been cognizant and of voting age back in the Reagan years and times previous. In reality, I became of age to vote in 2004, and even though in my ignorance I voted straight ticket then; the Republican Party at that point didn’t represent any recognizable conservatism. How can I possibly get them to return to the ideologies of Reagan, Goldwater, Taft and such by voting for Bush and McCain? Although people can deny it as much as they want, “what you reward you get more of“. The only way to change the party is by voting in the primary and trying to educate the public, when that fails, you cannot sit idly by and continue to support them. When it comes to people like that, I think to myself something much like Jesus said while on the cross, “Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do”. But on my gravestone, I want a message written to show my ideology and dedication; I want that message to say, “Let it not be said that no one cared, that no one objected once it was realized that our liberties and wealth were in jeopardy.” (Quote by Ron Paul, with tenses modified for eulogy purposes.

With that being said I’m going to break down the major candidates who are expected to run. I’ll give a little background, and analyze factors like their: electability, upsides, downsides, and if I can or cannot vote for them.

Mitt Romney - Former governor of Massachusetts, successful businessman and 2008 presidential candidate
Upside - Successful track record in business. Helped a number of businesses and events turn a profit and/or stay in business after they looked like lost causes. His experience as a business profitability consultant can perhaps help “operate government like a business” as the cliché goes. Everyone wants a businessman in office it seems.
Downside - He is known for his flip-flopping on issues to try making him more electable in Massachusetts and as president. His political record isn’t impressive in terms of the legislation he signed into law. He’d essentially have to run against his past political career and stances, with the biggest albatross around his neck being Romneycare (the basis for Obamacare). He has no discernable principles and he stands as one of the many worthless neo-conservatives in the field.
Electable – At the 2011 CPAC Ann Coulter said, “If we don’t run Chris Christie, Romney will be the nominee and we’ll lose.” Well Chris Christie isn’t running, but she’s right about Romney’s viability. I don’t think he can make it out of the primary. Usually I’m fairly embarrassed of my state’s religious bigotry when it comes to non-protestants… But in this case, I’m pretty happy it means Romney can’t win here, even if he didn’t pass Romneycare.
Can I vote for him? - Hell no.

Ron Paul – Doctor and current congressman from Texas. Often called “the godfather of the Tea Party”
Upside – Ron Paul has perhaps the most consistent record in American history. He is well known for his principled fights on just about every fiscal or Constitutional issue. He has never supported an unconstitutional bill or voted for an unbalanced budget. He is known for his ability to rally the youth to his causes, and known for never compromising. Ron Paul’s nickname is “Dr. No”, a reference to his record number of votes where he votes against the majority 434-1. He is also known for his opposition to typical republican foreign policy ideology and stance on the Federal Reserve, two issues which he has brought to the forefront in American politics.
Downside – At times he is perhaps too much of a civil libertarian for even the libertarian-leaning conservatives. An example of this would be his position on giving trials to Guantanamo inmates. He also said in a radio interview that had he been in office, he would’ve sought permission from Pakistan to take Bin Laden alive. This angered people because we haven’t respected other nation’s sovereignty and international law for so long, that starting to do so seems extreme.
Electable - Many republicans and conservative commentators still don’t take him seriously and consider him to be “fringe”. In 2008, he was held out of a debate in New Hampshire, put on by Fox News. He often receives little or negligible media coverage, despite his frequent appearances. A number of his stances are either little known by the public, which, in conjunction with the media’s belittlement, tends to make him misunderstood as well as a constant underdog.
Can I vote for him? There’d be no greater privelage I could possibly receive.

Mitch Daniels - Current 2-term Indiana governor and successful businessman.
Upside - He has reduced the size of Indiana’s government, with several entities being leased to private companies for operation. He has been a fiscal hawk, and also has shown that he’s not power hungry like some other nominees by declining an appointment to the senate to fill Vice President Dan Quayle’s void. He has taken on the unions in a northern state and also said that he’d cut some of the pentagon’s budget, again showing fearlessness when it comes to the “third rails” of politics.
Downside – Compared to Obama, he’s fairly mild and meek, and doesn’t ooze charisma. He also angered some social conservatives by saying that in this session (2 year period of the state legislature agenda) he’d agree to a truce on social issues, in order to put fiscal issues to the forefront. However, recently he did defund (take away state funding from) Planned Parenthood in Indiana, showing that the truce was very short lived.
Electable – Yes, in both the primary and general, as his past is free from scandals. His wife may receive some tough scrutiny though, because she left Mitch and the kids to go marry a man in California. A few years later, the marriage ended in divorce and she remarried Mitch. This is probably the reason she stays out of the spotlight and seems to be one of the reasons the governor hasn’t been more “gung ho” in getting in the race.
Can I vote for him? – Yes, he’s about the only more “mainstream” candidate I can get behind, so far.

Rick Santorum – Former Pennsylvania congressman and senator.
Upside – As he points out, quite often, he was able to win elections in overwhelmingly majority-democrat districts. And, if able to catch momentum, could easily sweep the Southern primaries with his record of social conservatism.
Downside – When it comes to electability, I’m not sure he has a chance to win a senate seat again in PA, let alone carry it in a general election. Rick Santorum defines himself as a “compassionate conservative”, the premise there being that other forms of conservative are uncompassionate. Also, if that term sounds familiar, it’s because that’s the phrase President Bush used to describe himself. Electing Santorum in virtually every way seems like giving Bush a 3rd term.
Electable – In the south and Midwest, it wouldn’t be a problem. Obama will be much weaker this go-around than in 2008. Whether he can beat Obama remains to be unseen. My sincere hope is that he isn’t given the chance.
Can I vote for him? – I’d probably rather watch Tron on a continuous loop, while wearing Gamecock apparel than vote for Rick Santorum.

Tim Pawlenty – Former two term governor of Minnesota.
Upside – Governor Pawlenty received an A Rating from the CATO Institute regarding his fiscal record as governor. Another upside to Pawlenty is his popularity in his overwhelmingly blue state, the only state in 1984 that Reagan didn’t win.
Downside – Pawlenty supported having a “sensible” Cap N Trade-type policy and even made an ad supporting it. He has come out publically and admitted that his support for the policy was stupid and that he wasn’t aware of all the downsides at the time. He also seems too establishment, as it’s hard to distinguish where he separates from a number of other mainstream republican figures.
Electable – Pawlenty can probably beat Obama, however his problem is that he needs to become much more popular to win the primaries. He currently has low name recognition even in some nearby Midwest states.
Can I vote for him? – Doubtful, the issue being that his CPAC 2011 speech focused on a number of republican foreign policy talking points that I have grown to hate. The speech itself wasn’t necessarily the problem; so much as I’m not going to vote for another neo-con. He’s going to have to show an independent streak and show me that he’s not another republican pentagon robot.

Gary Johnson – Former two term governor of New Mexico and successful businessman.
Upside – As a libertarian, I like Gary Johnson because he too is a libertarian leaning republican. He’s an extreme fiscal hawk and has no sacred cow that he isn’t willing to cut. A number of his views are controversial, but he backs them all up with facts and statistics, showing that he’s very well researched and unafraid to tackle the issues. I also like that he had the foresight to oppose Iraq from the beginning and support Afghanistan initially.
Downside – He has low name recognition and seems to be viewed as sort of “the other libertarian”. He’s going to have to show people his stance on certain social issues doesn’t alienate him from the party’s base, which is likely an uphill battle.
Electable – In the general election, I think he can give Obama a run for his money. He was a very popular governor in a blue state. He is pro-choice, which isn’t necessarily typical of republicans, but he explains that he views it as a state’s rights issue and that he’d sign a ban on partial birth abortions. Unfortunately I think the primary is the limit for Gary Johnson, but I have hope that he’ll run for the open senate seat in NM in 2012.
Can I vote for him? Yes.

Newt Gingrich – Former Speaker of the house 1996-1999 from Georgia.
Upside – High name recognition and lots of experience. Newt is often hailed as one of the smartest people in politics. He is well known for balancing the budget in consecutive years under a democrat president.
Downside – Newt has a past of cheating on wives, and while that may not be a deal breaker in democrat circles, it’s going to be hell for him trying to defend that in the religious south. Newt also supported Cap N Trade and calls Paul Ryan’s Pathway to Prosperity “right-wing social engineering”. Newt also supported the concept of an individual mandate, a key tenant of Obamacare.
Electable – If you’ve read Newt’s downside, you now know that he’s unelectable and can’t make it far in the primary… or the general.
Can I vote for him? No.

I want to give an analogy to how I view our current situation. We as a nation are a car, 2 miles away from driving off a cliff. When the democrats drive they are going 200 mph towards the cliff, while they are drinking champagne and living it up, and obviously calling anyone who dares to question the logic of our current trajectory, a racist. When the republicans take the wheel, they slow the car down to a “reasonable” 120 mph while heading the same direction. The republicans are telling us this is the responsible thing to do and that eventually, if you give them enough time, it’ll be alright. Questioning the republicans trajectory will get you called unpatriotic. Unless I’m sure the person I’m voting for is going to hit the brakes immediately or slow down to pull a U-turn before we drive off a cliff, I can’t vote for them.

I personally take responsibility for Bush’s actions from 2004-2008, Henry Brown’s actions from 2004-2010, and so on and so forth. If I vote for someone who does a terrible job, then I’m responsible for their actions, as I have enabled it. Another example of how I view this is this: I’m against “No Child left Behind” but I supported a president and congressman who passed it, therefore it doesn’t matter that I opposed it, because I enabled it. I’m against the war in Iraq, but almost every politician I’ve voted for is for it, therefore it doesn’t matter that I’m against it, because I’ve enabled the people to keep us there. My way of looking at this, isn’t inspiring or uplifting, but its important that voters as well as the politicians are held responsible for their actions.

In closing, I want to leave you with this quote, it’s one that inspired me to be principled in my actions and views. "The turn will come when we entrust the conduct of our affairs to the men who understand that their first duty as public officials is to divest themselves of the power that they have been given. It will come when Americans, in hundreds of communities throughout the nation, decide to put the man in office who is pledged to enforce the Constitution and restore the Republic. Who will proclaim in a campaign speech: 'I have little interest in streamlining government or in making it more efficient, for I mean to reduce its size. I do not undertake to promote welfare, for I propose to extend freedom. My aim is not to pass laws, but to repeal them. It is not to inaugurate new programs, but to cancel the old ones that do violence to the Constitution, or that have failed in their purpose, or that impose on the people an unwarranted financial burden. I will not attempt to discover whether legislation is “needed” before I have first determined whether it is constitutionally permissible. And if I should later be attacked for neglecting my constituents’ “interests,” I shall reply that I was informed their main interest is liberty and that in that cause I am doing the very best I can.” – Senator Barry Goldwater

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Worthwhile at What Cost?

 “One thing, however, is certain. Although we may never know with complete certainty the identity of the winner of this year's presidential election, the identity of the loser is perfectly clear. It is the nation's confidence in the judge as an impartial guardian of the rule of law.” - Justice John Paul Stevens (Ironically an activist judge)

In politics, just like in life, many individuals' beliefs and views are based on emotions and false preconceived notions instead of facts and statistics. These views can cause problems throughout society, but when these individuals who belief in falsehoods elect like-minded politicians to enact policies that control countries, states, and localities, society as a whole is punished for the voters’ lack of knowledge. To inform the well-intentioned but misguided populace is as great a public service as any.

Disinformation runs rampant in pop culture, whether you get it from liberal Hollywood on television and movies, to biased media outlets, or it could be learned as one of the many falsehoods and false narratives taught in schools (either intentionally by biased textbooks and teachers or unintentionally through lessons which give abbreviated drive-by summaries of complex issues and events).

A portion of the voting populace votes based on single issues or on singular categorical issues. Examples of this would be gays voting for only candidates who support gay marriage; or perhaps some church going folks only voting for candidates who oppose gay marriage and abortion. I don’t want to criticize people for strong beliefs and convictions; I, myself, have many. However, recklessly voting for candidates for such isolated issues is dangerous. What if the gay voter in the first example voted for his pro gay marriage candidate despite the fact that the candidate also supported terrible policies such as an open (unsecured) border, supported the largest tax increase in history, and pushing shady union deals that’ll hurt businesses, eliminate private ballots for union organizing, and burden state budgets with debt.

Perhaps the socially conservative voter elected politicians who are personally socially conservative, but accomplish nothing towards that goal and in fact help double the size of government and double the national debt. Obviously those two voters elected politicians who they agree with on at least one issue that’s important to them, but at what cost? I included the examples of those specific drawbacks because those exact politicians exist… in great numbers. Most democrats support gay marriage and are pro abortion, while most republicans oppose gay marriage and are pro life. However, anyone who casts a straight ticket vote for all democrats or all republicans is voting for a number of politicians who have no say on that issue. Your county council, school board, city council don’t legislate on those issues. Nationally and statewide, there is more that can be done to effect those issues; but generally not to the degree that most voters expect and believe. An issue that was considered under the Clinton Administration was a partial birth abortion ban. That was entirely possible, but an all out ban on abortion is currently impossible. States can legislate how late someone can have an abortion, but also cannot currently ban abortions. If you are a one issue voter primarily based on these issues, its probably high time you learn about other issues.

Proponents of gay marriage view the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) essentially the same way that pro life advocates view the Roe v Wade Supreme Court decision. DOMA was authored by then Congressman Bob Barr R-GA, and signed into law by President Bill Clinton in 1996. The bill federally defines marriage as between a man and a woman and also prevents states from having to legally recognize same-sex marriages having taken place in a state in which same-sex marriages are legal. Bob Barr, since then, has left the republican party and is now a member of the libertarian party, and ran in 2008 as their presidential candidate. In 2009, Bob Barr wrote an op-ed in the Los Angeles Times which said, “I have concluded that DOMA is neither meeting the principles of federalism it was supposed to, nor is its impact limited to federal law. In effect, DOMA's language reflects one-way federalism: It protects only those states that don't want to accept a same-sex marriage granted by another state. Moreover, the heterosexual definition of marriage for purposes of federal laws -- including, immigration, Social Security survivor rights and veteran's benefits -- has become a de facto club used to limit, if not thwart, the ability of a state to choose to recognize same-sex unions. Even more so now than in 1996, I believe we need to reduce federal power over the lives of the citizenry and over the prerogatives of the states. It truly is time to get the federal government out of the marriage business. In law and policy, such decisions should be left to the people themselves.”

Bob Barr, at that point was a fairly mainstream republican, a party of people who like to consider themselves to be advocates for a Constitutionally limited government and strict adherents to the Constitution. However, Barr came to the realization that following the Constitution means personal, civil, and economic liberties that most Americans have come to embrace and enjoy; but also it means the allowance of some things that you may personally dislike. One cannot use the Constitution when practical and when it supports your views and ignore it when it doesn’t. And this is precisely what most people in both political parties do. In 2004, Barr testified in front of Congress in opposition to a proposed Constitutional Amendment banning same-sex marriage. Barr said, “Part of federalism means that states have the right to make bad decisions – even on the issue of who can get married in the state. Resisting the temptation to use the federal government to meddle in state matters is the test of this conservative principle. Indeed, it is the test separating conservative federalists from hard-line social conservatives, willing to sacrifice the Constitution in their understandable anxiety over the sorry state of modern morality.”  The acceptance of this view is something vital to conservatism’s purpose and is also required to be a true advocate for the Constitution.

Now the important question, what would happen if DOMA was repealed or ruled to be unconstitutional? All of the federal benefits given to married couples would then be given to married same-sex couples. Also, in accordance to Article IV Section 1 of the Constitution, commonly known as the Full Faith and Credit Clause, states regardless of their views on the marriage issue would have to recognize same-sex marriages from other states. I’m a stronger advocate for state’s rights than perhaps anyone else I know and I personally don’t care if gays get married, its not an issue near or dear to my heart. I’ve always considered it to be a state’s rights issue. However the reason DOMA should be at least partially repealed, has nothing to do with morality or equality.

The reason DOMA should be repealed is that the legislation is in direct violation of the Full Faith and Credit clause which states, “Such Acts, records and judicial proceedings or copies thereof, so authenticated, shall have the same full faith and credit in every court within the United States and its Territories and Possessions as they have by law or usage in the courts of such State, Territory or Possession from which they are taken.” In simpler terms, states must respect the "public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of every other state." I'd personally prefer a partial repeal of DOMA that would allow the federal government to recognize gay marriage but wouldn't force it upon the states. In a free society there are things that will upset you, but that is the nature of freedom. But going back to a lesson my uncle (and the Rolling Stones) taught me frequently when I was younger, is “You Can’t Always Get What You Want”.

Abortion activists consider the Roe v Wade Supreme Court Decision (1973) to be a landmark triumph for women’s rights. In fact, women’s rights groups appear to be single issue advocates now. Women’s rights used to mean equal pay for equal work, protection for mothers in the work place under the Family Medical Leave Act, the right to vote, and general acceptance in mainstream society. Now, women's rights means pro abortion. It appears feminism and being pro-life are mutually exclusive. If you are a pro life woman and you are viciously attacked in the media, it takes nearly an act of God to get a women’s group to condemn the attacker.

On the other hand, pro-life advocates consider Roe v Wade to be an abomination because of the onslaught of millions of babies that have been terminated since the court decision. However, the issue of morality has nothing to do with why Roe v Wade was potentially the worst supreme court ruling of all time.

Writing for the American Thinker, Michael Filozof makes a great analogy as to why Roe v Wade was a terrible ruling. “Imagine for a moment that you were ticketed for speeding by the state police.  Suppose that you lied to the cop about why you were driving so fast.  Then imagine that a group of special-interest lawyers contacted you and told you they wanted to appeal your ticket to the Supreme Court, and they gave you a legal pseudonym to hide your identity.  Now imagine that the Court ruled that the ancient Romans had no speed limit on the Appian Way, that the Germans have no speed limits on the autobahn, and that speed limits are a violation of the Constitution and must be struck down.” That is essentially the logic, or perhaps more accurately the lack thereof, given by Justice Blackmun who wrote for the majority. Michael Filozof artfully breaks down a number of quotes given by Blackmun perhaps much better than I can; so, I will let him take over for a bit. The bold text is what the court wrote in its decision and the italicized text is Filozof’s analysis.

We forthwith acknowledge ... the emotional nature of the abortion controversy ... one's philosophy, one's experiences, and one's exposure to the raw edges of human existence ... are likely to influence and color one's thinking ... about abortion. [Emphasis mine.]

Do tell!  Sounds more like the Oprah Winfrey Show than a Supreme Court decision.


In addition ... pollution, poverty and racial overtones [emphasis mine] tend to complicate and not simplify the problem. ...


Racial overtones?  What in hell is that supposed to mean?

James Hubert Halford ... [alleged that the Texas law prohibiting abortions] violated ... his own right to practice medicine ... guaranteed by the First, Fourth, Fifth, Ninth[,] and Fourteenth Amendments.

Really?  I'll give $500 cash to the first person who can find the phrase "right to practice medicine" in any of those amendments, or anywhere else in the Constitution.  State governments have complete authority over the licensing and professional standards of physicians, nurses, clinics and, hospitals.

Ancient attitudes [toward abortion].  These are not capable of precise determination ...

OK, so why mention them?


We are told that at the time of the Persian Empire ... criminal abortions were severely punished. We are also told ... that abortion was practiced in Greek times as well as the Roman Era, and that "it was resorted to without scruple."

Precisely what does any of this have to do with the U.S. Constitution, ratified in 1789?

The Ephesian, Soranos, often described as the greatest of the ancient gynecologists, appears to have been generally opposed to Rome's prevailing free-abortion practices ...

This clearly takes the cake as the most ridiculous statement in the entire decision.  It's not as offensive as citing the laws of the British Parliament, though.  British Parliament?  Yep, you read that right:

The English statutory law. England's first criminal abortion statute ... came in 1803 ... Recently, Parliament enacted a new abortion law. This is the Abortion Act of 1967 ... [which] permits a licensed physician to perform an abortion ...

Wait a minute!  Didn't we fight a revolution against these people?  It's been over two centuries since the laws of Parliament mattered on this side of the pond!


It has been argued ... that [antiabortion laws] were the product of Victorian social concern to discourage illicit sexual conduct. Texas [the defendant], however, does not advance this justification in the present case ...

This is insane. Why did Blackmun mention an argument the defendant did not even make?


The Constitution does not explicitly mention any right of privacy ...

Aha!  The truth is revealed!  The mask slips! (As an aside: Yes, that was the gist of the majority’s decision, a right not guaranteed by the Constitution. Courts cannot make up rights to give people, nor can they take rights away. This decision made up a right, and that’s well… not right. And I’m a fan of rights, the Constitution is all about giving people rights, that’s why there is a Bill full of them. This is a textbook example of judicial activism, which ironically is a charge usually directed at people who want to overturn court precedents. Overturning decisions like this should be the goal of anyone opposing judicial activism.)

[But] this right of privacy, whether it be founded in the Fourteenth Amendment's concept of personal liberty ... as we feel [emphasis mine] it is, or ... in the Ninth Amendment's reservation of rights to the people, is broad enough to encompass [abortion].

There you have it.  The Constitution does not mention any right of "privacy," but it's in there -- somewhere.  Doesn't even matter where -- it's "broad enough" to include abortion.  (Justice Rehnquist dissented, observing that paying a physician for a medical procedure is hardly "private" -- it's a commercial transaction that normally falls under the regulatory power of the state.) Roe is so bad it makes other controversial decisions -- like Plessey v. Ferguson or Dred Scott -- look like models of Solomonic wisdom by comparison.  In those cases, the Court was clearly biased, but it at least made an attempt to pay lip service to the Constitution.”

Furthering the atrocity of such an awful supreme court ruling is the fact that the study of Constitutional Law has nothing to do with the Constitution itself. Constitutional Law is based off previous court rulings. Or as Robert Bork put it, “I don't think the Constitution is studied almost anywhere, including law schools. In law schools, what they study is what the court said about the Constitution. They study the opinions. They don't study the Constitution itself.” So when the court makes a decision such as Roe v Wade, it's asinine reasoning will continually damn our country when future courts make stupid rulings based on Roe v Wade’s initial stupidity. Stated differently, terrible rulings create an endless cycle of compounded stupidity.

What would happen if Roe v Wade were to be overturned, you may be asking? The overturning of Roe v Wade would result in the nation’s abortion policy returning to what it was before the decision, the states would decide their abortion policy. Before Roe v Wade, the states decided their abortion policies. Twenty states had abortions (with varying restrictions from only rape victims to on demand) and thirty states had no abortions under any circumstance. If Roe v Wade were to be repealed, the policy would revert to something similar, likely with many more states likely allowing it with their own varying degrees of restrictions, as times have changed.

Talking to a liberal about issues like medical marijuana, prostitution, or gambling (issues liberals wouldn't morally oppose, but aren’t legal on a nationwide level) they may say that the state’s should have the right to choose their policies. They feel this way because they may like those said things, but generally not because they sympathize with the 10th amendment. Those same issues, which conservatives typically don’t like, will draw one of two reactions from conservatives. The conservatives will favor the states’ rights approach, not because they like the issues, but because they do adhere to the 10th amendment and appreciate the Constitution’s dual sovereignty setup OR the conservatives will appreciate the status quo because they don’t mind using the federal government to ban things they don’t like. The two distinct conservative positions is a very accurate representation of the divide in the conservative movement, the Ron Pauls vs. the Mike Huckabees. Statists on both sides of the two issues makes me again prompt the question, abortion (or pro-life) or anti-gay marriage (or pro gay marriage) at what price? Is voting strictly on these issues worth eroding other freedoms? Endless wars? Trillions in debt? Open borders? Crazy judicial appointments who legislate from the bench? Pro-longed economic depressions? That’s a question one needs to ask themselves when being a single issue voter